Transcript Human Subject Experimentation – Nazis – Present

Human Subject Experimentation
The Nazis
Lessons for Contemporary Research
The Role of the Physician in Society
Martin Donohoe
“When a doctor [goes] wrong, he is the first
of criminals. He has nerve and he has
knowledge.”
- Sherlock Holmes to Dr. Watson, Arthur
Conan Doyle
Nazi Medicine
• Guiding philosophy = Hegelian (rational
utility)
• Social Darwinism - parallels in American
and British Eugenics Movement
– medical journals relatively silent
• Ethics reduces morality to efficiency,
economics, and aesthetics
Nazi Medicine
• An arm of state policy
• Focus on racial purity
– from eugenic sterilization (370,000)
– to involuntary euthanasia (70,000)
– to large-scale genocide (over 6 million)
Nazi Medicine
• Individual worth stated in economic terms;
propaganda re obligations to the state
– “I Accuse”
– “Mathematics in the Service of Political
Education”
Nazi Medicine
• Doctoring the nation more important than
doctoring individuals - Nazism as “applied
biology” (Rudolph Hess)
• Focus on preventive medicine and public health:
anti-tobacco and anti-alcohol campaigns,
environmental toxins, organic farming
to improve Aryan stock
• Nazi soldiers given anabolic steroids to increase
aggresiveness
Nazi Physicians
• 52,000 physicians
• National Socialist Party Members
• Jews ostracized; replaced by young Aryans
– today 0.2% of German physicians are Jews, c/w
17% pre-Nazis
– 5% of non-Aryans committed suicide; 25%
murdered
Nazi Physicians
• Economic hard times, physicians salaries
rise, academic perks
• Blutkitt (“blood cement”)
• Rare resistance
– Catholics
– Marxists
– Dutch
Nazi “Physician-Researchers”
(Torturers)
• Dr. Sigmund Rascher - coagulation/amputation
studies; hypothermia experiments
• Dr. Karl Gebhart: heteroplastic transplantation
experiments
– c.f. Stalin’s attempts to create interspecies (halfmen/half-apes) “super-warriors”
• Drs. Karl Clausberg and Viktor Brack: Xirradiation/sterilization
Nazi “Physician-Researchers”
(Torturers)
• Drs. Joachim Mrugowsky, Erwin Ding-Schuler,
and Waldemar Hoven: IV phenol and gasoline
executions
• Dr. Friedrich Wegener (“Wegener’s
Granulomatosis”): German pathologist, Nazi party
member, autopsied a prisoner with oxygen
injected into his bloodstream in an embolism
study; may have participated in experiments on
concentration camp inmates
Nazi “Physician-Researchers”
(Torturers)
• Dr Hans Conrad Reiter (formerly “Reiter’s
Syndrome”, now “reactive arthritis”): senior
Nazi official
• Dr. Joseph Mengele: Septicemia/twin
vivisection studies
• Dr. Hans Eppinger - “father of modern
hepatology”
“Indirect Participants”
• Prof. J Hallevorden: “Look here now, boys,
if you are going to kill all these people at
least take the brains out so that the material
could be utilized … the more (brains) the
better….I accepted these brains of course.
Where they came from and how they came
to me was really none of my business.”
Doctors and Resistance
• German invasion of Poland (1939)
• Drs Eugene Lazowski and Stanislaw
Matulewicz created a fake typhus epidemic,
using a harmless bacterium to innoculate
non-Jews, knowing that infected Jews
would be summarily executed
• Germans fooled, quarantined area, many
Jews escaped death
Nuremberg Doctors’ Trial
• 23 German physicians tried
• 16 found guilty
– 7 hanged (incl. Gebhardt, Brack,
Hoven, and Mrugowsky)
Nuremberg Doctors’ Trial
• Rascher died before trial
• Mengele fled for Argentina (remains
verified 1985)
• Hallevorden committed suicide before trial
• Otto Ambros (chemist) – invented sarin
(nerve gas), convicted of mass murder at
Nuremberg Trials, later freed and worked
with US chemical industry on thalidomide
Nuremberg Code
• Voluntary consent is absolutely essential
• Avoidance of unnecessary physical and
mental suffering
• Option to quit/responsibility to terminate
• Other safeguards
Declaration of Geneva
• “I will not permit considerations of religion,
nationality, race, party politics or social standing
to intervene between my duty and my patient”
• “I will not use my medical knowledge contrary
to the laws of humanity.”
