Transcript document

The Ethics of Character:
Virtues and Vices
Lawrence M. Hinman
University of San Diego
[email protected]
28/03/2016
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
1
Introduction
Concern for character
has flourished in the
West since the time of
Plato, whose early
dialogues explored such
virtues as courage and
piety.
Plato
28/03/2016
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
2
Two Moral Questions

The Question of Action:
– How ought I to act?

The Question of Character
– What kind of person ought I to be?

Our concern here is with the
question of character
28/03/2016
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
3
An Analogy from the
Criminal Justice System
• As a country, we place our trust for just
decisions in the legal arena in two places:
– Laws, which provide the necessary rules
– People, who (as judge and jury) apply rules
judiciously
• Similarly, ethics places its trust in:
– Theories, which provide rules for conduct
– Virtue, which provides the wisdom necessary for
applying rules in particular instances
28/03/2016
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
4
Virtue




Strength of character
(habit)
Involving both feeling
and action
Seeks the mean
between excess and
deficiency relative to
us
Promotes human
flourishing
Aristotle
28/03/2016
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
5
Virtues and Spheres of Existence
Sphere of Existence
Attitude toward self
Deficiency
Servility
Self-deprecation
Ignoring them
Attitude toward
offenses of others Being a Doormat
Attitude toward
good
deeds of others
Suspicion
Envy
Ignoring them
Indifference
Attitude toward our
own offenses Remorselessness
Downplaying
Attitude toward
our friends
28/03/2016
Indifference
Mean
Proper Self-Love
Proper Pride
Self-Respect
Anger
Forgiveness
Understanding
Gratitude
Admiration
Agent Regret
Remorse
Making Amends
Learning from them
Self-Forgiveness
Loyalty
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
Excess
Arrogance
Conceit
Egoism
Narcissism
Vanity
Revenge
Grudge
Resentment
Over
indebtedness
Toxic Guilt
Scrupulosity
Shame
Obsequiousness
6
Spheres of Existence--2
Attitude toward our
own good deeds
Belittling
Disappointment
Sense of
Accomplishment
Humility
Selfrighteousness
Attitude toward the
suffering of others
Attitude toward the
achievements of
others
Attitude toward
death
and danger
Attitude toward our
own desires
Attitude toward
other people
Callousness
Compassion
Self-satisfaction
Complacency
Competition
Cowardice
Admiration
Emulation
Pity
“Bleeding Heart”
Envy
Courage
Foolhardiness
Anhedonia
Temperance
Moderation
Respect
Lust
Gluttony
Deferentiality
28/03/2016
Exploitation
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
7
Two Conceptions of
Morality

We can contrast two approaches to the
moral life.
– The childhood conception of morality:
• Comes from outside (usually parents).
• Is negative (“don’t touch that stove burner!”).
• Rules and habit formation are central.
– The adult conception of morality.
• Comes from within (self-directed).
• Is positive (“this is the kind of person I want to be.”).
• Virtue-centered,often modeled on ideals.
28/03/2016
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
8
The Purpose of Morality


Both of these conceptions of
morality are appropriate at different
times in life.
Adolescence and early adulthood is
the time when some people make the
transition from the adolescent
conception of morality to the adult
conception.
28/03/2016
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
9
Rightly-ordered Desires

Aristotle draws an interesting contrast
between:
– Continent people, who have unruly desires but
manage to control them.
– Temperate people, whose desires are
naturally—or through habit, second-nature—
directed toward that which is good for them.
– Weakness of will (akrasia) occurs when
individuals cannot keep their desires under
control.
28/03/2016
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
10
Rightly-ordered Desires and
the Goals of Moral Education


Moral education may initially seek to
control unruly desires through rules,
the formation of habits, etc.
Ultimately, moral education aims at
forming rightly-ordered desires, that
is, teaching people to desire what is
genuinely good for them.
28/03/2016
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
11
Virtue As the Golden Mean

Strength of character (virtue), Aristotle
suggests, involves finding the proper
balance between two extremes.
– Excess: having too much of something.
– Deficiency: having too little of something.


