Transcript Shakespeare`s Astronomy

Shakespeare’s
astronomy
Michael Rowan-Robinson
Imperial College
‘Doubt
Nov 30th 2016
that the sun doth move’
Gresham Lecture
two themes
• Shakespeare’s knowledge of the night sky and his use of
astronomical images at key emotional moments
• Shakespeare’s contact with the Copernicans and his hints
to us about the new world order
Nov 30th 2016
Gresham Lecture
the English Copernicans
England in the time of Shakespeare was a hotbed of
Copernicanism.
De Revolutionibus came under fire in Catholic world soon after
its publication in 1543.Copernicus was also despised by Luther.
Nicolas Copernicus
1473-1543
A key figure was the enigmatic John Dee (1527-1608)
- interested in astronomy, but also in astrology, alchemy and the
occult.
- there is a direct link between Shakespeare and leading Copernicans.
Was Shakespeare influenced by this new world-view ?
Nov 30th 2016
Gresham Lecture
John Dee
the School of Night
•
a rival pro-Copernican group was centred on the Earl of
Northumberland and the Earl of Southampton
•
They were known as the ‘School of Night’, because of their
atheistic tendencies.
•
Shakespeare had links to the Earl of Southampton, to whom
The Rape of Lucrece and Venus and Adonis were dedicated
•
Writer’s linked to both Dee and Northumberland include
Spenser, Sidney, Marlowe and Donne.
Nov 30th 2016
Gresham Lecture
Earl of
Northumberland
Earl of
Southampton
Shakespeare’s astronomical references
At first sight the Shakespeare quotations are simple metaphors: ‘one particular
bright star’, ‘cut him out in little stars’, ‘you chaste stars’, ‘Two stars keep not their
motion in one sphere’
or they are astrological references: ‘it is the stars, the stars above us’, ‘there was
a star danced’, ‘yoke of inauspicious stars’ and ‘the fault, dear Brutus, is not in our
stars’.
Similarly astrological is another famous quotation from Julius Ceasar
‘When beggars die there are no comets seen,
The heavens themselves blaze forth the death of princes’
- more interesting because it connects to definite phenomena of the night sky,
comets.
Nov 30th 2016
Gresham Lecture
A more lurid version appears in Hamlet, when Horatio says:
‘A little ere the mightiest Julius fell,
The graves stood tenantless, and the sheeted dead
Did squeak and gibber in the Roman streets;
As, stars with trains of fire, and dews of blood,
Disasters in the sun.’
In Henry VI, Part I, the Duke of Bedford says:
‘Comets, importing change of time and states,
Brandish your crystal tresses in the sky’
and in King John Louis the Dauphin says:
‘But this effusion of such manly drops,
Startles mine eyes, and makes me more amazed
Than had I seen the vaulty top of heaven
Figured quite o’er with burning meteors.’
Nov 30th 2016
Gresham Lecture
Shakespeare knows about comets, meteor showers, the constellations, the motion of
the sky:
‘The wind-shak’d surge, with high and monstrous mane
Seemed to cast water on the burning Bear,
And quench the guards of th’ever fixed pole’
the violence of the storm encountered by Othello on his way to Cyprus indicated by
the fact that the Great Bear, which never sets from UK latitudes, seems to disappear
below the waves
‘Heigh-ho! An’t be not four by the day,
I’ll be hanged; Charles’ Wain is over the new chimney
And yet our horse not packed’
the porters in the inn-yard in Henry IV part 1 realizing they are running late from the
position of the Wain, or Plough, in the sky.
Nov 30th 2016
Gresham Lecture
Brutus however fails to tell the time in this way (II.1):
‘I cannot by the progress of the stars
give guess how near to day.’
Shakespeare seems to have a country boy’s knowledge of the sky and its phenomena.
in Two Nobel Kinsman, a joint work by Shakespeare and Fletcher. The Jailer’s
Daughter says:
‘I am very cold, and all the stars are out too,
The little stars and all, that look like aglets-’
The implication of the exceptionally cold night that the sky is especially clear so much
fainter stars can be seen
Nov 30th 2016
Gresham Lecture
did Shakespeare’s interest in
astronomy come from his mother?
Could Shakespeare’s knowledge of the night sky have
come from his mother, Mary Arden, who lived on a farm
until her marriage to John Shakespeare in 1557 ?
Interestingly the last lines of her epitaph in Holy Trinity
Church, Stratford, possibly written by her daughter
Susanna, translate as:
come quickly, Christ
that my mother, though shut in the tomb,
may rise again and seek the stars.
