Transcript SOC4044 Sociological Theory Ferdinand Toennies Dr. Ronald

EDAG 641
THE LEADER AND LEARNING COMMUNITIES
Workshop 1
Ferdinand Toennies
Adapted from Ronald Keith Bolender
Tuesday, July 21, 2015
1
Ferdinand Toennies
References
Christodoulou, Stavroula. 1965. 19th-Century Sociologists.
2d ed. New York: Monarch Press.
Perdue, William D. 1986. Sociological Theory: Explanation,
Paradigm, and Ideology. Palo Alto, CA: Mayfield
Publishing Company.
Tuesday, July 21, 2015
2
Ferdinand Toennies
 1855-1936
 Born in Germany
 Experienced the industrialization of Germany
 Experienced the population explosion within Germany
 Founded the German Sociological Society (along with
Max Weber, Georg Simmel, and Werner Sombart)
Serving as its president from 1909 to 1933
 He opposed the rise of nazism and was dismissed from
his post in 1933 (when Hitler rose to power)
(Perdue 1986:77-81)
Tuesday, July 21, 2015
3
Ferdinand Toennies:
Gemeinschft und Gesellschaft
Gemeinschaft
Gesellschaft
Community
Society
Folk
Urban
Natural Will
Rational Choice
Homogeneity
Heterogeneity
(Authority and Common Will)
Tuesday, July 21, 2015
4
Ferdinand Toennies:
Theory of Gemeinschaft (Community)
The theory of Gemeinschaft assumes that
all human wills are united and that this is
their natural condition. These wills are
related either by blood or by marriage,
through three strong types of
relationships: man-wife, mother-child, and
between children of the same mother.
(Christodoulou 1965:61-65)
Tuesday, July 21,
2015
5
Ferdinand Toennies:
Theory of Gemeinschaft (Community)
The man-woman relationship is not always
long and lasting, and it is based on the sexual
instinct. Usually at the beginning of the
relationship, it is one-sided because the man
is the dominant party and the woman is
passive. Later on, when they have children,
the bond between man and woman becomes
stronger.
Tuesday, July 21,
2015
6
Ferdinand Toennies:
Theory of Gemeinschaft (Community)
The mother-child relationship is the most
important because it is a very deep one.
Nature gives the mother a helpless baby who
depends on her for food, clothing, and
general care. Consequently, the mother loves
the child very much and this is an instinctive
feeling. The child on the other hand, returns
the mother’s affection and is also grateful to
her for all that she gave him. Both mother
and child are bound together with memories
of 21,
their common past.
Tuesday, July
2015
7
Ferdinand Toennies:
Theory of Gemeinschaft (Community)
The father-child relationship resembles the
relationship between brothers and sisters,
only it is less intense. The father assumes
authority over his children and delegates his
powers to his first son in the case of
primogeniture (this means that the first son
inherits his father’s possessions and his title).
In cases where all children inherit equally,
they receive their rights directly through the
father and not through the elder brother.
Tuesday, July 21,
2015
8
Ferdinand Toennies:
Theory of Gemeinschaft (Community)
The brother-sister relationship is not based on
instinct. In the old times, marriages between
brothers and sisters were allowed, but it is now
prohibited. The children of the same mother have
memories of experiences which they had shared in
the past while they were growing up together. They
also are more alike, since they have a common
biological heritage. Consequently we can say that the
brother-sister relationship is the most “human” of
man’s characteristics.
Tuesday, July 21,
2015
9
Ferdinand Toennies:
Theory of Gemeinschaft (Community)
There are three types of Gemeinschaft: the
kinship group, the neighborhood, and
friendship.
The kinship group live in the same house in close
proximity to each other; they eat together; they
have common enemies; they must protect the
family honor; and they share common ancestors.
This type of life fosters affection and love among
members and results in a very closely-knit group.