Not mediocrity, but harmony and balance.
See examples below.
28/03/2016
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
12
Virtue and Habit


For Aristotle, virtue is something that
is practiced and thereby learned—it
is habit (hexis).
This has clear implications for moral
education, for Aristotle obviously
thinks that you can teach people to
be virtuous.
28/03/2016
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
13
Courage

The strength of character necessary
to continue in the face of our fears
– Deficiency: Cowardice, the inability to do what
is necessary to have those things in life which
we need in order to flourish
• Too much fear
• Too little confidence
– Excess
• Too little fear
• Too much confidence
• Poor judgment about ends worth achieving
28/03/2016
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
14
Nichomachean Ethics, 3.7
What is terrible is not the same for all men; but we
say there are things terrible even beyond human
strength. These, then, are terrible to every one- at
least to every sensible man; but the terrible things
that are not beyond human strength differ in
magnitude and degree, and so too do the things
that inspire confidence. Now the brave man is as
dauntless as man may be. Therefore, while he will
fear even the things that are not beyond human
strength, he will face them as he ought and as the
rule directs, for honour's sake; for this is the end of
virtue. But it is possible to fear these more, or less,
and again to fear things that are not terrible as if
they were.
28/03/2016
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
15
EN, 2
Of the faults that are committed one consists in
fearing what one should not, another in fearing as
we should not, another in fearing when we should
not, and so on; and so too with respect to the things
that inspire confidence. The man, then, who faces
and who fears the right things and from the right
motive, in the right way and from the right time, and
who feels confidence under the corresponding
conditions, is brave; for the brave man feels and
acts according to the merits of the case and in
whatever way the rule directs.
28/03/2016
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
16
EN, 3
Now the end of every activity is conformity to the
corresponding state of character. This is true, therefore, of the
brave man as well as of others. But courage is noble.
Therefore the end also is noble; for each thing is defined by its
end. Therefore it is for a noble end that the brave man endures
and acts as courage directs. Of those who go to excess he
who exceeds in fearlessness has no name (we have said
previously that many states of character have no names), but
he would be a sort of madman or insensible person if he
feared nothing, neither earthquakes nor the waves, as they say
the Celts do not; while the man who exceeds in confidence
about what really is terrible is rash. The rash man, however, is
also thought to be boastful and only a pretender to courage; at
all events, as the brave man is with regard to what is terrible,
so the rash man wishes to appear; and so he imitates him in
situations where he can.
28/03/2016
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
17
EN, 4
Hence also most of them are a mixture of rashness
and cowardice; for, while in these situations they
display confidence, they do not hold their ground
against what is really terrible. The man who exceeds
in fear is a coward; for he fears both what he ought
not and as he ought not, and all the similar
characterizations attach to him. He is lacking also in
confidence; but he is more conspicuous for his
excess of fear in painful situations. The coward,
then, is a despairing sort of person; for he fears
everything.
28/03/2016
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
18
EN, 5
The brave man, on the other hand, has the opposite
disposition; for confidence is the mark of a hopeful
disposition. The coward, the rash man, and the
brave man, then, are concerned with the same
objects but are differently disposed towards them;
for the first two exceed and fall short, while the third
holds the middle, which is the right, position; and
rash men are precipitate, and wish for dangers
beforehand but draw back when they are in them,
while brave men are keen in the moment of action,
but quiet beforehand.
28/03/2016
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
19
EN, 6
As we have said, then, courage is a mean
with respect to things that inspire
confidence or fear, in the circumstances that
have been stated; and it chooses or endures
things because it is noble to do so, or
because it is base not to do so. But to die to
escape from poverty or love or anything
painful is not the mark of a brave man, but
rather of a coward; for it is softness to fly
from what is troublesome, and such a man
endures death not because it is noble but to
fly from evil.
28/03/2016
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
20
Courage

