Transcript The Moral Point of View

The Moral Point of
View
Lawrence M. Hinman, Ph.D.
University of San Diego
7/7/2015
Director, The Values Institute
©Lawrence M. Hinman
1
Why Study Ethics?


Moral concerns are unavoidable in
life.
Analogy: morality is a lot like
nutrition.
– Principal concern: health
– The role of experts
– Disagreement
7/7/2015
©Lawrence M. Hinman
2
Ethics as an Ongoing
Conversation


Professional discussions of ethical
issues in journals.
We come back to ideas again and
again, finding new meaning in them.
7/7/2015
©Lawrence M. Hinman
3
Ethics and Morality


Morality: first-order set of beliefs and
practices about how to live a good
life
Ethics: a second-order, conscious
reflection on the adequacy of our
moral beliefs.
7/7/2015
©Lawrence M. Hinman
4
Moral Health


The goal of ethical reflection is moral
health.
Thus we seek to determine what will
nourish our moral life and what will
poison it.
7/7/2015
©Lawrence M. Hinman
5
Ethical Inventory

Take the ethical inventory on pp. 8-10
now or on the web at:
– http://ethics.sandiego.edu/ActiveWebSurvey/theory/

.
Return to your answers after
finishing each chapter.
7/7/2015
©Lawrence M. Hinman
6
The Moral Point of View

What makes something a moral
issue?
– Content:
• duties, rights, human welfare, suffering,
character, etc.
– Perspective:
• impartial, compassionate, etc.
7/7/2015
©Lawrence M. Hinman
7
Example: Cheating
Imagine a situation in which you see a
classmate cheating. There are several
elements from a moral point of view:
– Some people are hurt by the cheating
– There is deception in the situation
– Cheating seems to be unfair to those who
don’t cheat
– There are conflicting values—honesty, loyalty,
etc.
– There are questions of character.
7/7/2015
©Lawrence M. Hinman
8
The Language of Moral Concerns

Some philosophers have argued that
moral issues are characterized by a
particular kind of language—terms
such as duty, obligation, right, and
good.
7/7/2015
©Lawrence M. Hinman
9
Impartiality
Many philosophers have argued that
the moral point of view is
characterized by impartiality, that is, I
don’t give my own interest any
special weight.
– Immanuel Kant
– John Stuart Mill
7/7/2015
©Lawrence M. Hinman
10
Compassion


Other philosophers have seen the
origin of the moral life to be in
compassion, feeling for the suffering
of other sentient beings.
Josiah Royce: “Such as that is for
me, so is it for him, nothing less.”
7/7/2015
©Lawrence M. Hinman
11
Universally Binding


Moral obligations, some
philosophers maintain, are
universally binding and that is what
gives them their distinctive
character.
Kant: morality is a matter of
categorical imperatives.
– Distinguish between hypothetical and
categorical imperatives.
7/7/2015
©Lawrence M. Hinman
12
Concern for Character


Philosophers from Aristotle onward
have seen the primary focus of
morality to be character.
Two questions:
– What ought I to do? (Kant and Mill)
– What kind of person ought I to be?
(Aristotle)
7/7/2015
©Lawrence M. Hinman
13
The Focus of Ethics

Ethics as the Evaluation of Other
People’s Behavior
– We are often eager to pass judgment on
others

Ethics as the Search for Meaning and
Value in Our Own Lives
7/7/2015
©Lawrence M. Hinman
14
Ethics as the Evaluation of Other
People’s Behavior






Ethics often used as a weapon
Hypocrisy
Possibility of knowing other people
The right to judge other people
The right to intervene
Judging and caring
7/7/2015
©Lawrence M. Hinman
15
Ethics as the Search for Meaning
and Value in Our Own Lives



Positive focus
Aims at discerning what is good
Emphasizes personal responsibility
for one’s own life
7/7/2015
©Lawrence M. Hinman
16
What to Expect from a Moral
Theory
Functions of theory:
 Describe
 Explain
 Give strength (Stockdale)
 Prescribe
– Open new possibilities
– Wonder
7/7/2015
©Lawrence M. Hinman
17
What to Expect from a Moral
Theory, 2
What is ethics like?
 Physics
– Clear-cut, definitive answers

Engineering
– Several possible ways of doing things,
many ways that are wrong
7/7/2015
©Lawrence M. Hinman
18
The Point of Ethical Reflection

Ethics as the evaluation of other people’s
behavior
– Sources of mistrust about moral judgments
•
•
•
•
•

Hypocrisy
Knowing other people
The right to judge
Judging and intervention
Judging and caring
Ethics as the search for the meaning of
our own lives
7/7/2015
©Lawrence M. Hinman
19
Conclusion:
Ethics & Good Health

Ethics is like nutrition
– One studies bodily health, the other
moral health
– Significant disagreement in both fields
– Still there is a significant common
ground.
7/7/2015
©Lawrence M. Hinman
20