Transcript 11-Operating Systems Security

Operating Systems and
Virtual Machines Security
Eng. Hector M Lugo-Cordero, MS
CIS 4361 Secure OS Admin
Problem
• Client / Server infrastructure very common
among most organizations
– Clients provide access to system
– Servers run the systems
• Software vulnerabilities (e.g. buffer overflow)
and malware need to be considered
• Follow a framework detailed by NIST (National
Institute of Standards and Technology) to
provide a secure environment, even when we
know it is not there
NIST Approach Phases
•
•
•
•
•
•
Planning
Installation
Configuration
Update
Maintenance
Consider the OS layered model, each
layer needs to be properly secured, and it
may be attack from layers bellow
OS Layered Model
User Space
Services / Hypervisor
System Calls
Device Drivers / Hardware Abstraction Layer (HAL)
Kernel / BIOS
Instruction Set Architecture
Hardware
Physical World
Australian Defense Signals
Directorate (DSD)
• Publish on “Top 35 Mitigation Strategies”
– 70% of intrusion studied by 2009 could be prevented
with 4 measures
• Patch operating systems and applications using auto-update
• Patch 3rd party applications
• Restrict admin privileges to users who need them
– Disable root on linux (only via sudoers groups users may gain
root privileges)
– Create other accounts (other than default) in Windows with less
privileges
• White-list approved applications
Overall Goal
• Asses risks and plan the system
development
• Secure the underlying OS and then key
applications
• Ensure any critical content is secured
• Ensure appropriate network protection
mechanisms are used
• Ensure appropriate process are used to
maintain security (policies)
System Security Planning
• There is a course CIS4313 that talks about
planning, here we care more about the RMM
(Risk Management Mitigation)
• Identify risks, along with their likelihood and what
are there impact
• Also identify how to prevent and mitigates these
risks
• Such process will drive what you need for
establishing a secure system (personnel for
installing, OS, hardware, apps, etc.)
Things to keep in mind
• Purpose of the system, type of information
stored, applications and services provided
• Users of the system and their privileges
• How are users authenticated
• How information on system is managed
• What other hosts / DBs are accessed by system
• Who will manage system and how (remote or
local)
• Additional measures such as: firewall, anti-virus,
logging
Hardening the OS
• Default OS configurations are for ease of use
• Measures have to be done at all stages
– Installing and patching
– Configuring
• Remove unnecessary applications, services and protocols
• Users, groups, controls and privileges
– Install additional software (anti-virus, firewall, intrusion
detection system, etc.)
– Test Security
Installing and Patching
• Installation
– Machines should not connect to network until secured
• However removable media may be infected as well
– Limited network (firewall) is acceptable, ideally:
• No inbound connections
• Only out to certain key sites
– Install only required services and drivers (from trusted sources)
– Set up automatic updates (only if update time is not an issue)
• Booting
– Protect BIOS changes with password
– Disable some bootable media
– Cryptographic hard drives? Pros and Cons
Automatic Updates
Remove Unnecessary Support
• Software have vulnerabilities, hence more
software = more vulnerabilities
• Better to not install it at all
– Uninstallers sometimes fail to clean all dependency
– Disabled software may be enabled by an attacker
upon control acquisition
• Disabling can be done via msconfig command
(Windows), yast or equivalent (Linux) or Control
Panel (Windows / Linux)
Configure U/G Authentication
• Define user types and privileges
– Admin (ideally only temporary)
– Normal
– Limited
• Authentication
– Force default password change
– Password definition
– Password lifespan
• Remove or disable old accounts
• Allow for remote connections?
Additional Security and Testing
• Anti-virus
• Firewalls, IDS, IPS
• White list
– If attackers manage to install a program what
will happen?
• Run some test cases which attempt to
break security (stress testing), good
hackers make a lot of money here
Security Testing
Application Security
• Configure applications properly
• Use encryption when possible as seen earlier
– For storing
– For transmit (SSH connections)
• Limit privileges as with users
– Remember what we have said about security in
Android, Blackberry, and iPhone
• Applications may provide backdoors if not
configured properly
Maintenance
• Now that system is set, keep it secure
• This involves
– Monitoring and analyzing logging information
– Performing regular backups
– Recovering from security compromises
– Regular testing of security
– Patch, update, and revise critical software
Logging
• Keep a record of important events in the
computer
• Problems
– Need to make sure to have enough space
– Manual analysis is hard, so these logs should
contain a format such that a program (e.g. in
Perl) can parse messages
Data Backup
• Backup is the act of creating copies of
information such that it may be recovered
• Archive is to keep these backups for a long
period of time in order to meet some legal
aspects
• Should the backup be kept online or offline?