The strength of character necessary
to continue in the face of our fears.
– Deficiency: cowardice, the inability to do what
is necessary to have those things in life which
we need in order to flourish.
• Too much fear.
• Too little confidence.
– Excess:
• Too little fear.
• Too much confidence.
• Poor judgment about ends worth achieving.
28/03/2016
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
21
Courage


Both children and adults need courage.
Without courage, we are unable to take the
risks necessary to achieve some of the
things we most value in life.
– Risk to ask someone out on a date.
– Risk to show genuine vulnerability.
– Risk to try an academically challenging
program such as pre-med.
28/03/2016
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
22
Courage and the Unity of
the Virtues

To have any single strength of character in
full measure, a person must have the
other ones as well.
– Courage without good judgment is blind,
risking without knowing what is worth the risk.
– Courage without perseverance is short-lived,
etc.
– Courage without a clear sense of your own
abilities is foolhardy.
28/03/2016
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
23
Courage
Excess
Mean
Deficiency
Underestimates actual
danger
Correctly estimates
actual danger
Overestimates actual
danger
Overestimates own
ability
Correctly estimates own
ability
Underestimates own
ability
Undervalues means,
what is being placed at
risk
Overvalues goal, what
the risk is being taken
for
Properly values means
that are being put at risk
28/03/2016
Overvalues the means,
what is being placed at
risk
Properly values goal that Undervalues goal, what
is being sought
the risk would be taken
for
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
24
Issues of Courage




Fears, dangers, and rightly-ordered fears
Seeking out danger: mountain climbing
Courage and nonviolence: Gandhi
Courage and gender
– Women’s courage is often undervalues
– Men’s courage is tied to their gender identity
28/03/2016
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
25
Compassion and Pity

Pity looks down on the other.
– Consequently, no one wants to be the
object of pity.

Compassion sees the suffering of the
other we something that could have
happened to us.
– Consequently, we welcome the
compassion of others when we are
suffering.
28/03/2016
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
26
Compassion






Etymology: to feel or suffer with…
Both cognitive and emotional
Leads to action
Excess:
the “bleeding heart”
Deficiency: moral callousness
Contrast with pity
28/03/2016
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
27
Compassion as an Emotion

Emotion is often necessary:
– to recognize the suffering of others
• emotional attunement
– part of the response to that suffering
• others often need to feel that you care
28/03/2016
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
28
Compassion and
Moral Imagination

Example from Le Chambon
“Later in the week they captured an Austrian Jew named Steckler—
he had made the mistake of going to a pharmacy without all of his
papers. The police put him—their only prisoner—in one of the big
buses. As he sat there, the villagers started gathering around the
periphery of the square. The son of Andre Trocmé [the village
pastor], Jean-Pierre, walked up to the window of the bus at which
Steckler sat and gave him his last piece of rationed (imitation)
chocolate. This started the closing of the circle of villagers. They
brought their most precious foodstuffs and put them through the
window into Steckler’s arms. Soon the quiet little man had a pile
of gifts around him about as high as he sat in the seat.
“When the buses left with their one Jew the villagers sang a song of
affection and farewell to him.”
28/03/2016
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
29
Cleverness and Wisdom


The clever person knows the best
means to any possible end.
The wise person knows which ends
are worth striving for.
28/03/2016
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
30
Self-Love
Introduction


Involves feeling, knowing, and acting
Characteristics of loving another person:
– Feelings of tenderness, care, appreciation,
respect toward that person
– Knowing that person (infatuation usually does
not involve knowledge)
– Acting in ways that promote the flourishing of
that person
28/03/2016
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
31
Self-Love
Principal Characteristics
Characteristics of self-love
– Having feelings of care, appreciation,
and respect for others
– Valuing yourself--flows from feelings of
self-love
– Knowing yourself--a long, often
arduous, and never completed task
– Acting in ways that promote your
genuine flourishing
28/03/2016
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
32
Self-Love:
Deficiency
Deficiency
– Too little feeling: self-loathing
– Too little self-valuing: self-deprecating
– Too little self-knowledge: unwilling or
unable to look at one’s own
motivations, feelings, etc.
– Too little acting: not taking steps to
insure one’s own well-being
28/03/2016
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
33
Self-Love:
Excess





