Transcript The impact of increased tuition fees on educational progression

The impact of increased tuition fees
on educational progression
www.herts.ac.uk/
Emma Jackson
[email protected]
Overview
Background to the increase in tuition fees.
Explore the impact of increased tuition fees.
Role of widening participation and outreach activities.
Key messages.
Questions.
The rise in tuition fees
Shift of the burden of paying for higher education from the taxpayer to the student.
1998: Annual up-front
tuition fees for
England of £1,000
was introduced.
2006: Tuition fees
were increased to
£3,000 after Labour
stated in 2001 it would
not introduce top-up
fees.
2012: Students can
pay up to £9,000 a
year.
2012 increase in tuition fees
In December 2010 the motion on student funding was passed.
The motion was to increase the tuition fees ceiling in England from £3,290 to a
maximum cap of £9,000
But, narrowly with 323 votes to 302. (In 2005, there was a difference of only four votes)
It was suggested to help low income graduates, part-timers and the long-term interest
of universities.
However, has this increase in tuition fees negatively impacted on progression rates,
social mobility………….
The Protests
Remember this?
Thousands of
students marched in
protest over
increased university
fees.
Organised by National
Campaign Against
Fees.
The student voice would suggest this will hinder progression & social mobility.
Impact of Fees
What is the impact in the rise in tuition fees for:
Parents/guardians- families
Young people
Graduates
Cost is one barrier to taking up higher education (Callender, 2003)
Low income students are more likely to see cost of university as a debt
rather than an investment in their learning (Callender, 2003).
Young people may aspire to progress to higher education but in the end
think it costs too much (Berzins, 2009).
Impact of Fees
Young people as young as 11 worry about the cost of university (NFER)
The NFER study tracked the rise in tuition fees on secondary school
pupils attitudes towards gaining a degree qualification.
An increasing number thought they would be successful without a degree
qualification.
Is university worth the price?
Moore, McNeill and Halliday (2011) used a mixed method approach to explore attitudes towards
the rise in tuition fees in Greater Manchester, Greater Merseyside and West Yorkshire.
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Respondents in Aimhigher target areas were knowledgeable about costs.
However, these young people were less likely to be interested in higher education.
They were uncommitted to the idea of university regardless of the fee.
Of those committed it related to viewing a university education as important for future job
prospects.
Cost of university would put 38% respondents off from applying to HE.
To pay for a university education respondents were more likely to get a student loan, only 23%
would ask parents to pay.
Cost would have a negative impact on studies.
Despite knowing all the benefits the costs were seen as too much and students spoke of
strategies to minimise debt.
Cost of university is a key issue- but it is not the only barrier.
Young people require more information on costs and signposting for advice.
Increased tuition fees may have benefited
students from poorer backgrounds…
Institute for Fiscal Studies reported that the introduction of higher tuition fees in England in
2006/07 has contributed to narrow the gap in university participation ( Crawford, 2012).
In 2004/05 12% of young people (aged 18/19) from lower socio-economic background
progressed to university, this increased to 18% in 2009/10.
The proportion of state-school teenagers has rose from 30% to 34%.
New fee regime is considered more generous to poorer students.
However, cannot be sure that changes in participation rates is due to just fee regime.
Increased tuition fees may have benefited
students from poorer backgrounds…
Attainment catch-up
The proportion of young people from poorer backgrounds achieving two A-levels has
increased.
This could also impact on progression rates
Middle-Class shun university
UCAS (2012) have suggested that applications to university from some of the most
affluent areas has fallen this year.
For example in North Tyneside there was a 23% drop in applications.
Whereas in Rochdale, an area with the worst unemployment rates saw a 6% increase
in applications, 4,273 to 5,013 this year.
9% drop in applications
It therefore proposes that the question of whether the middle class are rejecting higher
education.
Is the hike in tuition fees making young people think twice about university?
How much do young people know?
McNally, McGuigan and Wyness (2012)
Explored the understanding Year 10 students have on the cost and benefits of higher education.
54 schools in London took part with 12, 000 students in 2010/11 completing a pre and post
questionnaire.
At the pre questionnaire the students knew little about the costs and benefits of HE, their answers
reflected those in the media.
After the young people completed a information package about higher education, attitudes towards
higher education changed at post test.
The authors suggested that young people need the right information and this should be given early on
as decisions are made before the end of compulsory education.
To early to tell
UCAS estimates 15,000 18 years were put off by the hike in tuition fees.
This is overstated (Hepi, 2012)
It is too early to judge the impact of the changes to higher education in England.
