Transcript 4: Law and Order

Psychology
Unit 4: Developmental Psychology
Essential Task 4-7: Compare and contrast
Kohlberg and Gilligan’s models of moral
development.
Adulthood
Types of Studies
Adolescence
Unit 4
Developmental
Psych
Prenatal
Development
Adulthood
Aging
We are
here
Cognitive
Development
Piaget’s
Stages
Moral
Development
Vygotsky’s
Theory
Social
Kohlberg
Development
Erikson
Parenting
Styles
Gender
Gilligan
Heinz Dilemma
In Europe, a woman was near death from a special kind of cancer.
There was one drug that the doctors thought might save her. It was
a form of radium that a druggist in the same town had recently
discovered. The drug was expensive to make, but the druggist was
charging ten times what the drug cost him to make. He paid $200
for the radium and charged $2,000 for a small dose of the drug.
The sick woman's husband, Heinz, went to everyone he knew to
borrow the money, but he could only get together about $ 1,000
which is half of what it cost. He told the druggist that his wife was
dying and asked him to sell it cheaper or let him pay later. But the
druggist said: "No, I discovered the drug and I'm going to make
money from it." So Heinz got desperate and broke into the man's
store to steal the drug-for his
Morality Development: Piaget
• Responses to moral problems can be
divided into two broad stages:
 Moral Realism (Morality of Constraint)
– Rules are concrete, consequences determine
all guilt (6 year olds)
 Moral Relativism (Morality of
Cooperation)
– Rules are flexible, intent is important in
determining guilt (12 year olds)
Ethics Vs Morality
What is the difference between the two?
Morals are how you treat people you
know. Ethics are how you treat people
you don’t know.
Morality is primarily about making
correct choices, while ethics is about
proper reasoning
Trolley problem
You see that a runway train is hurtling
down a track, and that is going to hit a
group of 5 people standing in its path
and will certainly kill them all. However,
you happen to be stand next to a switch
that can divert the train down another
track where only a single person is
standing.
What would you do?
Trolley problem Cont
Suppose that there is no switch,
but that you are instead standing
on a bridge over the railway track
next to a very fat man, and you
are sure that if you pushed him
onto the track his bulk (but not
yours) would be sufficient to stop
the train before it hit the group of
people. What do you think now?
Should you kill the fat man?
Morality Development: Kohlberg
• Level I: Pre-conventional: Egocentric orientation focusing on moral
consequences for the self; reasoning found until about 10 years of age
Stage
1: Punishment Obedience
2: Individualism and
Exchange
Description
Moral reasoning based on immediate
consequences for the individual. An
act is moral if a person isn’t punished
for it. It is immoral if the person is
punished.
Moral reasoning based on reciprocity.
An act is moral if a similar act occurs
in return (i.e. satisfies own needs)
Morality Development: Kohlberg
• Level II: Conventional: Moral reasoning linked to perspectives of, and
concerns for, others (i.e. loyalty, obeying the law, family obligation); typical
of 10 to 20 yr olds.
Stage
3: Good boy-nice girl
4: Law and Order
Description
Moral reasoning based on concern for
others or the opinions of others. An
act is moral if others demonstrate
similar acts, or it helps others (i.e.
behavior likely to please others)
Moral reasoning based on rules, laws,
and orderly society. An act is moral if
it follows rules or promotes an orderly
society.
Morality Development: Kohlberg
• Level III: Post-conventional. Reasoning transcends society’s rules; reflects
an understanding that rules sometimes need to be changed/ignored.
Stage
Description
5: Social Contract
Moral reasoning based on principled
agreements among people. An act is
moral if it is consistent with a
principled agreement. (ex: Bill of Rights)
6: Universal Ethical
Moral reasoning based on abstract
principles. An act is moral if it is
consistent with an abstract principle
that transcends an individual’s
society.
Summary of Kohlberg’s Six Stage Theory of Morality Development:
1: Punishment and Obedience
Moral reasoning based on immediate consequences for the individual.
2: Market Exchange
Moral reasoning based on reciprocity. An act is moral if a similar act occurs in
return.
3: Interpersonal Harmony
Moral reasoning based on concern for others or the opinions of others.
4: Law and Order
Moral reasoning based on rules, laws, and an orderly society.
5: Social Contract
Moral reasoning based on principled agreements among people.
6: Universal Principles
Moral reasoning based on abstract principles.
Morality Development: Exercise (I)
1. If I stay out I will be in big trouble with my parents.
Stage 1: Punishment and Obedience
Preconventional Ethics: Young children, some teenagers
2. It’s not like they’ve never broken a promise to me.
Stage 2: Individualism and Exchange
Preconventional Ethics: Young children, some teenagers
3. My parents and I agreed that midnight was fair, and you
can’t go back on your agreements.
Stage 5: Social Contract
Postconventional Ethics: Middle school to high school
students
4. If I stay out my parents will be worried.
Stage 3: Good boy-nice girl
Conventional Ethics: Middle school to high school students
Morality Development: Exercise (II)
5.
It’s the curfew, so I’ll be in by midnight.
Stage 4: Law and order
Conventional Ethics: Middle school to high school
students
6.
My friends have curfews, too, and they’re going to be
home by then.
Stage 3: Good boy Nice Girl
Conventional Ethics: Middle school to high school
students
Piaget, Kohlberg, and Gilligan:
Moral Development
• Criticisms of Kohlberg’s Theory
 Acceleration of moral development
through instruction is limited
 Moral dilemmas are too removed from
everyday social interactions
 Too much emphasis on moral reasoning
and not enough on moral behavior
 Research sample (white males) limits the
generalizability of the findings
Morality Development: Gender
Differences
• Are there gender differences? Do men and
women approach moral dilemmas differently?
• Some suggest:
• Men: judgment on abstract concepts (justice,
rules, individual rights)
• Women: Interpersonal connections and attention
to human needs
• Ultimately, findings mixed
• Kohlberg focused exclusively on
cognitive aspects of moral
reasoning/development
Piaget, Kohlberg, and Gilligan:
Moral Development
• Gilligan’s View of Identity and Moral
Development
• Student of Kohlberg and later became
critical of some of him
• Females develop along different path
– Preconventional. Care is egocentric
– Conventional. Care results from internalized
focus on others, while neglecting oneself
– Postconventional. Critical of approach in
Conventional stage; Learn to balance caring
for self with caring for others.