Transcript Hypothesis B - UBC Psychology`s Research Labs

Psychology 305A:
Theories of Personality
Lecture 6
Psychology 305
1
1
The Biological Perspective
1. What are the basic principles of evolutionary theory?
2. How have the basic principles of evolutionary theory
been adapted to the study of personality?
3. What hypotheses has the evolutionary approach
generated regarding (a) altruism, (b) sex differences in
the desire for sexual variety, and (c) sex differences in
jealousy?
Psychology 305
2
2
By the end of today’s class, you should be able to:
1. describe natural selection, sexual selection, intrasexual
selection, and intersexual selection.
2. generate examples of distinct forms of selection.
3. define the term “inclusive fitness.”
4. review research supporting evolutionary hypotheses
related to altruism.
3
3
5. define the terms “reproductive capacity” and “minimal
parental investment.”
6. review research supporting evolutionary hypotheses
related to sex differences in the desire for sexual
variety.
4
4
What are the basic principles of evolutionary theory?
• According to Darwin’s theory of evolution, across
successive generations of a species, organisms develop
characteristics that enhance their ability to survive and
reproduce (i.e., adaptations).
• Darwin maintained that there are two processes through
which organisms develop these characteristics:
Psychology 305
5
5
1. Natural selection
 A process through which organisms develop
characteristics that enhance their ability to survive.
 Organisms that possess characteristics that enhance
their ability to survive are more likely to live to
reproductive age and to pass these characteristics on to
the next generation.
Psychology 305
6
6
 Offspring that inherit these characteristics, in turn, are
more likely to live to reproductive age and to pass the
characteristics on to yet the next generation.
 Through this process, characteristics that enhance the
organism’s ability to survive increase in frequency
across successive generations of the species until
they characterize virtually all members of the species.
Psychology 305
7
7
 Example: The preference for sweet, fatty, and salty
foods among humans.
8
2. Sexual selection
 A process through which organisms develop
characteristics that enhance their ability to reproduce.
 Darwin maintained that there are 2 mechanisms through
which sexual selection occurs:
Psychology 305
9
9
(a) Intrasexual selection
 Occurs when same sex organisms compete for the
sexual interest of the opposite sex.
 Organisms that possess characteristics that enable
them to “win” the sexual interest of the opposite sex are
more likely to mate and to pass these characteristics on
to the next generation.
Psychology 305
10
10
 Offspring that inherit these characteristics, in turn, are
more likely to mate and to pass the characteristics on
to yet the next generation.
 Through this process, the characteristics that enabled
the victors to win increase in frequency across
successive generations of the species until they
characterize virtually all members of that sex of the
species.
Psychology 305
11
11
 Example: The Ariel Hover Display of the male Bronzed
Cowbird.
12
(b) Intersexual selection
 Occurs when organisms of one sex prefer to mate with
organisms of the opposite sex that possess specific,
desirable characteristics.
 Organisms that possess characteristics that are
desirable to the opposite sex are more likely to mate and
to pass these characteristics on to the next generation.
Psychology 305
13
13
 Offspring that inherit these characteristics, in turn, are
more likely to mate and to pass the characteristics on
to yet the next generation.
 Through this process, characteristics that are desirable
to the opposite sex increase in frequency across
successive generations of the species until they
characterize virtually all members of that sex of the
species.
Psychology 305
14
14
 Example: The brilliant plumage of the male peacock.
15
How have the basic principles of evolutionary theory
been adapted to the study of personality?
• Evolutionary psychologists believe that our basic
psychological processes are the product of natural
selection and sexual selection.
• Our psychological processes are seen as adaptations to
the survival and reproductive challenges faced by our
ancestors.
Psychology 305
16
16
What hypotheses has the evolutionary approach
generated regarding altruism?
• Altruism: Refers to a desire to help others, even at
the risk of one’s own well-being.
• Theory of inclusive fitness: Organisms are motivated to
enhance their own survival and reproductive potential,
as well as the survival and reproductive potential of
those who are genetically similar to them.
Psychology 305
17
17
• On the basis of this theory, evolutionary psychologists
generated two hypotheses regarding altruism.
 Hypothesis A: Helping behaviour increases as the
degree of genetic overlap increases between the helper
and the recipient.
 Hypothesis B: Helping behaviour increases as the
reproductive potential of one’s kin member (i.e., relative)
increases.
Psychology 305
18
18
• Burnstein et al. (1994) tested both hypotheses in the
U.S. and Japan.
 Asked participants to imagine that people were
asleep in a rapidly burning building.
 Told participants they could only rescue one person.
 Asked participants to indicate who they would be
most willing to save.
Psychology 305
19
19
 Results consistent with
Hypothesis A.


