Transcript The impact of the crisis on the banking sector in the ESCWA

The Impact of the Crisis on the Banking
Sector in the ESCWA member Countries
Dr. Fouad Shaker
Secretary General
Union of Arab Banks
Damascus, Syria , 5-7 May 2009
1
Introduction
- All MENA banking sectors are affected by the global crisis
- They face the same issues as those in other regions:
liquidity drought, drop in asset values, lower business
volumes, asset quality deterioration, declining profitability…
- GCC banks more affected than those in north Africa
- We anticipate further deterioration
- Very limited growth in the short term
- Focus on liquidity and risk management
- Revision of strategy/business plan
- Government support is an important factor
2
GCC banks more affected than those in North Africa
Higher impact on GCC banking sectors due to:
• Vulnerability on their economies to oil price movements
• Very rapid loan growth in recent years
• Large exposure to the real estate sector
• Higher reliance on foreign funding: roll-over risk
• Higher exposure to structured products
GCC Countries are “interventionist” toward their banking
sectors and have large liquidity reserves
3
North African banking sectors less affected due to:
• Negligible exposure to “toxic” products
• Very limited reliance on foreign funding
• Positive impact of the drop in oil prices
Lower flexibility to provide support
4
Banks In North Africa
Morocco: Facing increasing risk from an adequate position
• Rapid loan growth be tested by weaker economic environment
• Correction in the real estate sector has already started in the
high-end segment
• Geographic expansion in Africa might prove riskier than
anticipated
Tunisia: Targeted improvements look more challenging
• Economic slowdown will limit banks’ ability to improve their
asset quality
• Additional pressure on already weak profitability and
capitalization
5
Egypt: Restructuring process at risk?
• Slowdown in economy will put pressure on already weak
asset quality
• Privatization process should prove more difficult (e.g.
Banque du Caire)
In addition, these three countries are exposed to the drop in:
• Tourism
• Textile sector
• Foreign direct investments
• Workers’ remittances
• Trade flows with Europe
6
The environment Weakening
7
A Sharp Weakening of The Environment
• Observed limited signs of stress until September 2008 but
rapid deterioration thereafter
• Sharp reduction in GDP growth
• Slowdown/delays in infrastructure and real estate projects
• Dramatic fall of markets (prices and volumes)
• Real estate prices are trending downwards
• Lower business volumes
• Liquidity drought and sharp increase in cost of funding
• Very low debt issuance volumes (e.g. GCC corporate bond
issuance down by more than 50% in 2008; GCC sukuk
issuance fell by more than 60%)
8
A Sharp Weakening of the Environment
Real GDP Growth (%) for some Arab Countries
Abu Dhabi
Bahrain
Kuwait
Oman
Qatar
Saudi
Egypt
Morocco
Tunisia
9
2007
7.6
8.0
4.8
7.7
15.4
3.4
7.1
2.7
6.3
2008e
5.9
7.0
4.5
10.2
17.6
5.8
7.2
5.8
4.9
2009f
4.2
4.0
1.4
2.0
10.6
-10.9
4.2
2.8
3.6
The effect on Stock markets
Market
Abu Dhabi
Bahrain
Dubai
Kuwait
Qatar
Oman
Saudi Arabia
10
2008 Change
-48%
-35%
-72%
-38%
-28%
-40%
-56%
The growth of Arab banking system during the crisis ($ billions)
Assets
Deposits
Loans
Shareholders Equity
11
2007
1,913
830
991
171
2008
1,938
999
1,121
194
MENA Banking Sectors Under Stress & Areas of Concern
• Major slowdown in business volumes
• Drop in fee and commissions from brokerage and IPOs
• Cost of funding will remain high
• Nonperforming loans are expected to increase rapidly
• Sharp increase in Loan-Loss provisions
• Goodwill impairment for recent acquisitions
• Further mark-downs on investment portfolios
• Areas of Concern:
 Banks with large exposure to Kuwaiti investment companies
 Banks with large exposure to Dubai real estate sector
 Banks with wholesale funding profiles
 Banks active in private equity
 Banks with large exposure to structured products
12
Government Support
• Willingness of MENA countries to provide extraordinary support
is considered high Sharp contrast in term of capacity between
GCC and North Africa.
• GCC countries seem to be “interventionist” toward their banking
sectors, reflecting the opinion that there is a high probability that
extraordinary support would be extend to “systemically important”
banks in case of need.
• Their capacity to support their banking sectors is strong (with
significant differences among countries), due to liquidity cushions
built up during times of high oil prices.
• GCC governments have so far reacted differently given the
different impact on their respective banking systems.
13
Government Support
• Two types of support: system-wide or bank-specific:
 Deposit guarantee (legal framework only in Kuwait)
 Reduction in reserve requirements
 Relaxation of regulation (e.g. loan-to-deposit ratio)
 Broader range of securities eligible for repo
 Swap facility
 Injection of liquidity through government related entities
 Capital injection (ABC, GIB, GIC, Gulf Bank, 5 banks in
Abu-Dhabi,…)
• Policies need to be comprehensive and coordinated
to avoid cross-border effects
• Timeliness of support has been perceived as less predictable in
some instance due to specificities , e.g. federal structure in the
UAE, political tension (Kuwait)
14
Where Are We?