Higher Education Policy Institute (Hepi) (2012), suggests there is no evidence at
present that shows people are put off by increased tuition fees. They may be shortterm impact such as some students started university in 2011/12 to avoid the fee
increase, similar to 2005/06.
Also, after the introduction of increased tuition fees in 2006/07 there was a small
temporary dip in participation at HE which may be similar this year.
What is the impact of fees…
Fees can impact on progression to higher education (Marr, 2012)
It can impact on the provision.
Increased fees and subsequent levels of debt can be off putting (Moore, McNeill & Halliday, 2012).
This is however related to social class.
Financial concerns are related to social identities (class, ethnicity and race) (Callender & Jackson, 2004)
Because for some the fees may be less than school fees
This area requires further research
But, the increase in variable tuition fees in 2006 did not appear to affect overall demand (OFFA,
2009;2010). So this may be the same for the £9,000 fees.
Factors that impact on educational progression
The increase in tuition fees is just one of many factors that can influence educational progression.
Barriers to higher education can be categorised as either; situational, institutional and/or
dispositional (Gorard et al., 2006).
Lack of aspiration
Prior attainment is a main predictor of educational progression (Gorard et al., 2006; Allen, 2012).
Parents/siblings/ other family members
School environment (young people from lower socio-economic backgrounds tend to attend less
well performing schools)
Teachers
Peers/ Peer groups
Careers advice
http://www.hefce.ac.uk/whatwedo/wp/ourresearch/polar/mapofyoungparticipationareas/
‘I can no longer afford university’ 
Young people will frequently say when asked I will no longer be able to afford
to go to university.
Debt aversion or lack of knowledge.
Key message is that students do not have to pay their fees up-front.
They do not have to pay anything till they are earning at least £21,000.
There is also support for students from poor backgrounds.
Students will never repay the full amount (Allen, 2012).
To do so, students would need to have an average salary of £40,000 over 30
years (Allen, 2012).
Factors that impact on educational progression
Educational experiences have an important impact on educational
progression.
Barriers to progression can include:
• Resources
• Self-esteem
• Mobility
• Opportunity
• Basic Study Skills
Widening Participation
‘Widening Participation addresses the
large discrepancies in the take up of
higher education opportunities between
social groups. Under-representation is
closely connected with broader social
issues of equity and social inclusion ,
so we are concerned with ensuring
equality of opportunity for disabled
students, mature students ,women and
men and all ethnic groups.’
HEFCE, 2009
Outreach and Widening Participation
Getting to university should depend on someone's ability, not their ability to pay.
There is an ongoing emphasis on raising aspirations (St Clair and Benjamin, 2011)
Universities charging more than £6,000 a year in tuition fees have to offer
bursaries, summer schools & outreach activities to encourage students to
apply to university.
Outreach activities aim to raise aspirations and awareness of higher
education.
Outreach and Widening Participation
The Outreach & Widening Participation team at the University of Hertfordshire
aims to provide advice, support and encouragement to increase student
numbers in higher education from under-represented groups.
Events include:
•
•
•
•
•
•
Activities that raise awareness of higher education
General talks
Mentoring
Summer Schools
Taster days
Schools visits
National Scholarship Programme
National Scholarship Programme was introduced this year to support students
from poor backgrounds at university.
Package of financial support varies between institutions but typically includes a
tuition fee wavier, cash bursaries and/or campus discounts.
Based on parental income, where people live as well as other factors.
It is a considerable complex system for these students (Institute of Fiscal Studies,
2012).
So, will it encourage young people from poorer backgrounds to progress to higher
education…
Outreach activities
Summer Schools are the chance for
learners whose own background
and experience of HE is limited. It
gives young people a chance to
experience a real life taste of what
university is like.
Summer Schools aim to consolidate
a
learner’s
exposure
to
experiencing the higher education
environment
and
raise
their
awareness and aspiration to
progress.
‘I know more about
what options to take
at sixth form.’
Paying the fees
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
The Government lend students the money for the fees.
Students will start to pay back their fees once they have graduated and begin to
earn over £21, 000 per year
Fees are not paid up front
The pay back is 9% of the student’s income
After 30 years debt is cleared
Potentially students could leave university with £43, 000 debt (combination of fee
and maintenance loans)
Lowest earners will pay less than they currently do
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FFOhzCCEtzc
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/education-14785676#student_finance_form
Conclusion
•
•
•
•
Tuition fees can potential impact on
educational decisions.
However a number of factors influence
educational progression.
It is too early to tell whether the
increase in tuition fees has resulted in
a drop in student numbers.
Young people need advice and
guidance early on.
Thank you,
Any Questions?