Tendency
to Help


.50
Highly Related
Psychology 305
20
.25
.125
Degree of
Genetic Overlap
.00
Not Related
20
 Resource replete;
results consistent with
Hypothesis B.


Tendency
to Help



1
10
18
45
75
Age of Kin (Years)
Psychology 305
21
21
 Resource scarce; results
consistent with
Hypothesis B.


Tendency
to Help



1
Psychology 305
10
18
Age of Kin (Years)
22
45
75
22
 Results consistent with
Hypothesis B.

Tendency
to Help


Healthy


Sick

.50
Highly Related
Psychology 305
23
.25
Degree of
Genetic Overlap
.125
Not Highly Related
23
What hypotheses has the evolutionary approach generated
regarding sex differences in the desire for sexual variety?
• Females and males differ in their reproductive capacity
and the minimal parental investment that is required to
produce an offspring.
Psychology 305
24
24
• Reproductive capacity: Males > Females
 Females: Can bear 8 – 12 offspring across the lifespan.
 Males: Can bear an almost unlimited number of
offspring across the lifespan (maximum recorded to
date: 900).
Psychology 305
25
25
• Minimal parental investment: Females > Males
 Females: Carry and nourish fetus for 9 months; nurse
child after birth; during lactation, ovulation is suppressed.
 Males: Engage in copulation.
Psychology 305
26
26
• Given sex differences in reproductive capacity and
minimal parental investment, evolutionary psychologists
maintain that males and females have developed different
strategies to maximize their reproductive potential.
Psychology 305
27
27
• Males: Employ strategies that enable them to copulate
with as many females as possible.
• Females: Employ strategies that restrict copulation to
males who are able to provide care and resources for
the offspring.
Psychology 305
28
28
• Following from these strategies, evolutionary
psychologists have generated 2 interrelated hypotheses
regarding sex differences in the desire for sexual variety:
 Hypothesis A: Males are less discriminating in their
selection of sexual partners than females.
 Hypothesis B: Males are inclined to seek more sexual
partners than females.
Psychology 305
29
29
• Studies that have tested these hypotheses include:
 Clark and Hatfield (1984)
 Had confederates approach students of the opposite sex
on campus.
 After saying “Hi, I’ve been noticing you around campus
lately and I find you very attractive,” the confederates
asked the students 1 of 3 questions:
Psychology 305
30
30
Percent Who Agreed
Male
Female
“Would you go out on a date
with me tonight?”
50
55
“Would you go back to my
apartment with me tonight?”
69
6
“Would you have sex with me
tonight?”
75
0
Psychology 305
31
31
 These results are consistent with Hypothesis A.
 Buss and Schmitt (1993)
 Asked unmarried participants how many sex partners
they would like to have through to the end of their lives.
Psychology 305
32
32
 Results consistent with
Hypothesis B.
20
Males
15

Desired
Number
10
of
Partners
5

0 
Psychology 305






Females



1
2
33

3


4
5
Time (Years)



10
20
Life
33
 In a large-scale cross-cultural investigation, Schmitt et al.
(2003) found similar sex differences across 52 nations
(e.g., Argentina, Austria, Canada, Chile, Croatia, Greece,
Israel, Italy, Japan, Lebanon, Slovakia, Zimbabwe, US).
Psychology 305
34
34
What hypotheses has the evolutionary approach generated
regarding sex differences in jealousy?
• Evolutionary psychologists maintain that, once a mate
has been selected with whom to copulate, males and
females encounter different adaptive problems.
Psychology 305
35
35
 Females: Must ensure that their mates do not withdraw
care and resources, as this would jeopardize the
survival of offspring.
 Males: Must ensure that their mates do not copulate
with other males, as this would result in uncertainty
regarding the paternity of offspring.
Psychology 305
36
36
• Following from these adaptive problems, evolutionary
psychologists have generated 2 interrelated hypotheses
regarding sex differences in jealousy:
 Hypothesis A: Females are more likely than males to
become jealous in response to cues that suggest
emotional infidelity.
 Hypothesis B: Males are more likely than females to
become jealous in response to cues that suggest
sexual infidelity.
Psychology 305
37
37
The Biological Perspective
1. What are the basic principles of evolutionary theory?
2. How have the basic principles of evolutionary theory
been adapted to the study of personality?
3. What hypotheses has the evolutionary approach
generated regarding (a) altruism, (b) sex differences in
the desire for sexual variety, and (c) sex differences in
jealousy?
Psychology 305
38
38