Transcript Sharon Kaasalainen, RN, PhD

Nursing Care Management of
Dying Persons in Rural
& Urban Areas of Ontario
May 19, 2010
Sharon Kaasalainen, RN, PhD
Project Team Members
Co-Principal Investigators:
Sharon Kaasalainen & Kevin Brazil
(McMaster University)
Co-Investigators:
Denise Marshall, Kathleen Willison & Alan Taniguchi
(McMaster University), Donna Wilson (University of
Alberta), and Lise Fillion (Université Laval)
Background
• Nursing plays a key role in the
coordination and delivery of
palliative care services in rural
and urban settings
• However, rural nurses are faced
with many unique challenges:
– difficulty separating their personal
and professional lives
– working alone in very isolated roles
– having limited access to continuing
educational opportunities
Background
• Nurses need to be equipped with
adequate knowledge and tools for
decision-making to provide quality
palliative care to rural and urban
clients
• MacLeod et al. (2004) found that
there were lower proportions of
rural nurses with advanced
education compared to urban
nurses who were employed in
clinical support roles
Research Purpose
•
To examine the role of community nurses in
the delivery of palliative care services for
rural and urban populations
→compared differences between rural and urban
nurses related to:
(1) current level of involvement and practice patterns
related to palliative care
(2) extent of interdisciplinary collaboration
(3) job satisfaction
(4) self-efficacy in palliative care
(5) barriers and facilitators to providing palliative care
Methods:
Design
• Exploratory cross-sectional survey design that
included both quantitative and open-ended
questions
Screening Question:
Definition of Rural
A community that is located at least 80 kilometers away from
the nearest large (i.e., population of 100,000 or more) city; or
• A community that is considered to be sparsely inhabited (i.e.,
less than 150 persons per square kilometre); or
• A community with a population of 10,000 or less
•
→ Based on this definition, how would you describe yourself?
□
□
□
□
All of my clients live in rural settings
Most of my clients live in rural settings
Some of my clients live in rural settings
None of my clients live in rural settings
*
Methods:
Recruitment & Procedure
• Nurse managers from Victorian Order of Canada
(VON) identified ‘high rural’ and ‘high urban’
nurses
• Mailed a postal survey along with a $5 gift
certificate
• Modified Dillman approach – 2 follow-up
contacts at the end of weeks 2 and 4 (2nd copy)
• Survey took approximately 20 minutes to
complete
Results:
Sample
• 159 community nurses completed the survey;
60% response rate
– 84 rural nurses & 75 urban nurses
• Nurses were primarily Registered Nurses (67%)
over 46 years of age (59%)
• 61% of nurses reported having some palliative
care training, mostly in-house training (36%)
Results:
Practice Patterns
•
Both rural and urban nurses reported
– Spending almost a third of their time providing
palliative care
– Being most active in assessing pain and other
palliative symptoms
– Assisting clients and their families to access and
navigate the health care system
– Supporting clients and their families in making
decisions related to location of death
•
Rural nurses spent significantly more time in
travel than urban nurses (t=2.66, p=0.01)
Results:
Management of Palliative Symptoms
•
•
Nurses reported that pain was the symptom
that they managed most often; followed by
irregular bowel functioning, and fatigue
No significant differences between rural and
urban nurses related to how often they
managed palliative symptoms
•
•
Results:
Interdisciplinary Collaboration &
Job Satisfaction
Urban nurses reported that interdisciplinary
collaboration occurs to a larger extent in their
practice environment than rural nurses
Both urban and rural nurses reported being
– fairly satisfied with their current job
– less satisfied with the extent of their
interdisciplinary collaboration
Results:
Self-Efficacy in Palliative Care
•
Rural nurses reported being significantly more
confident in their ability to provide palliative
care than urban nurses (t=1.95, p<0.05)
– Rural nurses were more confident in their ability to:
• communicate with others related to palliative care
issues (t=2.16, p=0.03), and
• engage in patient management activities related to
palliative care (t=2.86, p=0.01) compared to urban
nurses
Results: Barriers to Providing
Optimal Palliative Care
Rural
Urban
• Travel distance & time
• Bad weather conditions
• MDs lack training in
palliative care
• No home visits from MD
• Nursing shortage
• Poor accessibility to
equipments, medications &
services
• Isolation of client at home
• Fewer relationships
between patients and the
care providers because of
larger amount of clients to
care for
• Less time spent with each
client
• Lack of family doctors
• Lack of transportation
• Inadequate knowledge base
Results: Facilitators to Providing
Optimal Palliative Care
Rural
• Good support from family,
friends & neighbours
• Close-knit social network
• Physicians who make house
calls
• Palliative care volunteers
• Local Community Care
Access Center (CCAC)
Urban
• More services available &
closer to them
• better continuity of care
• Access to experts in
palliative care
Conclusions
• Rural and urban nurses had similar roles in palliative
care but rural nurses spent more time in travel and
were more confident in their ability to provide
palliative care
• Study results may help develop strategies to better
equip nurses with the knowledge, tools, and skill sets
that they need in order to provide specialized and
quality palliative care in an informed and competent
manner
Next Steps
Phase 2
• Complete qualitative study using grounded theory
approach to explore how nurses manage palliative
care clients in rural and remote settings at a more
indepth level
Thank you
Sharon Kaasalainen
[email protected]