• “It is unethical for physicians to employ
scientific knowledge to imperil health or destroy
life.”
Declaration of Helsinki
• Patients’ rights to respect, self
determination, informed decision-making
• Investigators’ duties: primacy of subjects’
welfare, ethical considerations take
precedence over laws and regulation
• Allows for surrogate consent
Japanese Abuses in WW II
• Extensive biological and chemical weapons
program involving prisoners of war
• Over 10,000 doctors and researchers
involved (led by Shiro Ishii, Chief Medical
Officer of the Imperial Japanese Army)
Japanese Abuses in WW II
• “Experiments:”
– Deliberate infections with plague, cholera, typhoid,
anthrax, and TB
– Testing of drugs and vaccines not previously tested in
animals
– Surgeries (for training purposes) without anesthesia,
followed by vivisection/death
– Detonation of bombs, followed by vivisections
– Number of victims unclear, likely in six figure range
• Subjects referred to as maruta (“logs”)
Japanese Abuses in WW II
• Many participants later achieved positions
of prominence in Japanese medical schools
and societies
– E.g., Tokyo Prefectural University, Olympic
Committee, Green Cross, Japanese NIH, and
private sector companies
Japanese Abuses in WW II
• U.S. government made secret deal with Ishii and top
collaborators - 250,000 yen and immunity from
prosecution in exchange for exclusive access to data
• Japanese scientists brought to Fort Detrick, MD, to help
establish U.S. biological/chemical weapons program
– Unclear if Ishii went to Ft. Detrick or stayed in Japan;
may have opened children’s clinic, converted to
Christianity prior to death in 1967
– U.S. has never apologized for protecting these war
criminals
Post-WW II
• Over 700 Nazi rocket scientists and their
families brought to the U.S. (including
Werner von Braun) to help build nuclear
missile program
– Operation Paperclip
Post-WW II
• German Medical Association
unanimously issues blunt,
straightforward apology for its role
in the Holocaust (2012)
Post-WW II Human Subject
Experimentation
• James Ketchum (psychiatrist), L Wilson
Green (scientist), Van Murray Sim –
psychochemical warfare studies for US
Army
– Ketchum later joined faculty of University of
Texas Medical School
Post-WW II Human Subject
Experimentation
• Tuskegee Syphilis Study
– “The men’s status did not warrant ethical
debate. They were subjects, not patients;
clinical material, not sick people.”
• Dr John Heller, Director of Venereal
Diseases at PHS between 1943 and
1948 (interviewed in 1976)
Studies on Native Americans
• Sterilizations
• Radioactive iodine to study adaptation of
thyroid gland to extreme cold
• Forced removal of children to English
language, religious schools (c.f., Australia)
• Distrust and reluctance of minorities to
participate in medical research
Research on Prisoners
• Very common historically (infectious diseases,
radiation, pharmaceuticals, illicit drugs)
• 1905: cholera experiments on “volunteers”
• 1915: Joseph Goldberger – pellagra studies
– Prisoners pardoned or paroled in exchange for
participation
• 1941: Physician William Black infects children
with herpes virus, paper published by J Peds
Post-WW II Human Subject
Experimentation
• Pharmaceutical and government sponsored
studies on prisoners
– 1940s and 1950s esp.
– Halted in mid-1970s after drug company
executives admitted prisoners were cheaper to
use than chimpanzees
• WW II: gonorrhea, gas gangrene, dengue
fever, malaria
Post-WW II Human Subject
Experimentation
• Guatemala STD study (1946-8)
– U.S. researchers deliberately infected 1,308
prisoners, military conscripts, prostitutes,
orphans (provided by Sisters of Charity), and
mental health patients with gonorrhea and
syphilis
– Scientists treated 87% of those infected (10%
later required re-treatment), lost track of 13%
Post-WW II Human Subject
Experimentation
• Guatemala STD study (1946-8)
– Wives, children, and grandchildren treated, but
sexual contacts not traced
– Study approved by Guatemalan government
• Received material for resource-starved institutions
in return
– Subjects received cigarettes for participating
Post-WW II Human Subject
Experimentation
• Guatemala STD study (1946-8)
– U.S. apologized (2010), has pledged $1 million
to study research ethics, $775,000 to fight
STDs in Guatemala
– Class action lawsuit against U.S. government
filed on behalf of 700 victims/relatives (2011)
Post-WW II Human Subject
Experimentation
• Guatemala STD study (1946-8)
– Dr. John Cutler (research coordinator): “Unless
the law winks occasionally, you have no
progress in medicine”
– In 1943, Cutler infected volunteer federal
prisoners in Indiana with gonorrhea in
exchange for cash
Post-WW II Human Subject
Experimentation
• Guatemala STD study (1946-8)
– After Guatemala, Cutler oversaw the Tuskegee
Syphilis Study
– Was acting dean at University of Pittsburgh in
1960s
Post-WW II Human Subject
Experimentation
• University of Minnesota malaria study
(1940s)
• Drs. Thomas Francis, Jr. and Jonas Salk
infect psychiatric hospital residents with
influenza (?if consent adequate?)