Nov 30th 2016
Gresham Lecture
In Timon of Athens Shakespeare shows that he is aware that the moon shines by
reflected light:
‘The moon’s an arrant thief,
And her pale fire she snatches from the sun.’
he knows that one half of the earth is illuminated by the sun at a time:
‘Now o’er the one-half world
Nature seems dead, and wicked dreams abuse
The curtained sleep.’ (Macbeth)
and in Henry IV, Part 1, Prince Hal shows that he knows the moon controls the tides:
‘For the fortune of us that are the moon’s men doth ebb and flow like the sea,
being governed, as the sea is, by the moon.’
Nov 30th 2016
Gresham Lecture
the Northern Star
Julius Ceasar says ‘I am constant as the northern star’, so Shakespeare
knew the night-sky rotates about Polaris, the Northern Star
Shakespeare again refers to the Pole Star in Sonnet 116
‘O no, it is an ever fixed mark
That looks on tempests and is never shaken;
It is the star to every wand’ring barque,
Whose worth’s unknown, although his height be taken.’
Shakespeare knows that mariners use the elevation of the Pole Star to
estimate their latitude.
Nov 30th 2016
Gresham Lecture
The conspirators in Julius are aware that the direction of sunrise varies with the
season:
Decius:
Casca:
Cenna:
Casca:
Nov 30th 2016
Here lies the east. Doth not the day break here ?
No.
O pardon, sir, it doth; and yon grey lines
That fret the clouds are messengers of day.
You shall confess that you are both deceived.
(he points his sword)
Here, as I point my sword, the sun arises,
Which is a great way growing on the south,
Weighing the youthful season of the year.
Some two months hence up higher towards the north
He first presents his fire, and the high east
Stands, as the Capitol, directly here.
(he points his sword)
Gresham Lecture
In Midsummer Night’s Dream the mechanicals consult an almanac to determine
whether there will be a moon on the night of their impending performance.
Snout
Bottom
Quince
Nov 30th 2016
Doth the Moon shine that night we play our play?
A calendar, a calendar! Look in the almanac; find out moonshine,
find out moonshine.
Yes, it doth shine that night.
Gresham Lecture
Richard the Third checks a calendar for the time of sunrise, just before the Battle of
Bosworth:
(Clock strikes)
Richard: Tell the clock there. Give me a calendar.
Who saw the sun today? (a book is brought)
Ratcliffe: Not I, my lord.
Richard: Then he disdains to shine, for by the book
He should have braved the east an hour ago.
A black day will it be to somebody
And of course the play’s opening lines
Richard Now is the winter of our discontent
Made glorious summer by this son of York
contains a pun on son/sun.
So Richard foresees his doom in the darkened sun and unconsciously refers back to his
gleeful opening words.
Nov 30th 2016
Gresham Lecture
Other intriguing or resonant astronomical quotes are Claudius’s remark to Hamlet
‘That is most retrograde to our desires’,
apparently referring to the occasional retrograde (or
backwards) motion of the planets.
Another technical astronomy term comes in Prospero’s
‘and by my prescience
I find my zenith doth depend upon
A most auspicious star’
A highly perplexing speech occurs in King John:
‘My lord, they say five moons were seen tonight:
Four fixed and the fifth did whirl about
The other four in wondrous motion’
Nov 30th 2016
Gresham Lecture
Shakespeare Concordance
Midsummer Night’s Dream
Hamlet
Romeo and Juliet
Love’s Labour’s Lost
Taming of the Shrew
Antony and Cleopatra
Winter’s Tale
King Lear
Henry IV, Part 1
Cymbeline
Henry V
Richard III
Richard II
Pericles
Coriolanus
All’s Well That Ends Well
Tempest
Titus Andronicus
Othello
Macbeth
King John
Timon of Athens
Merchant of Venice
Julius Ceasar
all plays
Nov 30th 2016
sun star/s
moon total date
2
8
14
6
9
5
7
5
7
9
9
9
8
4
4
2
4
7
4
4
7
7
3
2
2
10
6
5
3
6
6
5
4
4
3
3
3
6
1
8
1
1
1
2
2
0
0
3
23
5
3
10
8
7
4
6
5
1
2
1
1
2
6
0
5
2
4
3
0
2
4
1
27
23
23
21
20
18
17
16
16
14
14
13
12
12
11
10
10
10
9
9
9
9
7
7
252
128
130
510
Gresham Lecture
1595
1599-01
1595
1594-5
1590-91
1606
1609-11
1605-6
1591-92
1610
1599
1592-3
1595
1607-8
1608
1604-5
1610-11
1591-2
1603-4
1596-7
1596
1605-6
1606
1599
collaborator?
