Transcript Do multicultural experiences foster creativity?

Psychology 307:
Cultural Psychology
Lecture 22
1
Announcement
Will and Kate will extend their upcoming office hours for
students who are interested in reviewing their exam:
Kate (A-Q): Monday, April 11th, 12:00-2:00
Will (R-Z): Thursday, Aril 7th, 12:00-2:00.
Kate’s office hour will be cancelled on Monday, April 18th.
2
Acculturation
1. What are acculturation strategies and how are they
measured? (continued)
2. What are the psychological correlates of distinct
acculturation strategies?
3. Do multicultural experiences foster creativity?
3
By the end of today’s class, you should be able to:
1. describe distinct acculturation strategies and their
relations to psychological adjustment.
2. explain how multicultural experiences foster creativity.
4
What are acculturation strategies and how are they
measured? (continued)
● Recent research has provided support for the
distinction between alternation and fusion, suggesting
that there are at least five acculturation strategies that
people may use—assimilation, separation, alternation,
fusion, and marginalization.
● Acculturative strategies are typically measured using
self-report questionnaires:
5
The Vancouver Index of Acculturation
(Ryder et al., 2000)
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
I often participate in my heritage cultural traditions.
I often participate in mainstream North American cultural traditions.
I would be willing to marry a person from my heritage culture.
I would be willing to marry a North American person.
I enjoy social activities with people from the same heritage culture as myself.
I enjoy social activities with typical North American people.
I am comfortable working with people of the same heritage culture as myself.
I am comfortable working with typical North American people.
I enjoy entertainment (e.g., movies, music) from my heritage culture.
I enjoy North American entertainment (e.g., movies, music).
I often behave in ways that are typical of my heritage culture.
I often behave in ways that are ‘typically North American.’
It is important for me to maintain or develop the practices of my heritage culture.
It is important for me to maintain or develop North American cultural practices.
I believe in the values of my heritage culture.
I believe in mainstream North American values.
6
The Acculturation Questionnaire
(Campbell et al., 2003)
I do things the Canadian way. My attitudes and behaviours are consistent
with Canadian norms and values. I think and act like a Canadian when I am
among Canadians and when I am among Indians.
I do things the Indian way. My attitudes and behaviours are consistent with
Indian norms and values. I think and act like an Indian when I am among
Indians and when I am among Canadians.
I do some things the Canadian way and some things the Indian way. Some
of my attitudes and behaviours are consistent with Canadian norms and
values, and some of my attitudes and behaviours are consistent with Indian
norms and values. The way I think and act when I am among Canadians and
when I among Indians does not change—it combines aspects of both
Canadian culture and Indian culture.
7
I adapt to which ever cultural environment I am in. When I am among
Canadians, I do things the Canadian way—my attitudes and behaviours are
consistent with Canadian norms and values. When I am among Indians, I
do things the Indian way—my attitudes and behaviours are consistent with
Indian norms and values. The way I think and act is determined by the
cultural environment that I am in at a given time.
I do things neither the Canadian way nor the Indian way. My attitudes and
behaviours are not consistent with either Canadian norms and values or
Indian norms and values. The way I think and act when I am among
Canadians and when I am among Indians does not reflect aspects of either
Canadian culture or Indian culture.
8
What are the psychological correlates of distinct
acculturation strategies?
● To date, the bulk of research examining the
psychological correlates of acculturation strategies
has focused on the 4 strategies identified by the twodimensional model.
● In general, this research suggests that integration is the
most adaptive acculturation strategy.
9
● However, one study has examined the psychological
correlates of the 5 acculturation strategies recently
identified by theorists: Campbell et al. (2003).
 Recruited South Asian Canadian participants.
 Measured the following constructs:
1. Acculturation strategies.
2. Psychological adjustment: (a) Depression, (b) anxiety,
(c) somatization, (d) self-esteem, (e) life satisfaction.
10
3. Self-concept organization:
(a) Self-concept clarity (SCC): The extent to which selfbeliefs are clearly and confidently defined, internally
consistent, and temporally stable.
(b) Self-concept differentiation (SCD): The degree to
which people see themselves as having different
personality characteristics in different social roles.
(c) Self-discrepancies (SDs): The degree to which people
experience discrepancies between who they believe
they are and who significant others believe they are.
11
 Found that:
(a) Alternation and fusion are used more frequently than
assimilation, separation, and marginalization.
(b) Alternation is associated with relatively low levels of
psychological adjustment; fusion is associated with
relatively high levels of psychological adjustment.
12
(c) Alternation is associated with relatively low levels of
SCC and high levels of SCD and SDs; fusion is
associated with relatively high levels of SCC and low
levels of SCD and SDs.
(d) Self-concept organization mediates the relationship
between acculturation strategies and psychological
adjustment.
13
Do multicultural experiences foster creativity?
● Researchers have speculated that creative insight
(seeing problems in novel ways) may be fostered by
acculturative experiences.
● Many famous artists and writers have had
multicultural experiences.
Paul Gauguin
Georgia O’Keefe
Emily Carr
Ernest Hemingway
George Handel
Pablo Picasso
“Once I went (abroad) it was extremely
exciting for me to become a new personality,
to be detached from everything that bound
me, noticing everything that was different.
That noticing of difference was very
important.”
Richard Wright
● Research suggests that multicultural experiences
enhance creativity:
 Example: Maddux & Galinsky (2010, in press)
Study 1:
 Participants were individuals who had lived in more
than one culture and individuals who had travelled
abroad as tourists.
 Presented participants with the Duncker candle problem:
17
How could you attach the candle to the wall so that it
burns properly, and doesn’t get wax on the floor or table,
using only these objects?
 Found that:
Participants who had lived abroad were more likely
to solve this problem than participants who had
travelled abroad as tourists or had never been
abroad.
19
Study 2:
 Participants were individuals who had lived in more
than one culture.
 Exposed participants to one of two conditions:
20
“Functional multicultural learning” condition: Asked
participants to recall and write about a multicultural
experience in which they learned something novel
and were able to figure out the reasons for it.
“Non-functional multicultural learning” condition: Asked
participants to recall and write about a multicultural
experience in which they learned something novel and
were not able to figure out the reasons for it.
21
 Presented participants with the Duncker candle
problem:
 Found that those in the functional multicultural learning
condition were more likely to solve the problem than
those were in the nonfunctional multicultural learning
condition.
 Why?
22
Duncker Candle Solutions (%)
Acculturation
1. What are acculturation strategies and how are they
measured? (continued)
2. What are the psychological correlates of distinct
acculturation strategies?
3. Do multicultural experiences foster creativity?
24