Post-WW II Human Subject
Experimentation
• Atlanta, Alabama, and Terre Haute prison
gonorrhea studies (1940s and 1950s)
• Study evaluating effects of antibiotics on growth
rate (1950s, Navy recruits, mentally disabled,
Guatemalan schoolchildren)
• Patuxent prison Asian flu experiment (1957)
• U.S. govt.-sponsored radiation, LSD (MK Ultra)
experiments
Post-WW II Human Subject
Experimentation
• Pentagon/CIA experiments on soldiers and civilians
– Edgewood Arsenal Experiments (involving more than
7,000 soldiers who were exposed to at least 250
biological and chemical agents)
• Including sarin, VX, LSD, ritalin
• Caused long-term health effects
– Deliberate release of Serratia over San Francisco Bay;
radioactive cadmium over St. Louis
Post-WW II Human Subject
Experimentation
• 1963: Dr. Chester Southam injects tumor
cells into extremely infirm patients at
Jewish Hospital for Chronic Disease in NY
without informing them that the shots
contain cancer cells
– Southam later elected President of American
Association for Cancer Research
Post-WW II Human Subject
Experimentation
• Willowbrook Hepatitis Experiments (1960s)
• Pre-WW1: Joseph Goldberger’s pellagra
experiments on Mississippi prisoners
• Henry Beecher, NEJM (1966)
Post-WW II Human Subject
Experimentation
• Ongoing sterilization programs
– Buck v. Bell (USSC, 1927) – 60,000
Americans sterilized
– WI, NJ, CA, IN, NC, OR, others
– Alabama’s Governor Graves vetoed law in
1930s law citing “hazard to personal rights”
– Oregon governor Kitzhaber apologized in 2002
for the over 2500 state-forced sterilizations that
occurred between 1917 and 1983
– 2012 – NC to compensate victims
Post-WW II Human Subject
Experimentation
• Iowa elementary school race experiment
(1968; good or bad?)
• Milgram’s obedience studies (1963);
Milgram redux (2008)
• Soviet psychiatry
• US military/pharmaceutical vaccine and
medication trials in the developing world
GM foods, biopharmaceuticals
• Largest uncontrolled trial in history of
humanity
• E.g., Chinese children with vitamin A
deficiency used for feeding trials of Golden
Rice by Tufts University investigators
– Without preceding animal studies
– ? Nature of informed consent
– May violate Nuremberg Code
Research on Prisoners
• >90% of pharmaceutical industry research
in early 1970s
• Rapidly curtailed by state/federal laws and
new university regulations
• 2006: IOM approves with safeguards
– 2009: 44% of jurisdictions allow compensation
Self-Experimentation
• Albert Hoffman (LSD)
• Werner Forssmann (right heart
catheterization)
• Barry Marshall (Helicobacter pylori)
• Others
Disturbing Experiments
• Inter-species breeding (ape-man, Ilya
Ivanovich Ivanov, Guinea, 1927)
• Two-headed dog (Vladimir Petrovich
Demikhov, 1950s, Russia)
• Monster Study (Wendell Johnson, 1939,
University of Iowa) – deliberate induction
of stuttering in orphan children
Contemporary Issues and Ethical Dilemmas
• 90% of research dollars spent on diseases
affecting 10% of the world’s population
– Neglected tropical diseases
• Research on special populations (cultural
minorities, prisoners, developing world, etc.)
