Transcript Your Future Electric Service - Smart Grid Research Consortium

Our utility paradigm is changing…
will YOU be ready?
Paul Kalv
Smart Grid Research Consortium
Electric Director
October 20, 2011
Chief Smart Grid Systems Architect
City of Leesburg, Florida
Leesburg Overview
 23,000 electric customers also provide gas, water & internet.
 9,700 (42%) AMR electric – 18,900 (34%) AMR total meters.
(Discontinued further AMR deployment 2007)
 140 residential electric meter AMI pilot deployed January 2008.
 Completed AMI Business Case December 2009.
 $19,500,000 SGIG from DOE & $1,240,000 EECBG from State
 Vendor selection completed… working on Best and Final Price
Thoughts on Where to Start
 Identify YOUR one or two Biggest Issues
 Power Supply Costs
 Reliability
 Workforce Retention
 System Losses
 ???
Top Priority... Reduce Peak Demand
Power Supply Demand Rates
$30.00
$25.00
Combined
$ per kW
$20.00
$15.00
Capacity
$10.00
$5.00
Transmission
$FY 2006
FY 2007
FY 2008
FY 2009
FY 2010
What was Bad… is getting Worse!
Historic ARP Demand Rates
35
Projected
30
Combined
$ per kW
25
20
15
Capacity
10
5
Transmission
0
FY
FY
2007
FY
2008
FY
2009
FY
2010
FY
2011
FY
2012
FY
2013
Startling Realization
 All kilo-watt-hours are:
NOT CREATED EQUAL - Cost Differences
Energy Rate ≈ $0.05 / kWh
Peak Hour ≈ $20.05 (400 x)
Gas: $3.50 / gal.
Peak Hour: $1,403.50 (400 x)
 The lowest cost kilo-watt-hour is:
The kilo-watt hour NOT GENERATED
Charges Based on Coincident Peak
Where Did We Start?
1. Developed a Vision
2. Identified 4 Broad Goals
3. Focused efforts on developing Strategies
Leesburg’s 2020 Vision
Leesburg will operate the best and most secure electric
grid available in the country by the year 2020 by
incorporating information and control technologies
that can support four goals:
 (1) empowering consumers,
 (2) rewarding conservation and energy efficiency,
 (3) improving distribution reliability and resiliency
 (4) expanding the use of renewable energy, distributed
generation, and alternative technologies.
Focus - Empowering Consumers
 AMI Related Technologies
 Advanced Metering Infrastructure (Focus: Consumer Needs not Technology)
 Smart Meters.
 Communications network, or 2 or 3 or 4…. or more
 Meter Data Management System
 Communications infrastructure and meter installation
 Enterprise Service Bus
 Field Acceptance Testing
 Home Area Network
 In Home Display and web portal
 Programmable Communicating Thermostat
 Direct Load Control
 Pay-as-you-go
Focus: Rewarding Efficiency & Conservation
 Energy Efficiency & Conservation Initiatives
 Consumer Education & Information to change behavior
 Communications Plan
 Who to notify
 When to notify
 How to notify
 Create Focus Groups to receive consumer input
 Time Differentiated Rate Schedules – offer choices
 TOU, PTR, Direct Load Control, Other
 Utility control or Consumer control
 Security and Personally Identifiable Information(PII)
Focus – Improving Reliability and Resiliency
 Reliability and Resiliency Initiatives (Automation)
 Cyber Security
 Substation Power Transformer w/Smart Grid monitoring
 Distribution Transformer Monitoring
 Integrated Distributed Generation
 Communicating Distribution Automation equipment
 SCADA Upgrades
 Communicating Faulted Circuit Indicators
 Trip Saver Cutouts
 Integrated Volt/VAR Control
Focus – Expanding the use of Renewable Energy,
Distributed Generation, and Alternative Technologies
 “Preparing for the Future” Initiatives - (Complete)
 Integrating customer owned Solar PV systems
 Integrated Distributed Generation – Utility and
Customer
 “Preparing for the Future” Initiatives - (Future)
 Integrating PHEV Load and Storage
 2 MW Battery Storage at each of our 5 substations
 ???
Current and Emerging Technologies
Ready Now:
 Demand Response
 DG & Renewable Resources
 Distribution Automation
 Metering – (Reliability and remote upgrade issues)
 Meter Data Management Systems
 Outage Management Systems
 Field Installation Services
 Business Process Change Management
 Pay-as-you-go
Current and Emerging Technologies
Good Improvement and Choices – will become better:
 AMI Communications – (DA monitoring and control?)
