Transcript - Connect Innovate UK

Evaluation criteria
Scope
• Pre-commercial bioenergy projects that
demonstrate collaboration, innovation and
industry focus.
• Full-scale, similar (prototypical) system
demonstrated in relevant environment or
• Actual system completed and qualified through
test and demonstration
Examples
• New demonstrations of innovative bioenergy conversion
technologies, including analysis and evaluation of results,
plus strategies (and proposals) for optimisation.
• Innovative technological modifications of existing
demonstration plants that subsequently enable operations
which differ significantly from past operations of that plant.
This can include engineering tasks in planning and design as
well as technical installations and their operation (start-up).
Technological adaptations and test operations are eligible
for funding insofar as they are reasonable and caused by the
project.
7 Value Chains
•
1) Synthetic liquid fuels and/or hydrocarbons and blending
components via gasification
2) Bio-methane and other synthetic gaseous fuels from biomass via
gasification
3) High-efficiency heat and power generation via gasification of
biomass
4) Bioenergy carriers via other thermochemical processes (e.g.
pyrolysis, torrefaction)
5) Ethanol and higher alcohols from ligno-cellulosic feedstock via
fermentation
6) Renewable hydrocarbons through biological and/or chemical
synthesis from biomass containing carbohydrates
7) Bioenergy carriers from CO2 and sunlight through microorganismbased production and upgrading into fuels and valuable bio-products
Technology Readiness Level
5
BESTF 2 will not support
• Failed or ailing projects, i.e. projects that have
already failed to meet existing objectives or that
have proved unsatisfactory in operation;
• On-going work, or work that will be on-going before
the call is fully implemented;
• Costs of official permissions/ or licenses for
operation including the preparation for approval
procedures.
Key Performance Indicators
• Set by the Strategic Energies Technologies
Information System in 2011
• Created by working group using consultation e.g.
stakeholder workshops and analysis
• Purpose is to help monitor and review progress of
EIBI
• http://setis.ec.europa.eu/implementation/eii/eiikey-performance-indicators/KPIs_EIBI/view
3 Overarching KPIs
• Price before taxes of bioenergy products in
2020 (€/MWh) per value chain at point of
sale to customer
• GHG savings compared to fossil equivalents
• Total bioenergy produced by EIBI projects
(TWh/year)
Price before taxes of bioenergy products
in 2020 (€/MWh) per value chain at
point of sale to customer
Targets for primary products
1.
2.
3.
4.
Synthetic liquid fuels by gasification: < 80 €/MWh
Biomethane (<= price as for natural gas) and other synthetic gaseous
fuels by gasification: (depends on product, e.g. – DME <60 €/MWh),
Hydrogen compressed (<80 €/MWh ), CO (<30 €/MWh )
High efficiency heat and power by thermochemical conversion: <
75€/MWh (el), <35 €/MWh (heat)
Intermediate bioenergy carriers: pyrolysis oil <50 €/MWh (to
compete with Heavy Fuel Oil , but this depends on actual product),
torrefied product <30 €/MWh
Price before taxes of bioenergy products
in 2020 (€/MWh) per value chain at
point of sale to customer
5. Ethanol and higher alcohols from ligno-cellulosic
biomass by biological processes: <80 €/MWh (Note:
equates to <0,50 €/litre)
6. Hydrocarbons by biological processes and/or chemical
synthesis: < 80 €/MWh
7. Bioenergy carriers by micro-organisms (algae) from CO2
and sunlight: < 70€/MWh for lipids (to be competitive
with vegetable oils and animal fats). Biomethane (<=
price as for natural gas)
GHG savings compared to fossil
equivalents
Targets:
• Biofuels – GHG savings from use of
biofuels and bioliquids shall be at least
60%.
• Other – the same until any future
agreed methodology is adopted.