• Ghostwriters
• Contract Research Organizations
• Role of institutional and for-profit IRBs
Contemporary Issues and Ethical Dilemmas
• Use of placebo controls
– Various drug trials
– Anti-HIV medications and maternal-fetal
transmission(sub-Saharan Africa)
– Surfactant for neonatal RDS (Brazil, Bolivia)
– Hep A vaccine (Thailand)
– Trovan/meningitis/Nigeria (control =
inadequate ceftriaxone dose)
Contemporary Issues and Ethical Dilemmas
• Large majority of phase 3 US drug
company trial sites outside US, many in
developing countries
– Majority of developing nation trial sites
without institutional review boards
– Victims may seek redress under “Alien
Torts Statute”
• ICE drugging immigrants for deportation
Contemporary Issues and Ethical Dilemmas
• Nerve-sparing clitoroplasty as substitute for
female genital cutting
– AAP reversal of position (2010)
• Kennedy Krieger Institute (Johns Hopkins)
lead paint abatement study (1992)
Contemporary Issues and Ethical
Dilemmas
• Uninsured become research subjects to
receive needed care
• Human guinea pigs (professional lab rats)
• Parent investigators
• Neonatal analgesia
Contemporary Issues and Ethical
Dilemmas
• Under-representation of women and
minorities in clinical trials
• Trust issues:
– Racial minorities often wary of participation in
medical experiments
• Most clinical trial participants never
informed of trial results
Contemporary Issues and Ethical
Dilemmas
• Implied vs informed consent (ER research,
health information used in subsequent
research)
• Research by companies using large
databases (e.g., Facebook study on
emotional contagion through social
networks, OKCupid’s manipulation of
compatible “matches”)
Organ Donation
• 2009 survey
– 50% of adults afraid that physicians will not try
as hard to save their lives if they have agreed to
donate organs
– 44% fear their organs might be sold on the
black market
• May explain in part why only 45% of U.S.
adults have registered as organ donors
Contemporary Issues and Ethical
Dilemmas
• Informed consent for treatment –
physician/patient negotiation vs. unilateral
decision-making when treatment options
limited
• Relaxation of international research
standards by eliminating Declaration of
Helsinki standards (FDA, 2008)
Contemporary Issues and Ethical Dilemmas
• 2003: Ban on industry experiments testing safety
of pesticides/other potentially toxic chemicals in
humans lifted by NAS and EPA
– 2013 – EPA adds safeguards, issues regulations
prohibiting studies on pregnant women and
children
• Monsanto’s Roundup purchased by US
government for aerial spraying in Colombia as
part of “War on Drugs”
Contemporary Issues and Ethical
Dilemmas
• 2008: Former director of UCLA School of
Medicine’s donated body program pleads guilty to
5 year scheme to sell donated body parts to
medical, drug, and research companies, netting
more than $1 million
• Clinical Trials Registry
– Drug company noncompliance
Contemporary Issues and Ethical Dilemmas
• Physician participation in “War on Terror,”
Abu Ghraib, Guantanamo, Black Ops sites
– “Basic Science Consultation Teams”
– Co-optation of anthropologists in Iraq,
Afghanistan
– Nurses injecting psychotropic drugs to forcibly
sedate deportees
– AMA, AAP, APA oppose physician
involvement in interrogation/torture
What to do with data acquired via
unethical means?
• Eduard Pernkopf’s Atlas; Dachau
Hypothermia Experiments; Phosgene gas
experiments; biological weapons data
(offensive vs. defensive)
• Japan’s Unit 731 and biological warfare
experiments
What to do with data acquired via
unethical means?
• Move to rename “Hallevordan-Spatz
syndrome”: “pantothenate kinaseassociated degeneration” or
“neurodegeneration with brain iron
accumulation”
• Breast cancer cure scenario
What to do with data acquired via unethical
means – AMA Policy E-2.30 – Adopted 1998
• All proposed experiments using human subjects
should undergo proper ethical evaluation by a
human studies review board before being
undertaken.
• Responsibility for revealing that the data are from
unethical experiments lies in the hands of authors,
peer reviewers, and editors of medical texts that
publish results of experimental studies.
What to do with data acquired via unethical
means – AMA Policy E-2.30 – Adopted 1998
• Each publication should adopt a standard
regarding publication of data from unethical
experiments.
• If data from unethical experiments can be
replaced by existing ethically sound data
and achieve the same ends, then such must
be done.