 DAN Communications
 Customer Web Portal
 In Home Display
 ZigBee vs. WiFi
 Storage – huge potential for reliability and DR benefits
Current and Emerging Technologies
Future – Not yet ready for prime time:
 Home Area Networks
 Standards are slow to emerge
 Smart Appliances
Leesburg’s Distribution Smart Grid Landscape
Control Center
Meter &
Billing
CIS
GIS
AMI
Head-end
Mobile Data
System
Communications
Communications
(Existing Fiber)
(Existing Fiber)
PTZ Network
Camera
Substation
Substation
SCADA
OMS
Gateway
Communications
LTC, Voltage
Regulator,
and/or
Capacitor
Control
Feeder
Protection
FCI
FCI
Feeder
Monitor
Feeder
Automation
Network
(DAN)
Voltage
Regulator
Control
PTZ Network
Camera
Wide Area
Network
(WAN)
FCI
FCI
Feeder
Protection
Line
Recloser
Neighborhood
Area Network
(NAN)
Revenue Meters
Building
Automation
System
Switch
Control
Capacitor
Control
Switch
Control
Customer Generation
& Energy Storage
Leesburg’s DR Strategy To Date
 Strategies
 Conversation Voltage Reduction (CVR)
 Integrated Distributed Generation - City Gensets (IDG)
 Partnering with hospital and two Supermarkets (LRCR)
 Results
 Saved $1st MM in 14 months
 Saved $2nd MM in 7 months and 3rd MM in 7 months
CVR
IDG
LRCR
 FY 2010 31.0 MW $591 K
35.2 MW $654 K
11 MW
$222 K
 FY 2011
42.8 MW $861 K
15 MW
$304 K
24.6 MW $492 K
AMI Evaluation &Vendor Selection
 Began with very comprehensive and detailed proposal
 Selected top four proposals for final consideration
 Weighted Score used to Rank final four vendors
 Final four presented a 3 day AMI demonstration
 Demonstration script and DA controllers
 Major emphasis on demonstrating ability to deliver
Distribution Functions
 Secondary emphasis on gaining a better understanding
of the technology and observing team interaction and
problem solving
Final Evaluation Spreadsheet
AMI Proposal Evaluation Matrix
GOOD
FAIR
POOR
Evaluation Element
AMI Communications Infrastructure
EVALUATION
LEGEND
Business Process Org Change Mgmt
Customer Web Portal
Electric Metering
Enterprise Service Bus Integration
Home Area Network
Metering Communication Installation
Meter Data Management System
Operational Transition
Prepay Metering
Project Management Oversight
Validating Field Performance AMI System
Demand Response Management System*
* Not an evaluation element
pdk 5-27-2011
Vendor
Vendor
Vendor
Vendor
Overall #1
Overall #2
Overall #3
Overall #4
8 Field Demonstration Sites
DA Controllers at each Site
Location
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
1
Tower
Recloser
Control
Switch
Control
Regulator
Control
Recloser
Control
Capacitor
Control
2
3
Head End
Recloser
Control
Switch
Control
Regulator
Control
Recloser
Control
Capacitor
Control
Com to
Enclosed
meters & Gen.
Control
Purpose
City
Provided
Equipment
Meter Encl.
Vendor
Provided
Equipment
Collector, and
Form 2S meter,
& Communicate
w/ devices
Notes
Controller:
*SEL 651R &
*SEL 351S
Meter Encl.
Controller:
*SEL 2414
Form 2S meter
& Communicate
w/ devices
Form 2S
meter &
Communicate
w/ devices
*SEL equipment
RS-232, RJ45
DNP 3.0
Modbus
IEC 61850
Meter Encl.
Controller:
*SEL 2431
**IP Camera
Meter Encl.
Controller:
ABB RER620
ABB PCD
Meter Encl.
Controller:
QEI eCAP II and
*SEL 734B
Meter Encl.
Woodward
Easy Gen 3000, &
**IP Camera
2 Meter Encl.
Form 2S meter
& Communicate
w/ devices
Form 2S meter
& Communicate
w/ device
Form 2S meter &
Communicate w/
device
Form 9S meter
Form 16S meter
Antenna?
**IP Camera:
Panasonic BBHCM580A PTZ
Network
Camera
- Form 9S installed
in steel cabinet
- Form 16S
installed in
building
Business Case & Cash Flow
 Desire project AMI elements to have good payback
 DA equipment treated as Capital Improvements
 Original AMI Business Case prepared in 2009
 First 2011 Project Cash Flow – Breakeven in year 19
 A dagger to the heart
 Revised 2011 project Cash Flow – Breakeven in year 6
 Working to be cash positive in year one!
 Customer Participation Required for Success!!!
Next Steps
 Finalize Communications/Marketing Plan
 Replicate successes of others
 Finalize Rate and Rebate offerings
 Share the savings
 Revise business processes for operational benefits
 One of the AMI elements
 Revise business policies for operational benefits
 Changing what we do as well as how we do it
Closing Thoughts to Consider
 Attack your biggest issues – our needs are different
 Focus on your Consumer - not the technology
 Create a Vision and Goals - to drive your strategies
 Prepare a Business Case – you may be surprised
 Smart Grid entry points – start with what you have
 AMI or Distribution Automation
 Learn from others – Good, Bad, and Ugly
 Replicate only the GOOD
 Your business model will change – back office impacts
 You must take action to compete!
Questions?
Acknowledgement and Disclaimer
 Acknowledgement: This material is based upon work supported by the
Department of Energy under Award Number DE-OE-0000236.
 Disclaimer: This report was prepared as an account of work sponsored
by an agency of the United States Government. Neither the United
States Government nor any agency thereof, nor any of their employees,
makes any warranty, express or implied, or assumes any legal liability or
responsibility for the accuracy, completeness, or usefulness of any
information, apparatus, product, or process disclosed, or represents
that its use would not infringe privately owned rights. Reference
herein to any specific commercial product, process, or service by trade
name, trademark, manufacturer, or otherwise does not necessarily
constitute or imply its endorsement, recommendation, or favoring by
the United States Government or any agency thereof. The views and
opinions of authors expressed herein do not necessarily state or reflect
those of the United States Government or any agency thereof.
Good luck, have fun, and…
HANG ON TIGHT!
Thank YOU
[email protected]