Wilkins
Middleton
Marlowe
Middleton
Middleton
Shakespeare on astronomers
Shakespeare is not very complimentary about astronomers.
Biron in Love’s Labour Lost says:
‘Study is like the heavens’ glorious sun,
That will not be deep searched with saucy looks.
Small have continual plodders ever won
Save base authority from others’ books.
These earthly godfathers of heaven’s lights,
That give a name to every fixed star,
Have no more profit of their shining nights
Than those that walk and wot not where they are.
Too much to know is to know naught but fame,
And every godfather can give a name.’
Nov 30th 2016
Gresham Lecture
In Cymbeline, Imogen says:
‘O, learn’d indeed were that astronomer,
That knew the stars as I his characters;
He’d lay the future open.’
and in Sonnet 14:
‘Not from the stars do I my judgement pluck,
And yet methinks I have astronomy;
But not to tell of good or evil luck,
Of plagues, of dearths, or seasons’ quality.’
.
Nov 30th 2016
Gresham Lecture
Ben Jonson is even more scathing about astronomers:
SORDIDO: Tut, these star-monger knaves, who would trust
them? One says dark and rainy, when 'tis as clear as
chrystal; another says, tempestuous blasts and storms, and
'twas as calm as a milk-bowl; here be sweet rascals for a
man to credit his whole fortunes with! You sky-staring
coxcombs you, you fat-brains, out upon you; you are good
for nothing but to sweat night-caps, and make rug-gowns
dear! you learned men, and have not a legion of devils 'a
votre service! a votre service!' by heaven, I think I shall die
a better scholar than they:
(Everyman Out of his Humour)
Ben Jonson
1572-1637
Nov 30th 2016
Gresham Lecture
The astronomical universe that Shakespeare refers to is, naturally enough, a strictly
Aristotelian one:
‘Doubt that the stars are fire,
Doubt that the sun doth move
Doubt truth to be a liar
But never doubt I love.’
this letter from Hamlet to Ophelia assumes we all know that the stars are made of fire
and that the sun moves around the earth.
Any deviation from the motion of the spheres must be associated with magic:
‘And certain stars shot madly from their spheres
To hear the sea-maid sing.’
Nov 30th 2016
Gresham Lecture
an assault on astrology
But there is one very dramatic counter to this, in Lear:
‘This is the excellent foppery of the world … we make guilty of our disasters the
sun, the moon and the stars, as if we were villains by necessity, fools by heavenely
compulsion, knaves, thieves and treachers by spherical predominance, drunkards,
liars and adulterers by enforced obedience of planetary influence. … I should have
been that I am had the maidenliest star in the firmament twinkled on my
bastardizing.’
Earlier in the scene, the Earl of Gloucester has piously remarked:
‘These late eclipses in the sun and moon portend no good to us. Though the
wisdom of nature can reason it thus and thus, yet nature finds itself scourg’d by
the sequent effects.’
Edmund ridicules the idea that eclipses portend anything. Gloucester knows very well
that there is a natural explanation for eclipses, but still thinks they must mean
something.
Nov 30th 2016
Gresham Lecture
Othello invokes eclipses to express his anguish (V.2):
‘O insupportable, O heavy hour!
Methinks it should be now a huge eclipse
Of sun and moon, and that th’affrighted globe
Should yawn at alteration.’
In fact the sun and moon could not be simultaneously eclipsed (they can be eclipsed
two weeks apart and this happened in 1598 and, less impressively, in 1605 when Lear
was being written)
Nov 30th 2016
Gresham Lecture
In Antony and Cleopatra, Antony uses an eclipse metaphor to express his sense of
impending doom:
‘Alack our terrene Moon is now eclipsed,
And it portends alone the fall of Antony.’
Cleopatra also uses an astronomical metaphor as she resolves to die:
‘now from head to foot
I am marble-constant: now the fleeting Moon
No planet is of mine.’
