Transcript Document
Antibody and Vaccine
production in Plants
Plant biopharming of monoclonal
antibodies
Virus Research 111 (2005) 93–100
Kisung Ko, Hilary Koprowski
Plant-produced vaccines: promise and
reality
Edward P Rybicki
PLANT-DERIVED BIOMEDICALS FOR TREATMENT OF INFECTIOUS DISEASES
DISEASES
VACCINES
PLANT
Respiratory
Syncytial
Hepatitis B
Tobacco
Lettuce
HIV
Spinach
Rabies
Anthrax
Diphtheria
Spinach
Tobacco
Tobacco
Tomato
Tobacco
SARS
Smallpox
ANTIBODY
PLANT
Tobacco
Tobacco
Tomato
Tobacco
Tomato
PLANT-DERIVED BIOMEDICALS FOR TREATMENT OF CANCER
HUMAN DISEASES
VACCINES
ANTIBODY
Colorectal Cancer
Epithelial Tumors
(EGF receptor)
Antibodies
Magic bullets:
Therapeutic – inhibit target involved in
disease progression
Diagnostic
Prevention of disease
Cause cytotoxic death of target cells
Act as carriers for radioisotopes, toxins and
drugs to site of disease
Anti-rabies virus mAb
After exposure treated with Ab
Used to be made in horses
First mAb made in transgenic plants
4 genes – 2 H, 2 L
Transgenic plant for each one and
crossing plants
Later used single binary vector with
two promoters
Full-size monoclonal antibodies recently
produced in transgenic plants
Abs expressed in
transgenic plants
Constant
domains
Variable Light chain
Variable Heavy chain
Recombinant hinge region
Functional Abs
Need to be properly folded and assembled
Need disulfide bond formation and
glycosylation
Down stream processing:
Purification of Ab mostly with Protein A
or G
Glycosylation is different in plants
β 1,2 Xylose and α 1,3 fucose
Retain in ER, only mannose is attached
–Shorter half-life of Ab
Glycosylation of Ab
Full-size Ab
Large single-chain Ab
Camelid heavy-chain Ab
Minibodies and Fab fragments don’t get glycosylated
Glycosylation in Golgi
Antibodies: a compelling success story
high specificity: in vitro and in vivo diagnostics
low toxicity: therapeutic applications
high drug approval rates (24 approved mAbs)
major products in biotechnology (~240 in clinical
trials)
inherently stable human proteins
injectable, topical and oral applications
applicable for chronic conditions
potential long-lasting benefits
Production Costs for Antibodies
Production costs
cost in $ /gram
hybridomas
1000
transgenic animals
transgenic plants
100
10
Source: Daniell et al. (2001) TIPS 6, 219-226
E. coli & yeast
Tr. animals and
animal cells
Transgenic
plants
Comparison of Mammalian and Plant-produced
Antibodies
peptide sequence: identical
correct cleavage of Ig-derived signal peptides
kinetics & affinity: identical
stability in seeds > 30 months
antibody types: plant system more versatile (sIgA)
post-translational processing: different
core glycan identical, terminal sugar different plus xylose & fucose
antigenicity & clearance: apparently identical (shorter half-life)
Vaccines
Hepatitis B virus surface antigen
HBsAg
Norwalk virus capsid
Vibrio cholerae enterotoxin subunit
Animal vaccines
– Mink enteritis virus - MEV
– Rabbit haemorrhagic disease virus RHDV
– Foot and mouth disease virus - FMDV
Oral vaccines
First thought edible vaccines good idea
– Banana a day
Oral vaccination
– Might elicit antigenic tolerance
– ProdiGene - Got contamination of maize
and soybean harvest in 2002 with
transmissible gastroenteritis virus TGEV
Past and Future of PMPs
Plant produced Vaccines
HPV L1 – forms VLPs – can protect
Measles virus haemagglutinin
HBsAg
Porcine TGEV
Tetanus toxin
Vacinia virus B5
Allergy vaccines
HPV
HIV gp41
Newcastle disease virus
Rotavirus VP7
Cancer Vaccines
LSBC - Large Scale Biology Crop
Individually tailored single chain
variable region Ab fragments from
patients with Non-Hodgkin lymphomas
Colorectal cancer antigen
Cervical Cancer – HPV E7
Vaccines against
biothreat agents
Biodefence
– Anthrax
– Plague
– Ricin
– Haemorrhagic fever
PMP Development - Highlights
Series of plant-derived vaccines from Arizona State University have
completed clinical trials
Prodigene has trialled two plant-derived vaccines
LSBC pipeline of cancer vaccines prior to insolvency
Guardian Bioscience coccidiosis vaccine, CFIA phase II ongoing
Fraunhofer CMB, rabies vaccine trialled in humans
DowAgro Newcastle disease vaccine, approved Feb 2006
Heberbiovac (Cuba) approved antibody for HepB vaccine
purification
Current Challenges in Molecular Farming
yield of recombinant proteins
real quantitative comparison (TSP vs pg/cell/24h)
protein stability (proteases)
post-translational modification(s)
backcrossing in elite lines
extraction and downstream processing
QA, QC and substantial equivalence
clinical trials & regulatory approval
Regulatory Challenges for PMP
loci of transgene insertion
expression properties and levels, including PTM
effects of the transgene on the expression of flanking
endogenous genes
master line banking to ensure product consistency
contamination with animal excreta, pesticides,
organic fertiliser
procedures for detection and removal of weeds and pests
cultivation variables
Roadmap Plants for the Future
Plant production platforms
Health food and
quality
- Amino acids
- Oil
- Starch
Efficient
agriculture
- Bt technology
- Herbicide
resistance
1997
2005
Plant protection
-
Viruses
Nematodes
Fungi
Insects
2015
-
Vitamines
Fatty acids
Enzymes
Bio-polymers
Pigments
Pharmaceutical products
Fibers
Stress resistance
- Cold
- Drought
- Salinization
2025