– Online makes easier access, faster recover
– Offline is more secure, harder to recover
– Why not both?: Users should keep their own offline
backups, in case online backup gets removed
• Data may be lost accidentally (hardware failures,
human mistake) or intentionally
Backups
Linux / Unix Security Periodic Runs
• Patch Management
– Configure packet manager (cmd) on cron with crontab
–e (can be used for updates)
– Debian, Ubuntu: apt-get
– Red Hat, Fedora, CentOS: up2date
– SuSE: yast
– Mac OS X: ports
• Crontab usage
-e Edit or create crontab file
-l Display your crontab file
-r Remove your crontab file
Linux / Unix Security Configuration
• Applications and Services configuration
– Global configuration may be found at /etc or in
program tree
– Local configurations inside of ~/.<dir>
• ~ is an alias for $HOME, which is user home directory,
equivalent to C:\Users\<username>
• Typically located in /home/<username>/.<dir>
• Advantage
– Can have a program (e.g. Perl) that calculates
hashes for configuration files and verify its integrity
later
Linux / Unix Security Permissions
•
Users/Groups permissions
–
•
Permissions are not only to files but to process (/proc), memory (/dev), boot (/boot), etc.
Commands
–
chmod: change file mode
•
•
•
•
•
chmod +x jpegconv or chmod a+x jpegconv
chmod g+w jpegconv
chmod o-x jpegconv
chmod u+rwx jpegconv
chmod –c 777 jpegcong
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
•
rwx rwx rwx (groups of tree bits)
Each octal represents a group, bit 1 means grant right, bit 0 means remove/reject right
getfacl/setfacl: get/set file access control list
chown: changes file owner
chgrp: changes file group
groups <username>: shows a list of groups to which username or current belong to,
equivalent to cat /etc/groups | grep <username>
There are other commands which start with ch and help with other things, use auto-complete
feature (tab) for a complete list
Access Control List (more on man setfacl)
–
setfacl -m u:lisa:r file
Linux / Unix Access Control Lists
• [d[efault]:] [u[ser]:]uid [:perms]
– Permissions of a named user. Permissions of the
file owner if uid is empty.
• [d[efault]:] g[roup]:gid [:perms]
– Permissions of a named group. Permissions of the
owning group if gid is empty.
• [d[efault]:] m[ask][:] [:perms]
– Effective rights mask
• [d[efault]:] o[ther][:] [:perms]
– Permissions of others.
Linux / Unix Security
Remote Access
•
•
Configure firewalls to prevent remote access
Commands:
– /etc/hosts.allow and /etc/hosts.deny files
– iptables
• Filter by protocol
• Filter by source/destination
• Filter by rule (i.e. in, out, forward)
•
For consistency should log into /dev/log
–
–
–
–
–
openlog()
syslog()
closelog()
logger command
lsof: list open files
• lsof | egrep log
• ps -efawww | egrep syslog
•
chroot jail: set temporary a new root directory such that services if they get
hijacked do not give access to all the system (system call: chroot)
Linux / Unix Security Testing
• Nessus: security scanning and
vulnerability testing (like a fuzzer)
• Tripwire: builds and check integrity of files
(md5 compares)
• Nmap: can check for surrounding network
services
Windows Security
• Use automatic updates specially for
– Windows
– Adobe Acrobat Reader and Flash Plugin
– Java
• Users are defined with a Security ID (SID) and
information such as passwords may be stored at
Security Account Manager (SAM)
• System restore
• User Account Control to treat users with admin
only as admin when required, otherwise as
normal (Vista and later)
Windows Registry
• Hard to maintain
• Easy to access
• May use a specific application hiding
complex information from administrator
• May use regedit to see everything
– Useful to have an application that queues and
monitors registry changes, such that they
need to get approved before proceeding
Other Windows Security
•
•
•
•
Anti-virus
Anti-spyware
Personal firewall
Encrypting File Systems
– Local Security Policy
• BitLocker: full disk encryption with AES
• More on Control Panel System Security
• Microsoft Baseline Security Analyzer
– Checks for minimal recommended requirements in a system
– Its free
– Shavlik NetChk Limited for legacy
Virtualization
• Virtualization: defines an isomorphism that maps
a virtual guest system to a physical host
• Adds another degree of freedom by enabling
multiple resource managers and controlled
sharing.
– Adds a level of indirection
• Can virtualize a single resource (DRAM, Disks)
or an entire system (machine).
– may create one or more virtual objects.
• Virtual Machine: Add virtualization layer which
transforms the physical machine into the desired
virtual architecture.
Virtualization (Some Terms)
• Hypervisor/Virtual Machine Monitor: manages
physical resource allocation among VMs
• Application Virtualization: allow an application
written for one environment, to run at others
– Java
– .NET
• Full Virtualization: allows to run a full OS on a
machine
– Native Virtualization: runs without a host OS
– Hosted Virtualization: requires to have an OS running
below it
Some Virtual Machines
•
•
•
•
•
Oracle VirtualBox
Microsoft Virtual PC (formerly Virtual PC)
VMware
Xen Hypervisor
Parallel Desktop (popular on MAC)
History of Virtualization
• 1960’s
– 1964 - Birth of virtualization with the IBM CP
series which was a test bed for the IBM S/360
system. Provided full hardware virtualization
with the ability to run 14 OS instances.
