Transcript Wednesday 21 Oct, session on Spec 11 Security Framework

PUBLIC SAFETY WORKING GROUP (PSWG) – UPDATE TO T
Agenda Item 16 | GAC 54 | 20 October 2015
The GAC PSWG is…
• A forum for experts and a resource for the GAC, the Public Safety
Working Group (PSWG) proposes advice to the GAC through
research, discussion and consultations with operational cyber-security
experts.
• Created Feb 2015, ICANN 52 Singapore
• All GAC members are encouraged to join, in particular data protection
representatives, subject matter experts..
• More information:
https://gacweb.icann.org/display/gacweb/GAC+Public+Safety+Working
+Group
| 3
Members of the GAC PSWG – 18 countries & 7
observers
GAC Member/Observer - Contact(s)
African
Union
Commission
Alice Munyua (Chair)
Argentina
Olga Cavalli
Ezequiel Sallis, Buenos Aires
Police
Australia
Annaliese Williams
Adrian Norris (advisor)
Canada
Andrea Todoran
Maury Medjuck, Royal Canadian
Mounted Police
Lise Landry-Morson, Competition
Bureau
Andre Leduc, Industry Canada
EUROPOL
Gregory Mounier
Ukraine
Oleksandr Tsaruk
Germany
Sabine Meyer
Hubert Schoettner
United
Kingdom
India
Ajay Kumar
Mark Carvell
Nick Shorey
Stephen Truick
Will Metters
John Carr
International
Association of
Chiefs of
Police
James Emerson
United
States
INTERPOL
Adrian Eduardo Acosta
Kimmo Ulkuniemi
Japan
Shuji Yamaguchi
Morocco
Redouane Houssaini
Suzanne Radell
Ashley Heineman
Laureen Kappin, FTC
Daniel Burke, FDA
Robert Flaim, FBI
Ella Smallwoo, FBI
Iranga Kahangama, FBI
Carmen Alvarez, DEA
Mike Freeman, DEA
Amy J Sanbury, DEA
Tom Walden, DEA
Man Tse, Homeland
Security Investigations
Mark Hendersen, Internal
Revenue Service (IRS)
Peter Roman, US DOJ
Venezuela
Jesus Rivera
INTERPOL
Adrian Eduardo Acosta
Kimmo Ulkuniemi
Dominica
Thomas Benette
Niue
Pär Brumark
China
Guo Feng
OAS
Belgium
Jean-Philippe Moiny
Fernand Van Gansbeke
Ruben Verstraete
Belisario Contreras
Kerry-Ann Barett
Switzerland
Jorge Cancio
Adrian Koster (Advisor)
Egypt
Manal Ismail
Thailand
European
Commission
Megan Richards
Cathrin Bauer-Bulst
Cristina Monti
Michael Palmer
Wanawit Akhuputra
Pitinan Kooarmornpatana
Artthawit Hung
Panus Rattakitvijun Na
Nakorn
| 4
GAC PSWG: our achievements since February
2015

Terms of Reference for WG: Completed and endorsed by the GAC at
ICANN 53 in Buenos Aires

The PSWG has been very active since its creation, in particular
providing input on key WHOIS-related tracks:




Whois Accuracy Program Specification Review: Comments
produced in August 2015
Comments on the Privacy and Proxy Accreditation Services Initial
Report of the GNSO PPSAI PDP WG: endorsed by the GAC,
submitted to WG.
Next Generation Registration Directory Services: Comment
endorsed by the GAC and submitted in August 2015
Second face-to-face meeting of PSWG: 10 Sept 2015
| 5
For GAC consideration – PSWG plan of work
(1/3)

Submit letter to the Number Resource Organization (NRO) on IP
Address WHOIS accuracy, which is discussed by RIRs who gather at
ICANN as ASO/NRO.



Develop case studies in several areas,



No objections to date
Any additional comments by GAC requested by 22 Oct 2015
Include fee fraud investment scams.
Include cases showing need for access to DNS WHOIS and IP WHOIS.
Encourage regulator collaboration to solicit support from registrars and
registries



Look into standardizing requests by LEAs for WHOIS requests or domain
suspension (currently highly variable).
Clarify PSWG seeks accurate accessible WHOIS information, not necessarily
public (address this recurring misperception about the WG)
Organize meeting in Marrakech with regulators and registrars.
| 6
For GAC consideration – PSWG plan of work
(2/3)


Outreach to members from developing countries

Outreach to and through GAC, AUC, OAS, Europol, Interpol, CoE

Hold inter-sessional meeting early 2016, likely London

ICANN Fellowship Program, for each meeting alert to fellowship program
New gTLD Security Framework “Spec 11”

PSWG has drafted document to be presented to ICANN Security Framework
Working Group (October 2015)

Goal is final registry guidelines for public comment in Marrakesh but relies on
registry cooperation

Wednesday 21 Oct, session on Spec 11 Security Framework Drafting Team F2F
Meeting, Liffey B, at 11:30 – 12:45
| 7
For GAC consideration – PSWG plan of work
(3/3)


RAA 3.18 Addendum for Illegal/Counterfeit Drug Reporting to ICANN
Contract Compliance,

Draft will be presented to PSWG.

Draft by US Food and Drug Administration and European Union, Head of Section for
Pharmaceutical Care, Consumer Health Protection and Anti-Counterfeiting – EDQM

Ensure generic drugs are not mistakenly included/confused
GAC-GNSO early engagement




Importance of PSWG being involved early on in
GAC support staff track and signal budding PDPs
E.g. call for participation in WG on consumer trust in new gTLDs -- PSWG would
like one of its members on the review team so the PSWG can plays an important
role in the PDP – notice to GAC Chair!
Self-nominations by 30 Oct – does GAC wish to support candidate(s)?
| 8
Key/time-sensitive points






Program of work for GAC approval
NRO letter: any comments by GAC requested by 22 Oct 2015
Call for Volunteers: Competition, Consumer Trust and Consumer Choice
Review Team by 30 Oct – desire by PSWG to be
representedhttps://www.icann.org/resources/pages/call-volunteers-cctrt-2015-10-01-en
Spec 11: Wednesday 21 Oct, session on Spec 11
Outreach: Hold inter-sessional meeting early 2016, likely London –
resource considerations
Encourage regulator collaboration: organize meeting in Marrakech with
regulators and registrars
| 9