Transcript Ethics - University of Scranton

Ethics
In Security & Networking Issues
Purpose of Ethics Policies



Establish TRUST, OPENNESS, and
INTEGRITY in the environment.
PROTECTION of both the firm and the
employees.
Ethical procedures lead to fair
practices
Scope of an Ethics Policy


An ethics policy should apply, of
course, to EVERYONE within the
company.
Exception, after all, is unethical.
Before we get to “Policy…”


We should take a look at some
philosophical moral principles. As with
anything, knowing the theory makes
the activity much easier…
There are 3 “schools of ethical
thought” that are dominant today:
Kant: Deontology


The doctrine of deontological ethics is
also known as “duty ethics.”
According to Kant, rational beings
have certain duties to uphold. The
important one for us is the duty to the
universal. Kant called this duty a duty
to the universal moral law.
Kant cont’d

The universal moral law is the
CATEGORICAL IMPERATIVE. There
are 2 very famous manifestations of
the categorical imperative:
– “Act according to that maxim which you
will to become universal law.”
– “Treat all rational beings as ends-inthemselves, never as means to another
end.”
Kant cont’d

What that means:
– Think about what you’re about to do.
Formalize it (turn it into a universal
concept). Can this concept be instituted
as a universal law? If so, it’s a morally
good action. If not, it isn’t morally good,
and you shouldn’t do it.
– Don’t use people for other things.
Kant cont’d

So, if we take Kant’s argument as
valid, then we, as rational beings,
have a duty to always act for the
universally good. We determine what
is universally good by way of the
categorical imperative.
A picture of Kant for you

Sometimes it’s good
to see the face of
the thinker. I don’t
know why.
Immanuel Kant
Bentham/Mill:
Utilitarianism



Utilitarianism takes a different
approach to morality than deontology.
Where deontology considers the
means and motivation and all the
“pre-activity” factors, utilitarianism
considers the end result alone.
For this reason, utilitarianism is a kind
of consequentialism.
Bentham/Mill:
Utilitarianism


The motto: “The greatest good for the
greatest number.”
This means: Do that which will bring
about good for the majority of people
involved.
Bentham/Mill:
Utilitarianism

Problems arise, of course:
– According to utilitarianism, you could
morally break into a wealthy person’s
home, steal valuables, and sell them, as
long as you donate some of that money
to charity, as this will bring about good
for many in need, and bad only for the
wealthy person.
Bentham/Mill:
Utilitarianism
Jeremy Bentham
John Stuart Mill
Aristotle: Virtue Ethics


Aristotle’s ethics emphasize the
importance of VIRTUE.
Virtue can be discovered by way of the
GOLDEN MEAN:
– Virtue is the property in between a
DEFECT and an EXCESS (both vices).
– Cowardice --- Courage --- Recklessness
Aristotle: Virtue Ethics


Modern virtue ethics is only loosely
based on Aristotle. There are as many
theories of virtue ethics as there are
virtue ethicists.
One thing central to all virtue ethics:
– The importance of CHARACTER.
Aristotle: Virtue Ethics

Rather than focusing on ETHICAL
ACTIONS, like deontology or
utilitarianism, virtue ethics focuses on
the ETHICAL PERSON.
How does this fit in with
ethics in security &
networking?

Ethical policies in any field are decided
upon by management. I propose that
the most practical approach to ethics
in the field of security and networking
is the Aristotelian – virtue ethics.
How does this fit in?


Deontology relies on human reason.
Someone could in theory follow the
categorical imperative and come to the
wrong conclusion.
Utilitarianism justifies a good end by
any means necessary. Clearly, this
could have bad results; the means are
important.
How does this fit in?

Virtue ethics builds an ethically good
character, who by definition will uphold
ethics in the workplace. A good ethics
policy will build an ethical employee.
Policy, finally.

According to SANS:
– Executives should set a good example.
– Executives should keep an open door
policy for recommendations, etc.
– Employees should treat everyone fairly,
have mutual respect, promote a team
environment.
– Employees must exercise intelligence and
effort to maintaining an ethical character.
Policy

To maintain ethical practices:
– Start at the top. All employees should
maintain an ethical stance and support
ethical behavior.
– Employees should encourage open
dialogue, get honest feedback, and treat
everyone fairly, with honesty and
objectivity.
Policy – Unethical Behavior

Policy should have no place for:
– Harassment or discrimination
– Unauthorized use of trade secrets &
marketing, operational, personnel,
financial, source code, or technical
information
– Personal use of corporate assets or
business relationships
The End


Finally.
Questions?