What to do with data acquired via unethical
means – AMA Policy E-2.30 – Adopted 1998
• If ethically tainted data that have been validated by
rigorous scientific analysis are the only data of that nature
available, and such data are necessary in order to save
lives, then the utilization of such data by physicians and
editors may be appropriate.
• Should editors and/or authors decide to publish an
experiment or data from an experiment that does not reach
standards of contemporary ethical conduct, a disclaimer
should be included. Such disclosure would by no means
rectify unethical conduct or legitimize the methods of
collection of data gathered from unethical experimentation.
What to do with data acquired via unethical
means – AMA Policy E-2.30 – Adopted 1998
• This disclaimer should:
– (1) clearly describe the unethical nature of the origin of
any material being published
– (2) clearly state that publication of the data is needed in
order to save human lives
– (3) pay respect to the victims
– (4) avoid trivializing trauma suffered by the participants
– (5) acknowledge the unacceptable nature of the
experiments
– (6) endorse higher ethical standards.
What to do with data acquired via unethical
means – AMA Policy E-2.30 – Adopted 1998
• Based on both scientific and moral grounds, data obtained
from cruel and inhumane experiments, such as data
collected from the Nazi experiments and data collected
from the Tuskegee Study, should virtually never be
published or cited.
• In the extremely rare case when no other data exist and
human lives would certainly be lost without the knowledge
obtained from use of such data, publication or citation is
permissible.
• In such a case, the disclosure should cite the specific
reasons and clearly justify the necessity for citation.
What to do with data acquired via unethical
means – AMA Policy E-2.30 – Adopted 1998
• Certain generally accepted historical data
may be cited without a disclaimer, though a
disclosure of the ethical issues would be
valuable and desirable.
Ethical Perspectives on Scientific
Research and War
• Denial of moral responsibility for consequences
• Recognition of moral responsibility but competing
obligations
• Recognition of moral responsibility and refusal to
participate
• Responsibility to inform or lead public opinion
• Publication of research on dangerous/novel
pathogens
Scientists and War Research
• Archimedes, da Vinci, Galileo, Haber,
Fieser
• Farraday
• Nobel, Einstein, Szilard
Fritz Haber (Physical Chemist)
• Played major role in development of
chemical warfare in WWI
• In violation of Hague Convention of 1907
• “During peacetime a scientist belongs to the
world, but during wartime he belongs to his
country”
Fritz Haber (Physical Chemist)
• 3 future Nobel laureates served in his unit,
which developed Zyklon A (insecticide
used in gas chambers)
• Irony: Jewish, fled Germany in 1933,
ultimately took position at what is now the
Weizmann Institute in Israel
Doctors as Terrorists
• Pediatrician George Habash – founder of
Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine
– Behind aircraft hijackings of Black September
• Dr. Fathi Shiqaqi – founder of Palestinian
Islamic Jihad
Doctors as Terrorists
• Ayman Al-Zawahiri – leader of Al Qaeda
• Ikuo Hayashi – chief of circulatory
medicine at a leading Japanese hospital
– Pleaded guilty to planting sarin gas on Tokyo
subway
• Radovan Karadzic (psychiatrist) – on trial
for war crimes against Bosnian Croats and
Muslims
Doctors as Terrorists
• Dr Bilal Abdullah convicted in bungled Heathrow
Airport car bombing (2007)
• Psychiatrist Major Nidal Hasan – awaiting trial for
Fort Hood shootings (2009)
• Humam Khalil Abu-Mulal al-Balawi: Jordanian
suicide bomber, killed 7 CIA agents in
Afghanistan (2009)
Doctors as Murderers
• Dr Mehmet Resid (Ottoman middle manager,
started Butchers’ Brigade)
– Armenian slaughter
– “Those Armenian bandits were a bunch of harmful
microbes pestering the body of this nation. A doctor’s
duty is to kill microbes…”
• Bashir Assad (Syrian President, ophthalmologist)
– civilian bombings and use of sarin nerve gas
Doctors as Murderers
• Dr. H. H. Holmes, - "the torture doctor,"
• Linda Burfield Hazzard - "the starvation
doctor"
• Dr. Marcel Petiot
Doctors as Murderers
• GP Harold Shipman – world’s most notorious
serial killer (up to 400 victims) South African
cardiologist Wouter Basson (aka “Dr. Death”) –
ran “Project Coast” in 1980s (clandestine military
program linked to chemical and germ warfare,
assassinations, poisonings, kidnapping, and plots