Nov 30th 2016
Gresham Lecture
A more measured critique of astrological fortune-telling comes from Pandolf in King
John (III.4):
‘No natural exhalation in the sky,
No scope of nature, no distempered day,
No common wind, no customed event,
But they will pluck away his natural cause,
And call them meteors, prodigies, and signs,
Abortives, presages, and tongues of heaven
Plainly denouncing vengeance upon John.’
and in All’s Well That Ends Well, Helen says (I.1):
‘Our remedies oft in ourselves do lie
Which we ascribe to heaven. The fated sky
Gives us free scope, only doth backward pull
Our slow designs when we ourselves are dull.’
Nov 30th 2016
Gresham Lecture
Tycho Brahe 1546-1601
The famous Danish atsronomer Tycho
Brahe was in contact with the leading
English Copernicans
- in 1590 sent copies of this portrait to
Thomas Savile, asking to be
remembered to John Dee and Thomas
Digges. One of these ends up in the
hands of Thomas’s son Leonard.
Tycho is surrounded by the arms of his
ancestors, including Sophie
Gyldenstierne and Erik Rosenkrantz.
Presumption is that Shakespeare
acquired these names via Thomas
Digges
Nov 30th 2016
Gresham Lecture
Thomas Digges 1546-1595
brought up by John Dee following death of his father.
A noted mathematician and Copernican.
In 1576 he published A perfit description of the
caelestiall orbes, taking the Copernican system to its
logical conclusion and asserting that the stars extend to
infinity.
On his death his wife Anne married Thomas Russell, who
Shakespeare appointed as an overseer of his will.
His son Leonard wrote a touching poem about
Shakespeare in the Folio of 1623.
Nov 30th 2016
Gresham Lecture
an allegorical interpretation of Hamlet ?
The American academic Peter Usher in Hamlet’s Universe wants to take this
connection a lot further and gives an allegorical interpretation of Hamlet, in which
• Claudius represents the Aristotelian, earth-centred world view encapsulated by
Claudius Ptolemy
• Rosencrantz and Guildenstern represent Tycho’s hybrid model in which the planets
revolve around the sun and the sun revolves around the earth
• Hamlet himself represents the new universe of Copernicus and Thomas Digges.
Thus Hamlet has to kill off the competing but outdated world-views. It doesn’t seem a
very brilliant allegorical outcome when Hamlet dies shortly after Claudius.
Nov 30th 2016
Gresham Lecture
which star is Bernardo talking about ?
On the very first page of Hamlet, Bernardo says:
‘Last night of all,
When yond same star that’s westward from the pole
Had made his course t’illume that part of heaven
Where now it burns …’
Once again Shakespeare showing that he is familiar with the rotation of the night-sky,
but which star is Bernardo talking about ?
Nov 30th 2016
Gresham Lecture
Tycho Brahe’s supernova
Tycho Brahe
observed a
supernova in
Cassiopeia in
1572.
Nov 30th 2016
Gresham Lecture
NRAO
NASA/Chandra
Ben Jonson and a new star
In Ben Jonson’s Volpone, first performed in 1605, there is a comical list of prodigies
which includes
SIR POLITICK WOULD-BE:
Now heaven!
What prodigies be these? The fires at Berwick!
And the new star! these things concurring, strange,
And full of omen! Saw you those meteors?
PEREGRINE:
I did, sir.
SIR P:
Fearful! Pray you, sir, confirm me,
Were there three porpoises seen above the bridge,
As they give out?
PER:
Six, and a sturgeon, sir.
This new star must be Kepler’s supernova of 1604.
Nov 30th 2016
Gresham Lecture
was Shakespeare a Copernican ?
Hamlet: ‘I could be bounded in a nutshell and count myself a king of infinite space.’
- a revolutionary idea at the time, first introduced by Thomas Digges.
Here perhaps we do have a reference to the new astronomy of Copernicus and Digges.
Another remarkably modern-sounding line is the Chorus’s prologue to the fourth Act of
Henry V:
‘Now entertain conjecture of a time
When creeping murmur and the pouring dark
Fills the wide vessel of the universe.’
Nov 30th 2016
Gresham Lecture
a strong hint of Copernicanism in Ulysses’ famous speech on degree in Troilus and
Cressida:
‘The heavens themselves, the planets and this centre
Observe degree, priority and place,
Insisture, course, proportion, season, form,
Office and custom, in all line of order;
And therefore is the glorious planet Sol
In noble eminence enthroned and sphered
Amidst the other; whose medicinable eye
Corrects the ill aspects of planets evil,
And posts, like the commandment of a king,
Sans check to good and bad:’
Nov 30th 2016
Gresham Lecture
Perhaps we have to look again at Hamlet’s letter to Ophelia. He writes:
‘Doubt that the sun doth move’
meaning that you can’t doubt that, therefore you can’t doubt my love.
