Transcript Web Security

AAA Services
• Authentication
-
•
Authorization
-
•
Who ?
Management of the user’s identity
What can the user do?
Management of the granted services
Accounting
-
What did the user do?
Logging of activities and auditing
Uses of AAA
• Two modes:
– The character mode access
AAA services are used to control administrative
access such as Telent or Console access to network
devices
– The packet mode access
AAA services are used to manage remote user
network access such as dialup clients or VPN clients
T. A. Yang
Network Security
2
c.f., Alternative methods to AAA
• Examples:
– Password-based authentication
– Challenge-response authentication
• Incomplete access management
– Limited to authentication only
T. A. Yang
Network Security
3
Local vs Centralized Databases
in AAA
Features
Local dB
Centralized dB
In a central
authentication server
(remote to the device)
Location of user data
local on the device
Copies of user data
Multiple copies (one per
device)
Single copy
Scalability
Poor (Given a change,
each copy needs to be
updated.)
Good
Single-point failure ?
Depends (possibly no)
Yes
Recommended ?
Only for very small
networks
Yes (especially for larger
networks)
Network Security
4
T. A. Yang
Authentication Protocols in AAA
• RADIUS vs TACACS+
• RADIUS
–
–
–
–
–
Remote Authentication Dial In User Service
An IETF standard (RFC 2865)
Open source s/w
Interoperability among RADIUS-based products
Client/server authentication btwn a NAS (e.g., a
router) and a RADIUS server
• A shared secret btwn the client and the server
– on UDP (port 1812 for authentication and
authorization; port 1813 for accounting)
T. A. Yang
Network Security
5
RADIUS
T. A. Yang
• RFC 2865 (2000):
http://www.ietf.org/rfc/rfc2865.txt
Network Security
6
The Authenticator field
• Request Authenticator
– The authenticator in the Access-Request packets
– Rqts: The value SHOULD be unpredictable and unique
over the lifetime of a shared secret
• Repetition of a request value in conjunction with the same secret
would permit an attacker to reply with a previously intercepted
response.
• Response Authenticator
– The authenticator in the Access-Accept, Access- Reject,
and Access-Challenge packets
– ResponseAuth =
MD5(Code+ID+Length+RequestAuth+Attributes+Secret)
T. A. Yang
Network Security
7
RADIUS
• http://www.cisco.com/en/US/tech/tk59/technologi
es_tech_note09186a0080094e99.shtml
• Example Clients:
router, switch,
PIX/ASA, VPN3000
• The AccessRequest: contains
username, encrypted
password, NAS IP
address, NAS port
number, and session
information.
T. A. Yang
Network Security
8
RADIUS authentication
• Note: Both authentication and authorization information
are combined in a single Access-Request packet.
• Upon receiving an Access-Request, the RADIUS
server
1. Validates the shared secret
2. Validates the username and password
If not validated, sends an Access-Reject response;
3. Authorizes the user
If authorization fails, sends an Access-Reject response;
Otherwise, sends an Access-Accept response;
T. A. Yang
Network Security
9
Security mechanisms in
RADIUS
• Shared secret btwn the client and the server
• In the Access-Request packet, the password is
encrypted.
MD5 (shared secret + Request Authenticator)
XOR the-first-16-octets-of-the-password
16-octet encrypted password
• Q: How would the RADIUS server authenticate
the encrypted password?
T. A. Yang
Network Security
10
TACACS+
• TACACS: Terminal Access Controller Access Control System
• A Cisco proprietary client/server authentication
protocol
• A shared secret btwn the client & the server
• Can encrypt the entire body of the packet (as
indicated by the flags field)
• On TCP
T. A. Yang
Network Security
11
TACACS+
• http://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-grant-tacacs-02
T. A. Yang
Network Security
12
TACACS+
• Example
interactions:
http://www.cisco.c
om/en/US/tech/tk5
9/technologies_te
ch_note09186a00
80094e99.shtml
T. A. Yang
Network Security
13
TACACS+ vs RADIUS
• Shared:
– Client/server based
– Authentication btwn a NAS and an authentication
server
– Shared secret
• Differences ?
T. A. Yang
Network Security
14
TACACS+ vs RADIUS
source:
http://etutorials.org/Networking/network+management/Part+II+Implementations+on+the+Cisco+Device
s/Chapter+9.+AAA+Accounting/High-Level+Comparison+of+RADIUS+TACACS+and+Diameter/
Criterion
TACACS+
RADIUS
Transport
TCP (reliable; more
overhead)
UDP (unreliable; higher
performance)
Authentication
Can be separated (more
and Authorization flexible)
Combined
Multiprotocol
Support
IP only
Supported (IP, Apple,
NetBIOS, Novell, X.25)
Supports two methods to
Access to Router control the authorization of
CLI Commands router commands on a peruser or per-group basis
Not supported
T. A. Yang
Encryption
Passwords only
Network Security
Packet payload
15