Transcript Slide 1
Ethnicity in education research on British born ethnic minorities Demetris Hadjigeorgiou City University Ethnicity as Social Capital useful in explaining ethnic minority academic performance from bottom-up Must be sensitive so as not to ‘essentialise’ ethnicity Outline Overview of themes in early literature Recent encouraging trends Ethnicity as Social Capital Avoid essentialising ethnicity Overview of themes in ethnic minority educational research Family background, including class & racial disadvantage – ‘blackness’ School processes, role of teachers Pupil characteristics, language problems & selfperception More positive trends in ethnic minority education Increasing recognition of complexity & diversity in ethnic minority academic performance Achievement by ethnic group GCSE’s in England 2004 5 A*-C GCSE’s in Britain Chinese 1st generation low human & financial capital Indians & Pakistanis 10% more likely to achieve this when control for class Ethnicity %Expected GCSE’s 5 A*-C White British 52 Indian 67 Pakistani 45 Bangladeshi 48 Black Caribbean 36 Black African 43 Chinese 74 First Year Full-Time & Part-Time Students, 1997-98 Ethnicity %18-24 in higher education %18-24 in Great Britain 18-24’s in higher education White 85.2 4.7 2.7 0.7 1.0 1.2 1.4 1.0 0.5 92 2 1.8 0.7 0.4 0.4 0.6 0.9 0.7 48*-52* 51-49 56-44 58-42* 50-50 52-48 48-52 40-60 38*-62 Indian Pakistani Bangladeshi Chinese Asian Other Africans Caribbeans Black Other Ethnicity as Social Capital Ethnicity ‘unfashionable’ in 1970’s and into 1980’s Work in America on ‘ethnicity as social capital’. Combination of cultural capital & social capital (Modood, 2004). Can encourage academic performance through ‘communal effect’ and shielding children from developing similar attitudes to other pupils from disadvantaged backgrounds. Characteristics of ethnicity as Social Capital Family support Embededness in ethnic group Intergenerational closure Family Support Mean scores of Year 13 pupils’ decisions to enter Higher Education Issues affecting decision Black African Black Caribbean Pakistani/ B’deshi Indian Chinese All minority groups White E’ment from family 4 4 4 4 3.8 4 3.4 Always assumed go to HE 4 3.2 4 4.1 3.9 3.9 3.1 Chinese parents UK (Francis & Archer, 2003) Greek-Cypriot parents UK Embededness in Social Group Geographical concentration Many formal and informal networks Lack of sense of Britishness Intergenerational Closure Continued importance of family to many ethnic minorities in the UK Muslim community (Archer 2003) & Chinese community (Francis & Archer 2004) Avoiding essentialism Ethnicity as Social Capital can appear to ‘essentialise’ ethnicity New ethnicities literature Particular problem for minorities such as Asians portrayed as static and traditional Considerable intra-group variation e.g. Pakistanis & Bangladeshis Negotiating between family, community and ‘external influences’ e.g. local youth cultures Use of different capitals in different situations Developing understanding on class & status within communities Questions? [email protected]