– 1965 – IBM begins shipping S/360 systems,
the first mass production multi-purpose
mainframe. First machine to use virtual
memory for ‘infinite’ storage capacity.
History of Virtualization
• 1970’s
– IBM S/370, more of the same
• 1980’s
– 1987 - Merge/386 becomes available allowing
emulation of Intel 8086 instructions on Intel
80286 & 80386 CPUs. Could run any 8086
coded OS but was typical found running
Microsoft MS-DOS.
History of Virtualization
• 1990’s
– 1997 – Virtual PC released for Macintosh
– 1998 – VMware released for Windows
– 1999 – Citrix Presentation Server released for
Windows
• 2001
– Virtual PC released for Windows
– VMware Server released (first x86 server VM)
History of Virtualization
• 2003
– Xen Hypervisor released (Open Source x86)
– MS buys Virtual PC & releases MS Virtual PC 2004
• 2005
– MS releases Virtual Server 2005 (guest machines
limited to 32bit, 4GB of RAM, & 1 CPU)
– Intel’s VT and AMD’s AMD-V hardware virtualization
added to Server and Desktop CPUs
History of Virtualization
• 2006
–
–
–
–
VMware Server 1.0 released for free
MS Virtual Server 2005 R2 released for free
MS Virtual PC 2007 released for free
MS buys and releases SoftGrid (now called MS AppV)
– Amazon begins developing the first true Cloud
• 2007
– VMware Server 2.0 released
– VirtualBox Open Source released
– Citrix acquires Xen
History of Virtualization
• 2008
– VMware buys Thinstall and releases ThinApp
– VMware 6.5 released, first DX9 hardware
virtualization
– MS releases Hyper-V for Windows 2008
(guest machines gain 64bit support, 64 GB of
RAM, & 4 CPUs)
– First public Cloud systems come online
38
History of Virtualization
• 2009
– MS releases Hyper-V R2 for Windows 2008
R2 (guest machines gain CPU pooling)
• 2010
– MS releases Hyper-V R2 SP1 (guest
machines gain RAM pooling and DX9
hardware support)
– ARM announces A15 with hardware
virtualization
Processor Performance
• CPU Speeds
– 1965 - IBM S/360 – 0.1 MIPS (133,300 IPS)
– 1972 - IBM S/370 – 1.0 MIPS (1,000,000 IPS)
– 2000 - 1 GHz Intel P3 – 3,000 MIPS (3,000,000,000
IPS)
– 2009 - Qualcomm Snapdragon A8 – 2,000 MIPS
– 2010 - Intel Core i7 – 4 x 147,600 MIPS
– 2010 - Qualcomm Snapdragon MP – 2 x 2,500 MIPS
– 2011 - Qualcomm/Samsung/nVidia A9 MP – 2 x 5,000
MIPS
– 2012 – ARM Cortex A15 MP – 4 x 25,000 MIPS
Uses
• Implement multiprogramming: multiple single-user virtual
machine instances. IBM System/370 used this approach to
provide time-sharing behavior with each VM running a simple
single-user OS (Conversational Monitor System or CMS)
• Multiple single-application VMs: Dedicates a VM for each
application program, uses a general purpose OS.
• Multiple secure environments: VM creates sandbox to isolate
environments and security domains.
• Manage application environment: Install core applications in
one VM then create per user VMs for them to load their own
apps.
• Mixed-OS environments: Single hardware platform can
support multiple Operating System environments.
• Legacy applications: Dedicate VMs for legacy applications.
• Multiplatform applications development: One hardware
platform with VMs providing emulation of alternative hardware.
Uses
• New system transition: Staged or gradual migration (opposite
of legacy support).
• System software development: For testing or developing new
system software in a protected environment.
• Operating system training: Run OS instance in a VM so
parameter or configuration adjustments do not affect rest of
system
• Help desk support: Use VM to replicate user environment
• Operating system instrumentation: Can monitor hardware
access or low level software abstractions
• Event monitoring: execution traces, machine state dumps and
replaying of traces
• System encapsulation: Check pointing system state and
restarting on same or different machine.
Virtualization Security Issues
• Guest OS isolation: to have no connection
among running OS and the Hypervisor
• Keep the integrity of the hypervisor
• Adds layers to the OS security
Virtualization Security Guidelines
• Plan the security
• Secure all elements of full virtualization
– OS
– Hypervisor
– Virtualized infrastructure
• Restrict and protect administrator access
Hypervisor Security
• Like OS security
– Install from private network, or clean media
– Configure for automatic updates
– Disable unused services and hardware
– Restrict access to hypervisor
– If there is remote access do it on a separate
network (e.g. VLAN, VPN, etc.)
Virtualized Infrastructure Security
• Consider monitoring hardware activity
• Search for VMM which allow to allocate
hardware properly, such these activities on
the guess OS may be monitored