Tuesday, July 21,
2015
10
Ferdinand Toennies:
Theory of Gemeinschaft (Community)
The neighborhood consists of several dwellings in
close proximity to one another and the inhabitants
share belief in the common deities of the village.
They also share common rituals, beliefs, and
customs. Therefore, there is a give-and-take in
the neighborhood.
Friendship is a mutual feeling of affection
between two individuals. It is created by choice;
therefore no instinct is involved. Usually the
parties in a friendship situation have common likes
and dislikes, and often they have similar
occupations.
Tuesday, July 21,
2015
11
Ferdinand Toennies:
Theory of Gemeinschaft (Community)
Gemeinschaft is maintained through two
kinds of wills: authority and common will.
Authority is created when one person’s will is
increased while at the same time, somebody else’s
will is decreased or curbed. Authority involves
both rights and duties. However, as far as the
authority of the Gemeinschaft type is concerned,
the difference in wills cannot be great, otherwise
there will not be a common will.
Tuesday, July 21,
2015
12
Ferdinand Toennies:
Theory of Gemeinschaft (Community)
Common will is the binding force which keeps a number of
individuals together in the Gemeinschaft. It is based on the
fact that these individuals share the same beliefs, values,
and ways of behaving. The common will is expressed
through language (words and gestures), because
only through language we can let others know what
we think, what we fear, and what we like. Only
through language can we communicate and understand one
another. The mother also uses language--to admonish or to
praise her child, as well as to instill in him certain values and
beliefs which he will have to use in order to share in the
common will.
Tuesday, July 21,
2015
13
Ferdinand Toennies:
Theory of Gemeinschaft (Community)
The three basic laws of Gemeinschaft
Blood relatives and married couples, neighbors
and friends feel affection for each other and have
common beliefs and customs.
This affection and similarity in beliefs and values
creates “understanding.”
By virtue of this love and understanding the
members of the group tend to stay togther and
the result is the Gemeinschaft type of relationship.
Tuesday, July 21,
2015
14
Ferdinand Toennies:
Theory of Gesellschaft (Society)
 In the Gesellschaft type of relationship, a large number of
individuals live in close proximity without exhibiting any of the
characteristics of Gemeinschaft. There is no common will. Everyone
looks after his own personal interests and does not wish to
contribute anything to the community. Any expression of interest in
others is regarded with suspicion. Personal property is separate and
distinct, and there is no common property. Everything in the
Gesellschaft type of relationship is compared,
weighed, and measured, so that when a person
gives something away, he is sure to receive
something else which he considers of equal value
and/or worth.
Tuesday, July 21,
2015
15
Ferdinand Toennies:
Theory of Gesellschaft (Society)
Value is the quality which an object possess
in being better than another object. Who
determines value? In the Gesellschaft, a thing
is of value if it is possessed by one individual
and not by all; those who do not possess the
object in question desire to possess it.
Therefore, this gives the object value. An
object does not have to be practically useful
in order to be considered of value.
Tuesday, July 21,
2015
16
Ferdinand Toennies:
Theory of Gesellschaft (Society)
The worth of an object is estimated by the
amount of labor which is required for its
production.
The result is that every individual in the
Gesellschaft works and produces certain objects or
services which he offers to other individuals in
exchange for their products. At first glance, they
all seem to work for each other and for the
welfare of the Gesellschaft in general. At closer
scrutiny, this reveals itself to be an illusion. In
reality everyone looks after himself only.
Tuesday, July 21,
2015
17
Ferdinand Toennies:
Theory of Gesellschaft (Society)
There are times when the Gesellschaft is
suddenly thrown into a Gemeinschaft level
of activity…fighting a common enemy.
Catastrophic natural events
Floods
Tornadoes
Earthquakes
Major wars
Tuesday, July 21,
2015
18
Ferdinand Toennies:
Gemeinschft und Gesellschaft
Paper:
Applying the theories of
Gemeinschaft und Gesellschaft to real
world. Situations…practical uses for
these theories.
Tuesday, July 21,
2015
19