However as Polonius and Claudius come to realize, and Hamlet makes pretty clear to
Ophelia and the audience, he does not love Ophelia.
Is Shakespeare saying to us that perhaps we do have to question whether it is the sun
that moves ?
Nov 30th 2016
Gresham Lecture
When Hamlet jumps into Ophelia’s grave he says
‘What is he whose grief
Bears such an emphasis, whose phrase of sorrow
Conjures the wand’ring stars and makes them stand
Like wonder-wounded hearers? This is I,
Hamlet the Dane.’
again suggesting that the new world-order, in which it is not the sun and stars that
move, is on his mind. To Rosencrantz and Guildenstern he has earlier said:
‘and indeed it goes so heavily with my disposition that this goodly frame, the
earth, seems to me a sterile promontory. This most excellent canopy the air,
look you, this brave o’erhanging firmament, this majestical roof fretted with
golden fire – why it appears no other thing to me than a foul and pestilent
congregation of vapours.’
Is not part of Hamlet’s angst the destruction of the old world-order?
Nov 30th 2016
Gresham Lecture
Shakespeare on Aristotle
There are two direct references to Aristotle in Shakespeare’s plays. In The Taming of the
Shrew Lucentio’s man Tranio says:
‘Let’s be no Stoics nor no stocks, I pray,
Or so devote to Aristotle’s checks
As Ovid be an outcast quite abjur’d.
Balk logic with aquaintance that you have,
And practise rhetoric in your common talk;
Music and poesy use to quicken you;
The mathematics and the metaphysics,
Fall to them as your stomach serves you.’
Tranio is advising against excessive study but he is aware that Aristotle has written
books on Logic, Rhetoric, Poetics and Metaphysics.
Nov 30th 2016
Gresham Lecture
Even more interesting is the reference in Troilus and Cressida, where Hector says:
‘Paris and Troilus, you have both said well;
And on the cause and question now in hand
Have gloz’d but superficially; not much
Unlike young men, whom Aristotle thought
Unfit to hear moral philosophy.’
Now this is a direct quote from Aristotle’s Ethics, a work that was freely available in
English translation in Shakespeare’s lifetime.
So Shakespeare encapsulates the intellectual world of Aristotle, but seems to hint at the
arrival of the Copernican system. As he was writing, his exact contemporary Galileo
was plotting the overthrow of Aristotle’s physics.
Nov 30th 2016
Gresham Lecture
References
Harmon O.E., 1898, The Astronomy of Shakespeare, Popular Astronomy 6, 232, 263 and 321
Dean J.C., 1924, The Astronomy of Shakespeare, The Scientific Monthly 19, 400
Taylor G.C., 1925, Shakespeare’s debt to Montaigne, Harvard Univ Press
Chappell D.H., 1945, Shakespeare’s Astronomy, PASP 57, 255
McCormick-Goodhart L., 1945, Shakespeare and the Stars, Popular Astronomy 53, 489
Guthrie W.G., 1964, The Astronomy of Shakespeare, Irish Astronomical Journal 6, 201
Olson D.W., Olson M.S., Doescher R.L., 1998, The Stars of Hamlet, Sky and Telescope 96, 68
Voulkel J.R., 1999, Johannes Kepler and the new astronomy, OUP
Usher P., 2001, Advances in the Hamlet Cosmic Allegory, Oxfordian IV, 25
Usher P., 2006, Hamlet’s Universe, Aventine Press
McCarthy P., 2006, Pseudonymous Shakespeare: Rioting Language in the Sidney Circle, Ashgate
Rowan-Robinson M., 2008, Shakespeare’s Astronomy, Southwold Organ
Bloom H., 2008, Shakespeare: the Invention of the Human, Fourth Estate
Wember H., 2010, Illuminating Eclipses, Brief Chronicles II, 31
Levy D.H., 2011, The Sky in Early Modern English Literature, 1572-1620, New York, Springer
Falk D., 2014, The Science of Shakespeare, Thomas Dunne Books
Olson D.W., 2014, Celestial Sleuth, Springer
Craig L.H., 2014, Philosophy and the Puzzles of Hamlet, Bloomsbury
Edmondson P. and Wells S. (eds), 2015, The Shakespeare circle; an alternative biography, CUP
Nov 30th 2016
Gresham Lecture