Transcript 13 Putnam & Campbell

Religion in America:
Putnam & Campbell
“You can’t just translate the Mass from
one language to another—you have to
add a cultural component.”
(Sociology 156)
3 Social Cleavages
• Gender
– How have religious groups reacted to changing gender norms?
– Religious people have made little resistance to rapidly changing social
roles for women
• Social class
– What has been the reaction to rapidly widening gaps between social
classes?
– Religious people have made little resistance here
• Race & Ethnicity (Friday)
– What is the role of religion in shaping, maintaining, and/or
transforming racial & ethnic identity?
• Focus on behavior of religious individuals, not religious
organizations (233)
• Religion has followed broader social trends on gender & class, but
seems fundamentally involved in the construction of ethnic identity
2
Our Savior Lutheran Church
(Houston)
•
•
Emphasis on German heritage (181)
Strong denominational identity (182)
– Closed communion
•
•
•
•
•
•
Ornate, formal worship space (184)
Biblically literalist (182)
Theologically-focused, conservative approach (184)
Strongly pro-life (186)
Strongly conservative gender roles
Female Bible study leader forbidden from college by father (189)
– Women prohibited from voting in assemblies (191)
– Pastor White: “When God created mankind, at the core of that creation was gender.” (190)
•
Strong sense of persecution, views modern culture as hostile, corrupting (186)
– “Pastor White describes the modern era as the ‘eleventh hour’ for America, and believes the
nation may soon face the judgment of God if Christians fail to influence its current cultural
trajectory.” (194)
3
Bethel African Methodist Episcopalian
Church (Baltimore)
•
•
•
•
•
In the ghetto of downtown Baltimore (195)
Entirely black membership, drawn mostly from wealthier parts of town & suburbs
in the County (196)
Long involvement in anti-slavery, civil rights (196)
A community hub for Baltimore’s black elite (198)
Emotive, expressive worship style
– Aesthetics as an element of religious experience
•
Church centered on charismatic leader, Dr. Reid (201)
– Described as “educated,” “well-read,” “inspiring,” “visionary,” “legit” (202)
•
•
•
Wife, Marlaa’ Reid, has own leadership role, but publically stands behind Dr. Reid,
in supportive role (203)
Reid an influential player in Baltimore politics (208)
Intensely involved in causes of social justice, but indirectly
– Rehab programs (206)
– Congregants donate significant amounts of money, but agencies composed almost wholly of
non-members (207)
4
St. Pius V Catholic Church
(Chicago)
• Neighborhood populated by Mexican immigrants, but
immigrants come from across the city (213)
• Bilingual priest, Father Charles Dahm (Padre Carlos) helps
parishioners access social welfare institutions, interfaces w/
bureaucracies & authorities (213)
• Dahm considers himself a “social activist” who works to
empower the immigrant community
• “Here the music and preaching always refer to Latin culture
and things that are familiar. You can’t just translate the
Mass from one language to another—you have to add a
cultural component.” (216)
• A point of access to American culture & where Chicago’s
Mexican immigrant community is centered (219)
5
St. Frances of Rome
(Chicago suburb)
• Divided between older, declining white
Catholic population & growing, vital
immigrants (220)
• Tension & white flight (226)
• Demographic shift & resentment (228)
6
Religion & Gender
• At all levels of society, women tend strongly to
be more religious than men (233)
• Religious women enter the workforce at about
the same rate as non-religious
– True across religious traditions
• Religious beliefs & institutions have little to no
negative impact on the rate at which women
enter the workforce (237-238)
7
Fig. 8.1
8
Fig. 8.2
9
Religion & Gender
• The persistent 5-10% difference in attitudes “reflects
the persistence of traditional gender norms among a
minority of religious conservatives, and may well be
enduring.
– But to over emphasize this gap between religious and
nonreligious American women in their attitudes toward
gender would be to overlook the sweeping
transformations in gender norms shared by religious and
nonreligious Americans [...] over the last generation.” (239)
• Contemporary religious Americans less traditional than secular
counterparts a generation before
• Compare to widening differences in attitude toward sexual
morality between religious and nonreligious Americans
10
Religion & Gender
• Though religion has not appeared to significantly restrict women’s
participation in the workforce, women account for far less than 50%
of clergy
– All churches: 6% is 2006-07, up from 8% in 1999
• Self-described liberal congregations 37% (up from 23%)
• Self-described moderate: 8%
• Self-described conservative: 5% (243)
• Between 1986 General Social Survey & 2006 Faith Matters survey,
evidence suggests roughly 15-20% increase in support of female
clergy in every religious tradition
– Biggest gains in conservative traditions (evangelicals, Catholics, Black
Protestants)
• Generational shift: opposition concentrated among older people,
younger generation overwhelmingly favor female clergy (242-243)
11
• Fig. 8.3
12
Religion & Gender
• By 2006, majorities of every Christian religious
tradition except for Mormons favor female clergy
– 91% male Black Protestants support female clergy vs.
82% female
– 52% male Mormons support female lay priests vs.
10% female
• Evangelicals are slightly more skeptical than
others of women in religious leadership, the
difference “is almost entirely concentrated
among a minority of extremely fundamentalist
minority of evangelicals. (244-245)
13
Fig. 8.4
14
Economic Inequality
Fig. 8.5
15
Economic Inequality
• While barriers of race & gender have been
lowered, class inequality has risen to historic
heights across the last 30 years
• Class segregation has increased:
– Classes more segregated spatially than before
– Between 1940 & 1960, people married
increasingly across class lines (proxied by
education levels) but the trend has since reversed
– Fraternal and civic organizations no longer bring
different classes into conflict (247-249)
16
Economic Inequality
• While religious people & institutions have been on all
sides of American social and political movements,
historically, progressive social & political movements in
America have had religious roots
– First & Second Great Awakenings, Abolitionism, Populist
movement & William Jennings Bryan, Social Gospel
• Post-1920s, religion becomes associated with
conservatism, which rises with anticommunism and
climaxes after the “seismic shock” of the Sixties with
the birth of the Religious Right (247- 252)
17
What role does religion now play in
terms of class?
• Since the late 1970s, among college educated whites 45 & younger
(controlling for race & generation), church attendance has fallen
from 30% to 27%
– By contrast, among those without college, it has fallen from 30-32% to
about 20-22%
• However, religiosity, measured by church attendance, is correlated
with more downward-bridging class relationships than is found
among secular Americans (253-254)
– esp. among evangelicals
– Civil society
• Religiosity for white Americans correlated w/conservative views on
gov’t aid to poor, though this correlation is far weaker than with
views on sexual morality (256)
18
Fig. 8.6
19
Fig. 8.7
20