Total bioenergy produced by EIBI
projects (TWh/year)
• 2016: Intermediate step from 2012 to 2020
reflecting maturity of first phase of demonstration
projects (one fourth of 2020 target)
• 2020: 35 TWh total energy from EIBI projects
contribute to the 20% renewables target; 17.5
TWh of the 10 % renewable energy target for
transportation will be reached by advanced
biofuels. The 17.5 TWh corresponds to 2 GW
installed capacity.
Price and System Boundary
• For the purpose of setting targets for the KPIs a
cost base of 2010 has been assumed: $ 86 per
barrel (IEA 2010).
• System boundary
– Starting point: plant gate
– End point: finished product (e.g. electricity or heat fed
into a grid) or semi-finished product (e.g. bio-oil for
further refining) is the end point.
Price of bioenergy products (e.g. €/litre, €/MWh)
per Value Chain at point of sale to customer 2020
Value Chain
Ethanol
1
Diesel
<€0,75/litre
2
30 €/MWh
3
4
5
Biomethane
Heat
Electricity
30 €/MWh
70 €/MWh
<30 €/MWh
<70 €/MWh
<30 €/MWh
<70 €/MWh
Other
<€50/MWh *
<€30/MWh **
<€0.50/litre
6
<€0.75/litre
7
<€0,70/litre
* Pyrolysis oil, ** Torrefied Product
Proposal Evaluation
Scoring is made by a panel of independent experts at final stage:
•
Fit to call
•
Innovation
•
Quality of the technological concept
•
Sustainability
•
Project set-up and implementation planning
•
Risk analysis
•
EU dimension and industrial leadership
•
Implementation potential
•
Future market deployment of the concept
•
Strong business case
•
Impact, dissemination and exploitation plan and knowledge sharing
•
Societal issues:
Fit to call
• Proposal complete and complies with
specifications of BESTF and other relevant
programmes
• Min. 70% of the bio-products produced are
bioenergy, based on energy content of
products
• Incentive effect of the BESTF Grant
Innovation
Addresses innovative technologies
and processes or novel integration of
known technologies and processes
to be established at the appropriate
scale
Quality of the technological concept
• Techno-economic and environmental
analysis of the value chain
• Energy efficiency to primary end product
• Feedstock availability and logistics
• Quality specification of production, logistics
and end user requirements
Sustainability
Renewable Energy Directive and Greenhouse
Gas Emission targets/regulations met, based
on LCA and RED calculation
Project set-up and implementation planning
• Quality of the consortium
–
–
–
–
adequate competence, management experience and know-how,
adequate industrial and scientific competence,
financial strength,
operational capacity to carry out the project
• Realistic timeline of the project and deployment
• Work plan with clear tasks, deliverables and
milestones, methodology including LCA analysis,
efforts
• Progress monitoring /control
Risk analysis
• Identification and assessment
• Management, incl. Quality
Assurance Plan
EU dimension and industrial leadership
• Consortium requirements met
• Can the project contribute to achieving
the relevant KPI?
Implementation potential
• Operation of demo plant planned
for 2018?
• Learning curve for further
development?
Future market deployment of the concept
• Realistic feedstock and market
potential for industrial scale described
and volume potential of corresponding
bioenergy market outlined
• Economic performance of the
commercial concept
Strong business case
• Clear identification of target groups and
added value for consumers
• Adequate analysis of competition
• Adequate analysis of market potential
• Adequate marketing plan
• Adequate cost-benefit ratio of the concept
Impact, dissemination and exploitation plan
and knowledge sharing
• Contribution to call goals and to
European knowledge, incl.
dissemination plan
• Benefits to EU public
• Detailed exploitation plan incl. IPR
issues
Societal issues
• Employment
• Health and safety
• Training
• Rural development
• Public acceptance
Further Information
•
www.bestf.net
•
_connect Bioenergy
Businesses: Ewa Bloch
•
National Contact Point, Technology Strategy Board – TSB
•
Postal address: North Star House, North Star Avenue, Swindon, SN2
1UH, UK
•
Phone: +44 (0) 777 137 2409; email: [email protected]
Academics: Dr Colin Miles (BBSRC)
•
Phone: +44 1793 413359
•
e-mail: [email protected]