Transcript Peer Review in the Google Age

Open Notebook Science for
Collaborative Drug
Development
University of Manchester
Jean-Claude Bradley
E-Learning Coordinator
College of Arts and Sciences
Associate Professor of Chemistry
Drexel University
Sept 5, 2008
Open and Closed Science
Traditional
Lab Notebook
(unpublished)
Traditional
Journal
Article
Open Access
Journal Article
Open Notebook
Science (full
transparency)
RESEARCH
OPEN
CLOSED
TEACHING
Traditional
Paper
Textbook
F2F lectures
Lectures
Notes
public
Assigned
problems
public
Archived
Lectures
Public and
free online
textbooks
Motivations for ONS
•Faster Science
•Better Science
A recent example in Southampton
Sept 3, 2008 usefulchem.wikispaces.com/exp207
Investigating solubilities in organic solvents
Boc-glycine
vanillin
glucose
NaCl
The lab notebook page
The Log: No Insider Information
The Results in a GoogleDoc
reliable
unreliable
Representation in the Neylon notebook
Open Notebook Science
Grand Challenge
Round one
•design procedures to determine the solubility
of compounds in organic solvents
•teams or individuals welcome
•Open Notebooks will be validated by experts
•“mystery prizes” for creativity, productivity,
reproducibility and other metrics of scientific
quality
•details coming soon…..
UsefulChem Project: Open Primary
Research in Drug Design using Web2.0 tools
Rajarshi Guha
Indiana U
JC Bradley
Drexel U
Phil Rosenthal
UCSF
(malaria)
Docking
Tsu-Soo Tan
Nanyang Inst.
Synthesis
Testing
Dan Zaharevitz
NCI
(tumors)
Architecture: Distributed, Interlinked and
Redundant
BLOG
CDD
WIKI
Nature
Precedings
FriendFeed
JoVE
ChemSpider
GoogleDocs
Mailing List
Where’s the Beef?
Link to Lab Notebook Page in Wiki
Link to Molecules
Link to Docking Procedure
(Rajarshi Guha)
Link to Docking Results:
Lists of SMILES in GoogleDocs
(Rajarshi Guha)
Link to Raw Data with JSpecView
(data in JCAMP-DX format)
(by Robert Lancashire)
Using ChemSpider to archive
compound characterization
Conclusion is Fully Supported
Table of Contents
Indexing the Experiments in Google
Searching with
Google Custom Search
How are people finding our
experiments?
Specific Compounds
NMR in TFA
Phenylacetaldehyde
c4h6o2 nmr
methylene chloride/methanol
h'nmr of benzophenone
sulfuric acid pka
tertbutylamine
tosyl isocyanide
amino furan
dichloromethane polar?
Reaction between Benzaldehyde
and NaBH4
phosphoric acid pka
veratraldehyde wiki
Experimental Conditions
kinetics boc deprotection
Rf value in polar solvent
why glycerol is immiscible with
ether
side reaction of imines
5.8 ppm nmr
nmr cdcl3 chloroform side reaction
diasterotopic wiki
adding anhydrous MgSO4 to the
dichlormethane ether extraction
hnmr doublet of doublet
Boc-protected NMR
chromatotron recipe
triplet cdcl3 "13c nmr"
How are people finding
UsefulChem?
Educational
free downloading chemistry video
organic chemistry project + high
school
how to make poster in second life
organic chem. quiz
3d periodic tables
animation protein docking
docking animation
why are acid-base reactions
exothermic?
Big Picture
lysosomal targets
protease and malaria
cheminformatics project proposal
automated reactions
malaria review project synthesis
CHEMISTRY WEB 2.0
projects on QSAR & drug design
chemistry experiment results
database
How Should Open Notebook
Science be Used?
How did this
experiment
evolve?
Third party timestamp
http://usefulchem.wikispaces.com/page/diff/Exp037/1577428
Comparing wiki page versions
http://usefulchem.wikispaces.com/SO+Research+Report
Comparing Experiments
Ugi Master Table
YouTube for demonstrating experimental set-up
Older Males
Prefer
Organic
Chemistry!
Mailing List Facilitates inter-group
collaboration
Outcome of Guha-Bradley-Rosenthal
collboration
Collaborative Drug Discovery (CDD) Database
Interacting with NMR spectra
(JCAMP-DX) in Second Life
Talk to the spectrum: zoom 2.1-2.3 (Andy Lang)
3D molecules in Second Life
Imine Formation Mechanism:
talk to the molecules!
Gus Rosania’s Notebook
Cameron Neylon’s Notebook
Results in Machine-Friendly Format
Mettler-Toledo MiniMapper
Mettler-Toledo MiniBlock System
GoogleDoc to program and report
XML reports from MiniMapper robot
Writing Code in the Murray-Rust House
Experiments in Chemical Markup Language
Paper written on Wiki
References to papers, blog posts,
lab notebook pages, raw data
Pre-print on Nature Precedings
Methanol 0.4M xs of imine best
Paper on Journal of Visualized
Experiments (JoVE)
Where is Science headed?
WE ARE HERE
Conclusion



Communicate first
Standardize second
In a Science2.0 world redundancy is king