• MENA banks are operating in a much weaker environment
• MENA banks’ financial profiles will weaken in 2009
• Ongoing downward trend in asset quality and profitability
• Liquidity will remain tight and cost of funding high
• Government support is critical and an important rating factor
• More differences among banks across the region
• Overseas expansion will be limited and more selective
• Current focus on liquidity and risk management
15
Top 10 Banking Risks From Survey*
1996
2002
2008
1.Poor Management
1.Credit Risk
1.Liquidity
2.Bad Lending
2.Marco-economy
2.Credit Risk
3.Derivatives
3.Equity markets
3.Credit Spreads
4.Rogue Trader
4.Complex instruments
4.Derivatives
5.Excessive Competition
5.Business Continuity
5.Marco-economic trends
6.Emerging Markets
6.Domestic Regulation
6.Risk Management
7.Marco-economic threats
7.Insurance
7.Equities
8.Back-office failure
8.Emerging markets
8.Too much regulation
9.Technology foul-up
9.Banking over-capacity
9.Interest rates
10.Fraud
10.International regulation
10.Hedge funds
* Source: Banking Banana Skins 2008- The CSFI Survey of banks risk in association
with Price Waterhouse Coopers
16
Some Past Comments from the surveys*
- On Regulation: Eye on the wrong ball: Bankers and regulators
seem to be obsessed with implementation of new Basel2
framework. In reality the major risk to financial stability will not be
the capital adequacy of individual banks but rather the business
cycle and issues around liquidity of markets and institutions. (Prof.
Hans Geiger, Swiss banking Institute, University of Zurich, 2005)
17
- On Credit Risk: The exotic mortgage products may come back to haunt us in
an increasing interest environment. When the bankruptcies in both borrowers
and lending reach certain critical mass, the financial system’s capacity to absorb
the loss may collapse. If that happens, the shock may spill over into wider
markets and economy via two paths: a domino effect through the highly
leveraged derivatives markets and a collage of the housing markets which is the
main driver of the economy now, and with a heavy dept burden. (US Bank
Examiner, 2006).
- On Risk Management Techniques: Model Risk: The goal of quantitative and
objective decision making may cause the pendulum to swing too far from the
traditional judgmental approach. By giving insufficient weight to qualitative
judgment, institution will become even more exposed to model risk, with an
increasing reliance upon unregulated third parties (i.e. rating agencies and the
providers of risk management systems/methodologies). This will increase the
potential for bad lending decisions. (Group Financial Risk Controller
Multinational Bank. 2005)
18
Why GCC liquidity from flood to Drought
Three main factors behind tightening of liquidity
Conditions in the GCC during 2008
1. Reduced and more costly access to international capital
markets which have become increasingly important sources of
funds for both banks and corporate entities
2. A large withdrawal of speculative funds which had flowed
into the region betting on exchange rate revaluations
3. Sustained very rapid loan growth which has exceeded deposit
growth and led to elevated bank loan/deposit ratios
19
Looking ahead, GCC financing requirements remain high, especially in Dubai
GCC Corporate refinancing requirements
$ billions
2009
UAE
17.9
Of Which Dubai
15
Saudi Arabia
9.3
Qatar
2.8
Kuwait
1.7
Bahrain
1
Oman
0.2
GCC
32.9
Source Moody’s, Barclays Capital
20
GCC Policy Response: Providing and Injecting Liquidity
• Placing deposits in commercial banks (Saudi Arabia, UAE)
• Making lines of funding a available (Kuwait, UAE)
• Buying stakes in banks to provide capital for future project
financing (Qatar) and injecting capital (Abu Dhabi)
• Lowering interest rates (all expect Qatar)
• Introducing dollar/LCU swap facilities (UAE)
• GCC governments have the will and the resources to provide
additional liquidity to the banking system
21
Recent Situation of GCC Banks
1- Although GCC banks in general are well capitalized compared
with US and European banks, a sustained shortage of long term
funding sources may compel some to shrink their asset size
(deleverage). In any event, Liquidity constraints are likely to curtail
future asset growth.
2- Banks face significant risks from asset quality deteriorationincluding on international investments-rising NPLs, inflated
provisioning needs, and decreased credit volumes.
3- Exposure to declining real estate sectors is a major concern for
some, especially in the UAE where a speculative property bubble has
begun to burst and bank exposure is large.
22
4- The tightening of liquidity in the GCC was driven by the
outflow of speculative funds betting on currency reform, by
credit demand outstripping deposit growth, and by reduced
access to international capital markets.
5- The GCC governments and central banks have responded
swiftly and strongly to provide liquidity, and have the resources
to do more if necessary.
6- Economic growth will slow in the GCC, but government
support will ensure that the region does not slip into outright
recession.
7- Dubai will face the most testing time.
23
A Holistic Risk Management Approach
• Effective Governance, Risk Management and Control structure. Appropriate
Committees and three lines of defense:
1- First Level: Control Units within Business processes.
2- Second Level:
- Risk Management (Credit, Market, Operational, Information
Security, Business Continuity, Business Risk Review, and others
such as Insurance)
- Regulatory Compliance
3- Third Level: Internal Audit
• Risk Management methodologies and procedure. Need for pro-active
approach. Some risks require task forces, others require dedicated departments.
Importance of discipline.
• Importance of Stress Testing. Expect the unexpected
• IIF July Report on Best Practice Recommendations on Risk Management
24