Transcript CCBS Talk Chuck Matthews - The Centre for Cross Border Studies

CENTRE FOR CROSS BORDER
STUDIES
JOURNAL LAUNCH 2016
Leading Cross-Border Collaboration in the USMexico Border Region: What is Important?".
TODAY
•
•
•
•
•
•
Collective Impact and Live Well San Diego
• U.S. – Mexico Border Region
• Political/Operational roles at various levels of U.S. and Mexican government
• Status of border collaboration
• Leadership research/survey
• Where are we trying to go
President Elect Trump & cross-border work
COLLECTIVE IMPACT
No single organization has the ability to solve any major social
problem at scale by itself. Collective impact is a powerful
approach to cross-sector collaboration that is achieving
measurable effects on major social issues.
USED FOR MANY COMPLEX
ISSUES
Health
Community Safety
Homelessness
Education
Poverty
COLLECTIVE IMPACT
FRAMEWORK
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Common agenda
Shared measurement
Mutually reinforcing activities
Continuous communication
Backbone Organization
Mark Kramer & John Kania SSIR
2011
COLLECTIVE IMPACT IS…
6
THE COLLABORATION
SPECTRUM
Trust
Compete
Co-exist
Competition
for clients,
resources,
partners,
public
attention.
No
systematic
connectio
n between
agencies.
Communicate
Cooperate
Coordinate
Collaborate
Inter-agency
information
sharing (e.g.
networking).
As needed,
often
informal,
interaction,
on discrete
activities or
projects.
Organizatio
ns
systematical
ly adjust
and align
work with
each other
for greater
outcomes.
Longer term
interaction
based on
shared
mission,
goals;
shared
decisionmakers and
resources.
Integrate
Fully
integrated
programs,
planning,
funding.
Turf
Loose
Tight
CALL TO ACTION
More than
Result in
Lead to
THAT THREE NUMBERS AFFECT US ALL:
BEHAVIORS
DISEASES
PERCENT
No Physical Activity
Poor Diet
Tobacco Use
Cancer
Heart Disease & Stroke
Type 2 Diabetes
Lung Disease
of deaths
in San Diego
1 World Health Organization (WHO). “The Global Strategy on Diet, Physical Activity and Health.”
http://www.who.int/dietphysicalactivity/media/en/gsfs_general.pdf (Accessed September 22, 2011).
2 3Four50, www.3four50.com (Accessed September 22, 2011).
OUR VISION
2009
2011
2014
JULIAN AND THE UNION SCHOOL
DISTRICT
HOW TO DO THIS IN THE BORDER REGION
Shooting for this
We are about here
CALIFORNIA – BAJA CALIFORNIA:
BORDER HEALTH OVERVIEW
US-Mexico
Border Region:
Total Length:
~3,000 km
(1,863 miles)
North/South:
100 km (62 miles)
CA/Baja CA:
322 km (200 miles)
Source:
Pan American Health
Organization
CALIFORNIA – BAJA CALIFORNIA:
BORDER HEALTH OVERVIEW
San Ysidro/TJ Mexico
land point of entry (POE)
is the busiest in the
world.
In 2015 there was
approximately 65.4
million total individual
north- and southbound
crossings.
For reference, LAX
handled over 74.9 million
total passengers in the
same year
Sources: US Department of Transportation, SANDAG
EL PASO, TEXAS AND JUAREZ, MEXICO
Estimated Unauthorized Immigrant Populations
Numerical Size and Share of the Foreign-Born
Population in the United States, 1970-2014
Table 1: Numerical Size and Share of the Foreign-Born Population in the United States, 1970-2014
Source: Migration Policy Institute (MPI) tabulation of data from the U.S. Census Bureau's 2010 and 2014 American Community Surveys (ACS), and 1970-2000 decennial Census.
Different Roles
FEDS/STATES ON POLICY:
MEXICO
MEXICO: REPATRIATION CENTERS
The Migrant Health Program operates at four of the largest
points where U.S. immigration authorities deport Mexican
migrants:
Tijuana (2012)
Nuevo Laredo (2016)
Reynosa (2016)
Matamoros (2014)
BINATIONAL COORDINATION
Population-Based Strategies to Combat
Heart Disease and Stroke
TB AND EPIDEMIOLOGICAL
BINATIONAL COMMUNICATION

Binational communication regarding
infectious diseases of concern
 e.g. Rise of Meningococcal
disease in 2013, Ebola 2014

County of San Diego 2015 Annual
Vector-Borne & Zoonotic Disease
Meetings
 CURE TB program;
http://www.sandiegocounty.gov/hhs
a/programs/phs/cure_tb/
 Program dedicated to continuity of
care for Tb patients & their contacts
who travel between the US &
Mexico
WORKING IN SILOS
More than
Result in
Lead to
BORDER REGION
BEHAVIORS
DISEASES
PERCENT
No Physical Activity
Poor Diet
Tobacco Use
Cancer
Heart Disease & Stroke
Type 2 Diabetes
Lung Disease
of deaths
in San Diego Border
Region
SAN DIEGO BORDER HEALTH
COLLABORATIVE
 Objective: To address health priorities
in the border region, network and share
information with one another
 Goals: Communication, Coordination
and Collaboration
 Meetings: Bi-monthly meetings in San
Diego
 Support: County of San Diego, Public
Health Services & CDPH Office of
Binational Border Health
 Steering Committee provides
oversight
BORDER HEALTH CONSORTIUM OF THE
CALIFORNIAS
 Purpose
 Networking
 Trainings & Capacity building
 Information Dissemination
 Elevating key border health issues to ultimately impact
policy
 4 Work Groups
 HIV, TB, Obesity, Mental Health
 Meeting
 Biannual binational meetings (California & Baja California)
 Support
 County of San Diego, Public Health Services, CDPH
Office of Binational Border Health & US-Mexico Border
Health Commission
 Binational Executive Committee provides oversight
CROSS-BORDER LEADERSHIP RESEARCH
SURVEY
Example Survey Statements
Have a good understanding of the politics of any
issue being considered by the group,
Ensure that cross border collaboration meetings are
held in a neutral location and or equally held on
each side of the border.
Work to diversify the leadership of the steering
committee and the collaborative as a whole
(academia, government…)
Understand the motives for cross-border
collaboration members to be involved in the group
Survey Demographics
Leadership Themes/Categories Restated
1. Communicate to Engage the
Collaborative
2. Steer the Collaborative
3. Understand the Members of the
Collaborative
4. Manage the Collaborative
5. Strategic Relationship Building for
the Collaborative.
Leadership Themes/Categories
“Working at the edge
of our competence
and at the height
of being uncomfortable”
Dr Michael McAphee;
Promising Neighborhoods
USA
PRESIDENT ELECT TRUMP