Transcript Fig 1

New MNS
New Grasp
New Concept
New Anatomy
Fig 1
Fig 2
Fig 3
Fig 3
Task Constraints (F6)
Working Memory (46)
Instruction Stimuli (F2)
AIP
Ways
to grab
PFC
“It’s a
mug”
F5
F1
canonical
IT
cIPS
Ventral
Stream:
Recognition
Hand Control
Task Constraints (F6)
Working Memory (46)
Instruction Stimuli (F2)
PF
Handobject
trajectories
PFC
“It’s a
mug”
F5
mirror
IT
Dorsal
Stream:
Affordances
F1
Hand
Shape &
Motion
STS
Hand Control
Feedback Correction
Observe
Execute
F5 mirror
F5 canonical
Recognize Actions
Command Actions
Interpretation
Planning
Working Memory for
Perception and Production of
Utterances
Working Memory for
Actions, Objects, and
Relationships
Auditory
Input
Tpt
Wernicke’s
PF extended
DPLF
IT
STSa
Visual
Input
Recognizing
Actions, Objects, and
Relationships
PF
AIP
Multimodal
Broca’s area
(vocal,
manual, orofacial)
Protospeech (basis for speech)
From Imitation to Describing
Actions, Objects, Relationships
Protosign (basis for
sign language)
F5 mirror
Recognizing an Action
F5 canonical
Choosing an Action
Arbib, 2001 updated by FARS modificato
Object features
Object
affordance
extraction
AIP
Object affordance
7b: PF/PG
-hand state
Integrate
association
temporal
cIPS
association
F5canonical
Motor
program
(Grasp)
Hand
shape
recognition
Mirror Action
recognition Motor
Feedback
Hand
(Mirror
program
motion
Neurons)
Hand-Object
(Reach)
detection
spatial relation
F5mirror
F4
analysis
STS
7a
Object
location
The Mirror
Neuron System
(MNS) Model
(Oztop & Arbib)
Motor
execution
M1
• Activity of F5 canonical neurons is part of the code for
Command: Grasp-A(Object) The full neural representation of the “Cognitive
Form” (CF): Grasp-A(Object)
requires not only the regions AIP and F5canonical shown in the MNS diagram,
but also inferotemporal cortex (IT) which holds the identity of the object.
How are these representations bound together?
• NOTE: This is only the “Cognitive Form”. There are no “Linguistic Forms” in
the monkey.
Object features
Object
affordance
extraction
cIPS
7b: PF/PGObject affordance
-hand state
association
Hand
shape
recognition
Hand
motion
detection
STS
F5canonical
Motor
program
(Grasp)
AIP
Integrate
temporal
association
Action
Mirror
Feedback recognition
Hand-Object
spatial relation
analysis
7a
F5mirror
Motor
program
(Reach)
F4
The Mirror
Neuron System
(MNS) Model
(Oztop & Arbib)
Motor
execution
M1
Object
location
• Activity of F5 mirror neurons is part of the code for
Declarative: Grasp-A(Agent, Object) The full neural representation of the “Cognitive
Form” (CF): Grasp-A(Agent, Object)
requires not only the regions AIP, STS, 7a, 7b and F5miirror shown in the MNS diagram,
but also inferotemporal cortex (IT) which holds the identity of the object and regions of
STS (?) not included in MNS which hold the identity of the agent.
• How are these representations bound together?
• Agent  Action  Object Analysis of the Mirror System
makes
• Grasp (Raisin) primary, where the Agent is the self and thus
unspecified,
• and then makes
• Grasp (Leo, Raisin) secondary
• The mirror system expands the representational capacity of the
canonical system to allow the Agent role to be played by
others as well.
• But note that the full power of the system is “Beyond the
Mirror” embedding MNS in a larger system:
F5 canonical
F5 mirror
STS
Agent
IT
Observed Action
Executed Action
Object
view of object
Learn by
Imitation
"Social
Learning"
view
of gesture
AIP
gesture
description
STS (and 7b?)
Learn by Doing
Try to Grasp
Object
MP: Gesture
Motor Program
gesture
recognition
expectation
F5
ENN
7b or F5?
command
corollary
discharge
MPG
Mirror neurons
Non-Mirror Neurons
grasp of object