Transcript Dr Gardner

Claiming the credit: international
organizations, foreign investors, and
developmental states
Leigh A Gardner
Economic History Department
London School of Economics
Current performance in a long-run
perspective
• This not the first growth boom in Africa’s economic
history
• Previous period of growth from 1940s-1970s also
characterized by optimism about future prospects
• Longer-term performance comprised of periods of
growth followed by reversals, with limited gains in per
capita income.
Global comparisons
• Other world regions have experienced same
boom-and-bust pattern for long periods
• Transition to modern (sustained) economic
growth is the exception rather than the rule
• Key to transition is institutional change
FIGURE 4: Real GDP per capita in four European countries,
1270-1870 (1990 international dollars, log scale)
6,400
3,200
1,600
800
400
1270
1284
1298
1312
1326
1340
1354
1368
1382
1396
1410
1424
1438
1452
1466
1480
1494
1508
1522
1536
1550
1564
1578
1592
1606
1620
1634
1648
1662
1676
1690
1704
1718
1732
1746
1760
1774
1788
1802
1816
1830
1844
1858
200
Britain
Holland
Italy
Spain
Source: Malanima (2011); Álvarez-Nogal and Prados de la Escosura (2012);
Broadberry, Campbell, van Leeuwen and van Zanden (2012).
4
Lesson from European transition
• 2 key institutional changes paved the way for
modern economic growth:
– Constraint on the executive
– Expansion of state capacity
• Problem? Institutional change takes time.
Why is institutional change important?
• Growth reversals are less severe in countries
with better institutions
– The reversal of fortune between South Asia and
SSA was linked to the duration and severity of the
reversal following the 1970s oil crises
• Institutional change facilitates structural
change and diversification
Remaining challenges in Africa
• Democratization and governance have
improved since the 1990s
• State capacity, measured in terms of tax
revenue collected, has shown little
improvement in many countries
Elusive factor – sustained growth
What gave rise to modern economic growth is the
question that prompted the birth of economic
history in the first place, and it remains as relevant
today as it was in the late nineteenth century.
- Kevin O’Rourke, Irish Economy Blog
Question for Africa is not who can claim credit for
current boom, but how to generate institutional
change necessary for transition to modern
economic growth.