Excesses of self-love take many forms:
arrogance, conceit, egoism, vanity, and
narcissism are but a few of the ways in
which we can err in this direction.
Too much caring: self-centeredness
Too much self-valuing: arrogance, conceit
Too much self-knowledge: narcissistic
Too much acting for self: selfishness
28/03/2016
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
34
Friendship


For Aristotle, there is no necessary
dichotomy between self-interest and
concern for others.
Without friends, in Aristotle’s view, we
cannot achieve happiness:
– “…without friends no one would choose to
live, though he had all other goods; even rich
men and those in possession of office and of
dominating power are thought to need friends
most of all…” EN, VIII, 1.
28/03/2016
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
35
What Is Friendship?
“We may describe friendly feeling towards any one
as wishing for him what you believe to be good
things, not for your own sake but for his, and being
inclined, so far as you can, to bring these things
about. A friend is one who feels thus and excites
these feelings in return: those who think they feel
thus towards each other think themselves friends.
This being assumed, it follows that your friend is
the sort of man who shares your pleasure in what is
good and your pain in what is unpleasant, for your
sake and for no other reason.”
--Rhetoric, Book II, Chap. 4; 1380b36-1381a5
28/03/2016
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
36
Types of Friendship

Friendship may have three possible aims:
– Utility: ends when the useful purpose is no
longer present.
– Pleasure; ends when the pleasure disappears.
– A shared commitment to the good: “Perfect
friendship is the friendship of men who are
good, and alike in virtue; for these wish well
alike to each other qua good, and they are
good themselves.” EN, VIII, 3.
28/03/2016
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
37
Self-love and Altruism
“It is true of the good man too that he does many acts for the
sake of his friends and his country, and if necessary dies for
them; for he will throw away both wealth and honours and in
general the goods that are objects of competition, gaining for
himself nobility; since he would prefer a short period of
intense pleasure to a long one of mild enjoyment, a
twelvemonth of noble life to many years of humdrum
existence, and one great and noble action to many trivial ones.
Now those who die for others doubtless attain this result; it is
therefore a great prize that they choose for themselves. They
will throw away wealth too on condition that their friends will
gain more; for while a man's friend gains wealth he himself
achieves nobility; he is therefore assigning the greater good to
himself.”
EN, IX, 8
28/03/2016
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
38
Self-love and Altruism, 2
“The same too is true of honour and office; all these
things he will sacrifice to his friend; for this is noble
and laudable for himself. Rightly then is he thought
to be good, since he chooses nobility before all
else. But he may even give up actions to his friend;
it may be nobler to become the cause of his friend's
acting than to act himself. In all the actions,
therefore, that men are praised for, the good man is
seen to assign to himself the greater share in what
is noble. In this sense, then, as has been said, a
man should be a lover of self; but in the sense in
which most men are so, he ought not.”
EN, IX, 8
28/03/2016
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
39
Forgiveness

This, too, is a virtue indispensable for
human flourishing
– In any long-term relationship (friendship,
marriage, etc.), each party will do things that
must be forgiven by the other.
– Long term relationships are necessary to
human flourishing.
– If we cannot forgive, we cannot have
continuing long term relationships
28/03/2016
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
40
Forgiveness:
Excess and Deficiency

Excess: the person who forgives too
easily and too quickly
– may undervalue self
– may underestimate offense

Deficiency: the person who can never
forgive
– may overestimate his or her own importance
– usually lives a life of bitterness and anger
28/03/2016
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
41
Cleverness and Wisdom


The clever person knows the best
means to any possible end.
The wise person knows which ends
are worth striving for.
28/03/2016
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
42
Concluding Evaluation


Virtues are those strengths of
character that enable us to flourish
The virtuous person has practical
wisdom, the ability to know when
and how best to apply these various
moral perspectives.
28/03/2016
(c) Lawrence M. Hinman
43