Transcript The Economics of Collective Decision Making

Norton Media Library
Chapter 24
Taxes and
Spending
Nariman Behravesh
Edwin
Mansfield
Jump to first page
Government Spending as a Share
of the Economy, 1930-2006
• The following slide shows total government
spending (federal, state, and local) as a share
of the economy.
• Total government spending accounted for
only 9.4% of GDP in 1930, and only one
third of this spending was at the federal level.
• Government spending, particularly at the
federal level, soared from 1930 to 1970.
• Total government spending rose from 9.4%
of GDP in 1930 to 30.2% of GDP in 1970.
• Since 1970, government spending has been
relatively constant at about one-third of the
U.S. economy.
Jump to first page
The Size of Government
Government Expenditures as a Share (%) of GDP
1930
1940
1950
1960
1970
3.0
6.5
8.4
7.3
14.7
16.5
21.1
7.6
19.4
21.0
1990
21.6
2006
State & local
15.7
6.3
1980
2000
Federal
9.4
24.1
10.9
30.2
11.8
12.6
19.0
12.9
20.3
13.5
Jump to first page
32.8
34.2
31.9
33.8
How the Federal Government Spends (2006)
Social
Security 20.7%
Defense 19.7%
Net
Interest 8.5%
Transportation
2.6%
Other
13.3%
Income
Security 13.3%
Medicare and health 21.9%
Sources: Economic Report of the President, 2007, and Statistical Abstract of the United States, 2007.
Back to slide 29
Jump to first page
Jump to first page
Jump to first page
Jump to first page
Jump to first page
How State and Local Governments Spend
Insurance trusts 8.9%
Education
28.8%
Public welfare
& Health 19.5%
Administration
& other 21.9%
Police &
Fire Protection 4.9%
Transportation 5.5%
Utilities &
liquor stores 6.9%
Sources: Economic Report of the President, 2007, and Statistical Abstract of the United States, 2007.
Jump to first page
Interest on debt 3.6%
Financing the Public
Sector: Taxation
In order to make available public and correct
inequity, government must free up resources
from the production of private goods.
• Taxes shift resources from private to public use
• Taxing households and businesses reduces their
incomes and spending, the private demand for
products decreases, as does the private demand for
resources.
• This is known as Deadweight Loss
Jump to first page
THE U.S. TAX STRUCTURE
Collection of Taxes
Federal Government
•Personal Income Tax
•Corporate Income Tax
Jump to first page
(Social Security)
Jump to first page
THE U.S. TAX STRUCTURE
Collection of Taxes
State Governments
•Personal Income Tax
•Sales Tax
County and City Governments
•Property Taxes
Jump to first page
Jump to first page
Jump to first page
TAXES
Tax Incidence
The Tax Incidence or Tax Burden is the
determination of who actually pays the
tax. Government must determine how to
appropriate taxes from the citizens.
Jump to first page
THE U.S. TAX STRUCTURE
INCIDENCE OF U.S. TAXES
Personal Income Tax
Individual
Corporate Income Tax
Stockholders – Consumers
Sales Taxes
Consumers
Property Taxes
Owner or Renter
Jump to first page
TAXES
Tax Incidence
•Benefits-Received Principle
•Ability-to-Pay Principle
Jump to first page
Benefits Received versus
Ability to Pay
• The benefits-received principle is the idea that
people who receive the benefit from governmentprovided goods and services should pay the taxes
required to finance them.
• The ability-to-pay principle is the idea that
people who have greater income should pay a
greater proportion of it as taxes than those who
have less income.
Jump to first page
THE
TAX BURDEN
• Progressive Tax
• Regressive Tax
• Proportional Tax
•Flat Tax
Jump to first page
Progressive, Proportional,
and Regressive Taxes
• A progressive tax is one whose average tax rate
increases as the taxpayer’s income increases.
• A regressive tax is a tax whose average tax rate
decreases as the taxpayer’s income increases.
• A proportional tax is a tax whose average tax rate
remains constant as the taxpayer’s income
increases.
• A flat tax is a tax which takes the same monetary
amount regardless of income.
Jump to first page
Progressive, Proportional,
and Regressive Taxes
• In general, progressive taxes fall relatively more
heavily on high-income households while
regressive taxes are those that fall relatively more
heavily on the poor.
Jump to first page
Progressive, Proportional,
and Regressive Taxes
• Taxes are classified as progressive, proportional,
or regressive, depending on the relationship
between
• average tax rate (total tax paid as a percentage of
income) and
• marginal tax rate (the rate paid on each
additional dollar of income).
Jump to first page
Jump to first page
Jump to first page
PRESIDENT
GROWTH
RATE
Tax year
Top marginal
tax rate (%)
Taxable
income over--
1913
7
500,000
1918
77
1,000,000
1922
58
200,000
HARDING
1923
43
200,000
COOLIDGE
1925
25
100,000
1932
63
1,000,000
1936
79
5,000,000
1940
81
5,000,000
8.1%
1942
88
200,000
18.5%
1951
94
400,000
EISENHOWER
8.7%
1965
70
200,000
KENNEDY
1.7%
1981
38.5
215,400
REAGAN
-0.2%
1986
28
29,750
1993
39.6
89,150
1994
39.6
250,000
2003
35
311,950
Jump to first page
WILSON
ROOSEVELT
-1.3%
4.3%
CLINTON
4.0%
BUSH
3.9%
Jump to first page
TAX APPLICATIONS:
Identify whether progressive,
regressive, or proportional
• Personal Income Tax
Progressive
• Sales Tax
Regressive
• Corporate Income Tax
Proportional
• Payroll Taxes
Regressive
• Property Taxes
Regressive
Jump to first page
Tax Progressivity in the
U.S.
• The majority view of economists is as follows:
• The Federal tax system is progressive.
• The state and local tax structures are largely
regressive. A general sales tax and property taxes are
regressive with respect to income.
• The overall U.S. tax system is slightly progressive.
Jump to first page
Jump to first page
THE TAX ISSUE
The Liberal Position
Jump to first page
Jump to first page
Jump to first page
Jump to first page
Jump to first page
Jump to first page
Jump to first page
THE TAX ISSUE
The Conservative Position
Jump to first page
Jump to first page
Jump to first page
Jump to first page
Jump to first page
Jump to first page
End
Chapter 24
Jump to first page