The Measurement of Mental Disorder

Download Report

Transcript The Measurement of Mental Disorder

The Measurement of Mental
Disorder
Why is it so difficult to determine who
is mentally disordered when
interviewing people in the community?
1
Why do community sampling?
 Helpful in formulating mental health policy
 Helpful in evaluating theories of causation
 Helpful in planning delivery of mental health
services
 Helpful in justifying requests for funding to
support research and service provision
2
2 Major Epidemiologic Studies
 Epidemiologic Catchment Area (ECA) Project


Robins & Regier, 1991
Surveyed samples of general population in 5 sites—New
Haven, CT to Los Angeles, CA
 National Comorbidity Survey (NCS)


Kessler et al., 1994
Focused on degree to which different disorders appeared
in same individual
3
Difficulties Encountered
 Prevalence rates of mental disorders seem to be too
high


ECA found that 1/3 of Americans suffer from a mental
disorder at one point in their lives
NCS figure was 1/2
 Although the studies used similar instruments, the
results were quite different in many areas


ECA estimated that 6% of Americans suffer from a
depressive disorder at some point in their lives
NCS estimated 17%
4
Clinical prevalence vs. true
prevalence
 Why not just count the number of people in clinical
settings?
 Clinical prevalence of mental disorder is not a
measure of true prevalence

Clinical prevalence is a measure of how many people
seek and receive treatment; true prevalence is a measure
of how many people have mental disorders, whether or
not they seek or receive treatment
 It’s the rate of untreated mental disorder that is
important for planning purposes.
5
What does socioeconomic status (SES)
have to do with mental disorder?
 Diverse mix of services may not be accessible, especially in
lower-class communities


In lower class communities, there are fewer office therapists
available (poor people can’t afford them)
Poor people more likely to use public hospitals; middle and upperclass people more likely to use office therapists
 Social class, ethnicity, and gender have an effect on how
mental disorders are expressed, diagnosed, and handled
 Lower SES people may be under more chronic stress, may
be more prone to develop mental disorders
6
Conceptual validity
 Measurement tool has conceptual validity when it is
successful in distinguishing between persons who
have a mental disorder and those who don’t
 Too expensive to have clinicians interviewing large
community samples, so questionnaires are used. It
is very difficult to create a questionnaire that has
conceptual validity.
7
Back to the DSM
 Basic idea is that disorders can be recognized by
symptoms
 DSM gives rules for deciding, from symptoms,
which disorder a person has, if any
 DSM is theory-neutral
 DSM is useful tool for psychiatric epidemiologists
8
Fundamental question
 What is mental disorder, and how does it
differ from the “normal suffering of everyday
life” of “problems in living”?
 According to DSM, pattern of symptoms that
is identified must be associated with distress,
disability, dysfunction. Dysfunction must be
harmful. Disturbance must not be only a
conflict between an individual and society.
9
Validity
 Criteria for classifying a disorder must be:


Sensitive: when applied the criteria should not
indicate that someone is normal when, in fact,
they have a disorder (false negative)
Specific: when applied the criteria should not
indicate that someone has a disorder when they
are normal (false positive)
10
More on validity
 False positives more of a problem than false
negatives—because the normal population is
much larger than the disordered population.
 If there are many false positives, the
estimated prevalence of a disorder can be
very much overestimated.
11
Problem with using DSM
criteria in epidemiology
 DSM is designed to be used in a clinical
setting, where clinicians have the luxury of
refining the diagnosis after several
interviews.
 Questionnaires used in community surveys
give epidemiologist a quick diagnosis, one
that cannot be refined later.
12
Problems with epidemiological
studies of mental disorders
 No matter how carefully the instrument for
measurement is developed, sample is
selected, and data is collected, if the
definitions of mental disorders do not give a
clear picture of the disorders, then the studies
will be flawed.
 Question: How else could we estimate the
prevalence of mental disorders?
13