to sterilize the country’s black population)
– Acquited of 67 criminal charges in 2002
• Others
Physician Criminals
• Violent crimes, including rapes of
patients
• Performance of unnecessary,
dangerous procedures
• Medicare fraud, kickback scams
• Ethical violations through participation
in executions
Doctors as Racists
• Long history
• Common slave era diagnosis =
drapetomania
– The tendency to run away
• More recent: Ophthalmologist John
Taunton – anti-immigrant, white
supremacist
Torture in the War on Terror
• Doctors involved in torture, extraordinary renditions
• CIA report (2014) describes horrific torture, which was not
valuable in obtaining any significant information
• American Psychological Association rewrote ethics code
to allow psychologists to participate, later apologized
– APA president-elect during rewrite called international
laws against torture a “distraction” to ethics guidance
Torture in the War on Terror
• More than 80 % of interrogation between
2005 and 2008 outsourced to Mitchell
Jessen & Associates, Spokane, WA
– Run by psychologists James Mitchell and Bruce
Jessen
– Firm collected $81 million from CIA
• Investigations, outcry, but no real
consequences
War on Terror
• Capture of Osama bin Laden involved
(unsuccessful) sham CIA hepatitis B vaccination
project to collect DNA (violation of public trust,
has harmed international efforts to eliminate polio
and put health care workers lives at risk)
– White House has pledged to end program
• USAID social media program designed to
overthrow Cuban government
– 2014 – now relations to be “normalized”
Primo Levi
“A country is considered the more
civilized the more the wisdom and
efficiency of its laws hinder a weak
man from becoming too weak or a
powerful one too powerful.”
(U.S. – largest maldistribution of wealth of
any industrialized country)
The role of the doctor in society
• Public health versus individual health
• Roles, responsibilities, and obligations
–
–
–
–
–
–
patients
society
institutions
families
government
world
The role of the doctor in society
• Theodore Billroth:
– “If the whole of Social Medicine needs to
be part of the curriculum of the medical
student, it must not take more than two
hours per semester … during the last two
semesters; otherwise, it will surely be
detrimental to his other studies”
The role of the doctor in society
• Rudolph Virchow:
– “Doctors are natural attorneys for the
poor … If medicine is to really
accomplish its great task, it must
intervene in political and social
life…”
The role of the doctor in society
• World Health Organization:
– “The role of the physician … in the
preservation and promotion of peace
is the most significant factor for the
attainment of health for all.”
Ethical Issues Relating to Mixed
Agency of Military Physicians
•
•
•
•
•
•
Triage and return to combat
Confidentiality
Communication
Loyalties/Command
Experimentation
“The Sea and Poison”
Medical Education Lacking
• 2007 survey: 5,000 medical students at 8 medical
schools, 35% response rate (Int J Hlth Serv 2007;37(4):64350)
• 94% received < 1 hr. instruction on military
medical ethics
• 3.5% aware of legislation already passed making a
“doctors’ draft” possible
• 34% did not know Geneva Conventions require
physicians to treat the sickest first, regardless of
nationality
Medical Education Lacking
• 34% not aware Geneva Conventions
prohibit ever threatening or demeaning
prisoners or depriving them of food or water
• 34% could not state when they would be
required to disobey an unethical order
(answer = always)
The Death Penalty and Health
Professionals
• AMA, APHA, ANA, and ABA
(anesthesiologists) oppose participation
of health professionals in executions
• Only 7/35 death penalty states
incorporate AMA ethics policy,
including barring doctors from taking
an active role in the death chamber
The Death Penalty and Health
Professionals
• 2001:
– 3% of physicians aware of AMA
guidelines prohibiting physician
participation
– 41% would perform at least one
action in the process of lethal
injection disallowed by AMA
Ethical Issues Relating to Mixed
Agency of Civilian Physicians
• Physician participation in torture and
executions
– Most torturers never identified/held accountable
– 2008 study at University of Illinois at Chicago
• 35% of medical students said torture could be
condoned under some circumstances
• Pharmaceutical company provision of
agents used in lethal injection executions
Contact Information
Public Health and Social Justice
Website
http://www.phsj.org
[email protected]