Transcript Document

Unacceptable
Acceptable
General
Procedure
Failed to follow
directions, did not
work with/as a group,
late, did not use web
resources
Followed some
directions, worked
some as a group,
used some web
resources
Target
Followed directions,
worked with team,
completed on time,
used all web resources
recommended/
available
Argument/Case
No defined position,
argument incoherent,
ineffective
Position generally
understood, made
a decent argument
Clearly defined
position, articulated
well
Structure
Data
Coherent, concise
No structure to
Ideas generally
argument or case,
outlined, made some ideas, clearly put a lot
of thought into points
no valid points made good points
and flow of argument
No facts/data to
strengthen argument/
inaccuracy of facts,
did not cite sources
Use of some facts/
data, information
mostly accurate,
somewhat relevant,
cited some sources
Use of many facts/
data, information
accurate and
relevant to position,
cited all sources