Transcript כותרת מצגת

Doing Business
Reducing Bureaucracy
Background
The 2011 Doing Business report is the eighth in a series of annual
reports benchmarking the regulations that enhance business activity
and those that constrain it. The report presents quantitative indicators
on business regulation and the protection of property rights for 183
economies
Israel's global ranking in 2011 is:
29
The World Bank’s Ranking
Rank
(29)
Dealing with
Licenses
(121)
Starting a
Business
(36)
Procedures
(number)
(5 / 7.8)
25%
Procedures
(number)
(20 / 18)
Registering
Property
(147)
33%
Time (days) 25%
(34 / 33.9)
Time (days) 33%
(235 / 207.3)
Cost
(% of income 25%
per capita)
(4.3 / 40.7)
Cost
(% of income 33%
per capita)
(104 / 723.4)
Min. capital
(% of income 25%
per capita)
(- / 59.6)
Procedures
(number)
(7 / 5.9)
Time (days)
(144 / 58)
Getting
Credit
(6)
33%
33%
Cost
(% of property 33%
value)
(5 / 5.9)
Protecting
Investors
(5)
Paying
Taxes
(82)
Legal Rights
62.5%
Index
(9 / 5.5)
Shareholder 33%
Suits Index
(9 / 5.7)
Credit
Information 37.5%
Index
(5 / 3)
Disclosure
Index
(7 / 5.3)
Payments
(number)
(33 / 29.9)
Trading
Across
Borders (10)
33%
33%
Time (hours) 33%
(235 / 282.1)
Director
Liability Index 33%
(9 / 4.4)
Total tax rate
33%
(% profit)
(31.7 / 47.8)
Investor
Protection
Index
(8.3 / 5.1)
Documents
for export
(number)
(5 / 6.5)
Enforcing
Contracts
(96)
17%
Time for
17%
export (days)
(11 / 23.1)
Cost to export
17%
(US$ per
container)
(670 / 1393)
Documents
for import
(number)
(4 / 7.3)
Procedures
(number)
(35 / 38.1)
Time (days)
(890 / 605.1)
Cost
(% of debt)
(25.3 / 34.7
Closing a
business
(40)
33%
33%
33%
Time (years)
(4 / 2.9)
Cost
(% of estate)
(23 / 15.6)
Recovery rate
(cents on the %100
dollar)
(49.1 / 32.3)
17%
Time for
import (days) 17%
(10 / 25.8)
(Israel/ Average world)
Cost to import
(US$ per
17%
container)
(605 / 1639.8)
Legend:
Leading
Lagging
How do we improve ?
Benefit for the Israeli
economy
Measuring the burden and the
improvement using the SCM
Identify processes which have an
impact on the ease of Doing
Business
Many government agencies
participate in the process
Better Regulation
How ?
Improving
World Bank
rankings
What needs to be done?
 Starting a business
 Property registration




Business Registration
Import Food Products Registration
Medical Tools and Devices Registration
the Standards Institution of Israel (SII)
Adding additional processes,
according to SCM
Doing
Business
Additional
Processes
Phase 1
Additional Processes
Phase 2
Open Discussion
• the Ministries’ roles in reducing bureaucracy..
• How does government prioritize what needs to
be done ?
• How to co-ordinate processes across multiple
agencies?
• Is it necessary to set up a dedicated mechanism
to achieve Better Regulation?
Thank you
A joint effort of all Government offices
 Ministry of Finance
 Ministry of Justice
 Ministry of Trade, Industry & Labor
 Ministry of Interior affairs
 Ministry of Health
 Ministry of Environmental Protection
 Ministry of Agriculture & Rural Development
 Tax Authority
 National Insurance Institute
 Accountant General
Additional partners:
 Chamber of Commerce
 Israel Federation of Independent’s Organizations
 Manufacturers Association of Israel
Mapping the Costs
What is the administrative burden of
regulation?
Costs applicable to businesses and citizens arising from Government’s legislation
and regulation.
The cost of administrative burden for
businesses in Europe is estimated at € 470
billion per year which accounts for 3.5%
of GDP EU
Accordingly, the administrative burden in Israel is estimated at NIS 30 Billion
Standard Cost Model – SCM
SCM
The conventional model for examining the cost of bureaucratic burden
Hours
X
Cost per hour
X
Frequency
X
businesses