Transcript Assessment - What Evidence do You Accept?

Natural Selection Problem
Goals: Students will be able to
1. Design a testable hypothesis
2. Analyze and interpret a simulation
about an ecological problem
3. explain how evolution actually works.
Pre-test: Explain the changes that occurred in the tree and animal. Use your
current understanding of evolution by natural selection.
Pre-test Analyses



Instructor read responses to assess
students’ prior knowledge and
misconceptions.
Responses will be coded and compared with
post-test writings.
Analysis pending…
Hummingbird Video
www.pbs.org
What are the four
processes required
for natural selection?
Sex and the Single Guppy
www.pbs.org
Introduction to the Question



In pools with many predators, male
guppies are drab colored.
In pools with few predators, male
guppies have bright coloration.
Why is there a difference?
Guppy Gallery
Design a Testable Hypothesis


In your groups, develop a hypothesis
to explain the observed pattern of
fish coloration in the pools.
Design an experiment to test your
hypothesis.
Experimental Simulation


Before each simulation begins, predict
what will happen, based on your
hypothesis.
As the simulation is running, your
group will record data for each
generation.
Simulation 1
Results - Simulation 1
Data Table - Simulation 1
Simulation 2
Results - Simulation 2
Data Table - Simulation 2
Data Analysis



On your carbonless paper, plot a line graph
of the changing proportions of color
pattern over time.
What is the independent variable? Which
axis should you plot it on?
Which is the dependent variable? Which
axis should you plot it on?
Low Predation
High Predation
Analysis


Do these data match your prediction
(support your hypothesis)?
Why or why not?
Questions for Discussion



What determines the color pattern of an
individual guppy?
What role(s) does color play in guppy
survival and reproduction?
Explain the results in terms of fitness and
natural selection. Describe how sexual
selection and natural selection push in
opposite directions.
Questions for Assessment
(from Anderson et al., 2002)
A typical natural population of guppies consists of hundreds
of guppies. Which statement best describes the guppies of
a single species in an isolated population?
a.
b.
c.
d.
The guppies share all of the same characteristics and
are identical to each other.
The guppies share all of the essential characteristics
of the species; the minor variations they display don’t
affect survival
The guppies are all identical on the inside, but have
many differences in appearance.
The guppies share many essential characteristics, but
also vary in many features.
Student Responses on Midterm
(n=176)
Questions for Assessment
(from Anderson et al., 2002)
Fitness is a term often used by biologists to explain the
evolutionary success of certain organisms. Which feature
would a biologist consider to be most important in
determining which guppies were the “most fit”?
a.
b.
c.
d.
large body size and ability to swim quickly away from predators
excellent ability to compete for food
high number of offspring that survived to reproductive age
high number of matings with many different females
Student Responses on Midterm
(n=176)
Questions for Assessment
(from Anderson et al., 2002)
In guppy populations, what are the primary changes that
occur gradually over time?
a.
b.
c.
d.
The traits of each individual guppy within a population
gradually change.
The proportions of guppies having different traits within a
population change.
Successful behaviors learned by certain guppies are
passed on to offspring.
Mutations occur to meet the needs of the guppies as the
environment changes.
Student Responses on Midterm
(n=176)
Final Exam Assessments



Analogous questions from Anderson et
al., 2002 - Canary Island Lizards
The final exam was optional; 72 of 182
students chose not to take the final
The following data are from the 110
who took the final
Questions for Assessment
(from Anderson et al., 2002)
Fitness is a term used by biologists to explain the
evolutionary success of certain organisms. Below are
descriptions of four fictional lizards. Which lizard would a
biologist consider to be the “most fit?”
a.
b.
c.
d.
Very healthy, strong, and clever - 10 offspring surviving to
adulthood
Has mated with many lizards - 28 offspring surviving to
adulthood
Dark colored and very quick - 22 offspring surviving to
adulthood
Has the largest territory of all the lizards - 26 offspring
surviving to adulthood
Student Responses on Final
(n=110)
Questions for Assessment
(from Anderson et al., 2002)
According to the theory of natural selection, where did the
variations in body size in the three species of lizards most
likely come from?
a.
b.
c.
d.
The lizards needed to change in order to survive, so
beneficial new traits developed
The lizards wanted to become different size, so beneficial
new traits gradually appeared in the population.
Random genetic changes and sexual recombination both
created new varieties.
The island environment caused genetic changes in the
lizards.
Student Responses on Final
(n=110)
Questions for Assessment
(from Anderson et al., 2002)
What would cause one species to change into three species
over time?
a.
b.
c.
d.
Groups of lizards encountered different island
environments so the lizards needed to become new species
with different traits in order to survive.
Groups of lizards must have been geographically isolated
from other groups and random genetic changes must have
accumulated in the lizard populations over time.
There may be minor variations, but all lizards are
essentially alike and are members of a single species.
In order to survive, different groups of lizards needed to
adapt to the different islands, and so all organisms in each
group gradually evolved to become new lizard species.
Student Responses on Final
(n=110)
Final Exam: Explain the changes that occurred in the tree and animal. Use your
current understanding of evolution by natural selection. Analysis pending…